5 ms·
Among my affluent, educated, “liberal” friends, expressions of concern about race have completely replaced concern about poverty. I probably hear more people ta
by rayiner 5y ago
Among my affluent, educated, “liberal” friends, expressions of concern about race have completely replaced concern about poverty. I probably hear more people talking about student loans than poverty—except insofar as that poverty affects non-whites.
The brilliant thing about “equity” is that it refocuses everyone on distribution within a class instead of between classes. “Health equity” means you prioritize people of color over whites when they show up at an under-resourced hospital. But it draws attention away from the disparities between medical resources available in rich communities versus poor ones. Admissions gerrymandering at Princeton may mean that the consultants at McKinsey are more diverse than ever, but they’re all still working on shipping American jobs to China. In theory, of course, one can chew gum and walk at the same time—think about class disparities, and also about racial disparities that exist even after accounting for class. But that’s not the nature of politics. If you split the electorate along one axis (race), it becomes almost impossible to work on issues that require them to orient themselves along another axis (class). And of course 80% of racial inequality is caused by the top 10%, so you’ve kneecapped your ability to achieve the measures that would make the biggest difference.
- bogota 5y agoIt sucks. I have all but stopped talking about any issues. My opinions are no longer wanted or valued in society. Anything someone disagrees with instead of talking about it’s “you are privileged so of course your opinion is wrong”.
- coryrc 5y agoWe need more than one axis to vote with in the US. Mathematically that will only be stable if we eliminate FPTP voting and switch to voting for multiple people for multiple positions. I'm fine with Kshama Sawant being on the Seattle City Council but 49% of voters in that district are disenfranchised. They should be able to band together with others to get a candidate more to their liking.
- drewcoo 5y agoEven an axis can hold more than two points. If something other than D and R were considered viable everywhere, Sawant wouldn't seem like such an outlier. When people are forced to hold their noses and vote for the lesser of two evils, can we really say they are enfranchised? What if those two evils are captured by corporate interests and not the interests of general citizenry?
- uoaei 5y agoThat is an incoherent conception of "equity". I don't really see how you can consider the pursuit of equity not to involve things like opening up otherwise exclusive (e.g. medical treatment) options to under-resourced individuals. Equity is nothing more than the "to each according to their need" half of traditional Marxism. And from what I can tell no one really has a problem with the latter half -- all critiques I've heard focus only on the former.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoYou’re giving a completely unconstrained analysis here. What do you mean by “opening up…under-resources individuals?” If this isn’t happening along racial lines, then I agree. But if it is, then your second paragraph is hypocritical.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> except insofar as that poverty affects non-whites The elephant in the room is that most impoverished people in the US are white but the social narrative is that this is only an issue for minorities.
- foerbert 5y agoIn terms of (only) racial equality, it is actually only an issue for non-whites. That's not factually incorrect. Hence we come back to the OP's point - it's hard to get broad public support for both racial and class issues simultaneously... regardless of how interconnected the problems and possible solutions may be.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoSolving racism is basically child's play compared to solving poverty. There have been some half-hearted attempts in America that never went anywhere. Lumpenproletariat will always exist until we become a post scarcity civilization.
- drekk 5y agoWe are a post-scarcity civilization. We landfill most of our food, and produce enough calories to sustain many multiples of our population. For every homeless person in the US, we have over a dozen empty homes. Poverty is a policy choice. The cruelty is the point. 20% of children on the wealthiest country in the history of the planet do not know where or when they'll get their next meal and that is entirely socially constructed. Americans weren't joking when they said better dead than red. I wish they felt that statement in their bones the way they do in their heads.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> We are a post-scarcity civilization. No, we aren't. Resource remain finite, and less than human desires, which is the definition of scarcity. > Poverty is a policy choice. Yes, but it's a choice because the desperation in the working class produces conditions that enable the elite class to get more of the goods and services they want; the particular distribution of the pain of scarcity may be artificial, but it is designed to deal with real scarcity—people have desires for goods and services, and the tradeoff for maximizing them is other people must be deprived. If we were post-scarcity, the desires of one group would not need sacrifice by another to satisfy. The existence of such a tradeoff defines scarcity.
