3 ms·
> I think SMRs are a response to boondoggle construction projects... This +10 (if I could). Consider orbital-class rockets - another very advanced technology,
by bell-cot 5y ago
> I think SMRs are a response to boondoggle construction projects...
This +10 (if I could).
Consider orbital-class rockets - another very advanced technology, and far less forgiving than nuclear power reactors. How much does it cost to launch (say) 10 tons of satellite on a rocket from plucky upstart SpaceX? Vs. how much did it cost back when only a few bloated "cost plus plus" mega-corporations were providing orbital rockets?
- philipkglass 5y agoOrbital rockets are less forgiving than reactors in that they operate closer to engineering limits even when they work correctly. They are more difficult to make reliable. But they have a far more forgiving-to-neighbors failure mode. When a SpaceX test vehicle explodes only SpaceX is harmed. With reactors you can't start by testing a design that spontaneously disassembles itself and iterate toward a reliable one like the organizations that build rockets have done.
- bell-cot 5y agoWell, true. But since reactors run nowhere nears engineering limits, they need "build, explode, iterate" R&D about as much as they need testing at 5g, or in vacuum. (Yes, I know that destructive testing of many reactor components & sub-systems is quite reasonable.)