5 ms·
I know this will get labeled as whataboutism, so to pre-empt that I am suggesting sanctions and Hague charges for all perpetrators, but what is uniquely bad abo
by whimsicalism 5y ago
I know this will get labeled as whataboutism, so to pre-empt that I am suggesting sanctions and Hague charges for all perpetrators, but what is uniquely bad about killing Ukrainians over Syrians, Libyans, or Iraqis?
- reaperducer 5y agoI haven't seen anyone in this thread, or anywhere else, state that killing Ukrainians is uniquely bad. Do you have a source for this assertion?
- whatshisface 5y agoThey are obliquely complaining that the US gets a free pass to blow up civilians in other countries in the course of pursuing its own geopolitical goals, an by extension the US armed forces are exempt from international prosecution. As for domestic prosecution, the record is mixed, but there was that high-profile case that got a presidential pardon.
- ensan 5y agoThen, if you live in a western country, stop paying taxes because it supports killing innocent people, and to a much larger extent than what is going on in Ukraine. Leave your job because tech companies have contracts with the government/"defense industry" and also pay taxes. Don't buy anything from the grocery stores. Cancel your flight if it's on an Airbus/Boeing. Otherwise, it's all empty talk. To be clear, it absolutely is in my opinion.
- dunkelheit 5y agoIt is kind of crazy when one remembers all the human rights abuses that companies providing popular products and services tolerate and benefit from, and where the tax money goes. It is almost as if if the goal is to be consistent and avoid hypocrisy, the only two options are abandoning modern lifestyle... or not protesting at all.
- mrtranscendence 5y agoWhat specifically is empty talk? Someone can support Ukraine for a number of reasons that don't require withdrawing from all life in a western nation. They might trust that their rulers have evaluated most alternatives before deploying military options and do not kill indiscriminately. You might scoff, but I suspect most people are at least somewhat in that boat; even if they think that the US shouldn't have invaded Iraq, for example, they probably think it wasn't that bad and that murders of civilians were minimal. That doesn't mean that they don't or shouldn't protest the invasion of Ukraine, though it probably does mean that they should reflect further. They might also believe that invading Ukraine is uniquely bad because it is a developed western nation within mainland Europe, setting a terrible precedent. Or they might simply not have thought very much about the contradiction. And I note that you're lumping every western nation under the same category when some are much less objectionable than others; in how many developing nations has Finland engaged in extralegal murder? That said, yes, the costs are lower to protesting the invasion of Ukraine than protesting everything the US government does overseas. So what? The costs are lower for me to buy Kroger brand soft drinks, too, that doesn't mean my opinions about the flavor is just empty talk.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> murders of civilians were minimal. But nobody (AFAIK) is contesting that the US killed more civilians in Iraq or in Syria (or second-order in Libya) than Russia has killed in Ukraine. Your argument is that people perceive it as okay because the intentions were good? Our government could not forsee that these people would die, it was unexpected? Or were they unintended consequences that were foreseen? I don't believe such a distinction is defensible, if you foresee the consequence and do it anyways, you intended such a consequence.
- pessimizer 5y ago> Your argument is that people perceive it as okay because the intentions were good? Even worse, I think the argument is that the intentions were good because it was our rulers who did it, not theirs. Our rulers are careful and thoughtful, while theirs are evil and cruel.
- dunkelheit 5y agoActions speak louder than words and the reaction to the current conflict is certainly unique. I haven't heard of people pressuring companies to stop doing business with the US due to the Iraq war.
- whatshisface 5y agoThe simplest explanation is that US companies + media + government is the only group with enough clout to do this, and they will not sanction themselves. It's not like there's a Netherlands invasion of Germany for us to all use as a neutral reference.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI think you are conflating things here. Sure, US govt is not going to sanction itself. But I don't perceive the general populace as being as outraged by lives lost when the US bombs a hospital in Afghanistan as opposed to when Russia bombs a theater in Ukraine.
- whatshisface 5y agoI would posit that the ratio of the number of people who know about it to the number of people outraged about it is similar in both examples. It's really about which got the 24/7 coverage.
- tomjen3 5y agoAfter ISIS rose I gave up the idea that countries like Syria, Iraq etc can ever become anything more than "hellholes", at least in my lifetime. Certain areas like Kurdistan excepted (and I hope and support their recognization as a state), but in general there will always be one strongman or another. But Ukraine was different (and I hope it still will be), turning from the world of the strongman and toward Europe and modern freedoms. It was on the same trajectory that Poland went on 18 years ago: a massively better life for the average, ordinary person. Ukraine had troubles, but those were solvable because that is what they wanted. All of that is now ground up along with so many children under the ruble in the streets because Putin had to establish a slightly larger state. So when Ukraine was killed, not only was the civilians there massacered, so was the future of the entire country or at least pushed another generation into the future. I hope neither of the perpretators ever make it the Hague, a few years in prison is nowhere near enough punishment.
- whimsicalism 5y agoAll this comment shows to me is you knew very little about Syria & Iraq. The cultural & population centers of Syria were never taken by ISIS and Damascus prior to 2011 would not have felt as "hellhole"-esque as I think you are imagining. > turning from the world of the strongman and toward Europe and modern freedoms Towards Europe, certainly, but also towards nationalism - undoubtedly. It is not a "modern freedom" to ban minority languages from schools and government, restrict regional autonomy, etc.
- geoka9 5y ago> to ban minority languages from schools Please, it's not a ban. The relevant law only applies to state-funded schools and makes sure that students who don't speak Ukrainian gradually learn it over the years and start using it in school: _https://ukrainian-studies.ca/2020/08/01/ukraines-russian-language-secondary-schools-switch-to-ukrainian-language-instruction-a-challenge/ https://ukrainian-studies.ca/2020/08/01/ukraines-russian-lan... If Ukraine hasn't been the target of Russian territorial expansionism, we could argue that this law is overreaching. However Russia had claimed the right to "defend Russian-speaking people" outside of Russia before invading Ukraine in 2014 (the law was passed in 2017). Under these conditions, passing such a law was practically a question of self-preservation.
- def_true_false 5y agoFrom the point of view of American isolationists, there is no difference. There is a difference for Europeans, in that Ukraine being engulfed by a full scale war will result in around 40M refugees in the EU, almost 10% of EU population. That's an order of magnitude bigger than the previous migration wave. It's also an order of magnitude faster. Over 10M people have been displaced already. Some numbers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Ukrainian_refugee_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Ukrainian_refugee_crisis , note the dates.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI think you are reversing causality here. No doubt the EU could have seen similar numbers of refugees from Syria and Iraq and Afghanistan, had they allowed them in.
- def_true_false 5y agoBefore the current crisis, there were >1M Ukrainian workers in Poland, hundreds of thousands in Slovakia, Czechia, etc. The world where Polish, Slovak or Baltic people watch dying Ukrainians through their border fences was never going to exist. The possibility only ever existed in the minds of some confused Americans and maybe western Europeans. German policy in the previous refugee crisis (especially with regard to non-Syrian migrants) literally made the present course the only possible one -- something along the lines of "If we are letting random Africans in, how can we not let the Ukrainians in." is hard to argue with. On the other hand, accepting even less refugees in the previous crisis is something that was definitely (politically) possible at the time.