- silisili 5y ago> The brilliant thing about “equity” is that it refocuses everyone on distribution within a class instead of between classes. This is something I hope is not true, but as more people mention it make me think really is. How sick is it, if true, people are purposely pitting people against each other for the sake of getting away with something. Semi related...I hear a term a lot recently that seems similar...'pulling the ladder up.' Seems most companies who are all in on diversity have all white C levels, often all men. Typical "I got mine." mindset. Seems increasingly those pushing divisive things are those not affected by them.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThe political class (both parties, but republicans in particular) and rich elites are absolutely polarizing the country, discrediting the value of tolerance and education, buying up all media, and aiming people at each other like nuclear missiles instead of promoting the general welfare.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Seems most companies who are all in on diversity Companies that are really all-in on diversity tend to be small and low visibility. Megacorporations that are all in on marketing social virtue of any kind (environmentalism, DEI, whatever) are doing image management that is, for the most part, either unrelated to or directly opposed to the substance of what the company does (not uncommonly, marketing bare minimum legal compliance, and sometimes specific sanctions imposed on the firm for wrongdoing, as virtue.)
- silisili 5y agoThat's a good distinction, thanks. Just looking at two companies recently in the news for their 'white privilege' training pushes...Amex and Coke. Amex - https://ir.americanexpress.com/governance-and-corporate-responsibility/executive-committee-and-directors/default.aspx https://ir.americanexpress.com/governance-and-corporate-resp... Coca Cola - https://craft.co/the-coca-cola-company/executives https://craft.co/the-coca-cola-company/executives Notice how these companies put out such trainings, but never properly diversify or offer to step down themselves. The absolute gall of a 70 year old white rich ceo trying to make their 20 year old barely minimum wage stockperson feel like privileged racist trash is sickening. One wonders if it is to take attention off of their exec level(again, I got mine), or perhaps more conspiracy theorist level...rich people getting everyone else to fight among themselves while income disparity grows and grows. Pretty gross either way.
- TeeMassive 5y agoReminds me of the charts showing a huge spike in media articles talking about racism and diversity right around the time of Occupy Wall Street.
- throwaway7033 5y agoI'm reminded of this cartoon - Introduce them to identity politics (https://imgur.com/gallery/KdeMOdA https://imgur.com/gallery/KdeMOdA).
- babyshake 5y agoThe other aspect about racial equity is it quickly gets into highly subjective territory that often just amplifies existing unconscious biases. You may think that 30 year old men from China and India are sufficiently represented or even over-represented in tech at the expense of people of color, but you may find yourself giving preferential treatment to Carlton from Bel-Air over people from the lower classes or castes of their cultures who don't happen to have the particular appearance that helps sell how diverse your company is on its careers page. And to pre-empt downvotes, of course Carlton is an outlier, I'm just using a pop culture reference to make a point.
- weezin 5y agoThe interesting thing is that for them that makes sense, the poor people are not white on the coast, but for the "fly over states" there is a ton of poor white people with drug addictions and poor education.
- mbg721 5y agoIt doesn't even have to be by state. PA is Philadelphia at one end, Pittsburgh at the other, and Pennsyltucky in between. I sort of do appreciate the novel dismissal of "a ton of poor white people with drug addictions and poor education" as opposed to "a ton of poor white people whose previously-vibrant relationships got mercilessly ploughed over", because that's the exact thing that happened with black neighborhoods.
- weezin 5y agoI don't really get your point, I wouldn't call it a dismissal. Not all areas of white poverty were once "vibrant".
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIt's not just Pennsylvania, it's like that in most states. The further you get from the cities the poorer people get. Of course there are some exceptions like smaller tourist rich towns or oil rich towns like in Montana/Texas/Oklahoma, but those are pretty rare.
- rayiner 5y agoPennsylvania is a good illustration of this. It was a prosperous state that now has lots of problems. Back when it was exporting steel around the world, that kept (mostly white) folks in the middle of the state working, but also the many Black communities in the port cities of Philadelphia and Wilmington (in DE). Globalization destroyed those jobs leaving the highly visible poverty in those cities, but also the less visible poverty in the rest of the state. And my modest assertion is that the racial diversity of the consultants doing that outsourcing doesn’t matter and is besides the point.
- RhysU 5y ago
- bryanlarsen 5y agoContext matters. In my experience, at firms with good salaries the focus is on racial equity because that's the problem they have. At firms paying close to minimum wage, the cause people are focusing on is getting the employer to pay a living wage. I believe you just have more contact with the former than the latter.
- faangiq 5y agoLook man. If Trevor Noah says it’s cool, it’s cool. Don’t rock the boat kemosabe.