3 ms·
You pretty much summarise what is wrong with the title. It is not "Protestware" that harms open source. It is politics and ideology harms open source. And the
by ksec 5y ago
You pretty much summarise what is wrong with the title.
It is not "Protestware" that harms open source. It is politics and ideology harms open source.
And the rate things are going may be Open Source will not only be split between permissive and copyleft, but progressive and libreRight.
Edit: Now I remember Douglas Crockford's "The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil." license. I wonder if there are still any open source that uses it.
- XorNot 5y ago"protestware" is just malware. The punchline is: do you understand your supply chain? Can you audit your software? Do you have security controls for potentially hostile packages? This is nothing new: this is a problem which has always existed.
- unethical_ban 5y agoIt isn't ideology, it's malware for political purposes. https://xkcd.com/605/ https://xkcd.com/605/ No, at the rate things are going, OSS will not be as you describe.
- BaronVonSteuben 5y agoThanks for the perspective and the laugh. It's very easy to see a trend that isn't there in an aberration.
- beaconstudios 5y agoyou can't really escape politics and ideology. What you can do, is to not be petty with your public contributions. As the parent example states, while somebody /could/ embed malware into their software that targets Texans, this falls under the pre-existing social doctrine of a "dick move". These things exist on a scale from "exclude government/corporate entities from your software license" to "try to fuck up random people's hard drives" and vary widely in terms of validity.
- BaronVonSteuben 5y agoI think the main problem is that we are increasingly operating with different definitions of "dick move." To many people, the idea that a small business owner would have their store burned to the ground because someone else in their town (or on the other side of their country) did something bad, is a massive dick move. Yet, this happened numerous times during the summer of BLM in 2020 and it was widely defended with things like, "everything is political" and "not to take a side is to take a side" and "you're either with us or you're against us" and "mostly peaceful protests." There was even a famous "looting is reparations" in articles and at least one book called "In Defense of Looting."
- beaconstudios 5y agoIf anybody is defending burning down small businesses as part of BLM, I can promise you they're in the vast minority.
- zucker42 5y ago> It is politics and ideology harms open source. The movement towards free and open source software was created in no small part do to activists with a very strong ideology. Open source would not exist to the same extent without the ideology espoused by the FSF. The problem is that abandoning a key tenant of the free software movement, neutrality towards different uses (part of freedom 0 of the free software definition), does far more harm than good and contravenes FLOSS ideology.
- beaconstudios 5y agoyeah it's kind of ironic to call for "no politics" in a movement that is essentially based in digital anarchism.
- pelasaco 5y agoThat's exactly what I would write here. FLOSS is basically a political movement against the software industry since 1960...
- seneca 5y ago> The movement towards free and open source software was created in no small part do to activists with a very strong ideology. This is true, and an argument that keeps getting repeated, but isn't the same issue. The politics of open source software are about software. How it's made and how it's used. The modern push is about injecting outside ideology into software (and everywhere else). Bringing geo, gender, and racial politics into software is a whole lot different than software politics in software.
- BaronVonSteuben 5y agoEither you or I misread GP, because I don't see any disagreement. GP points out that FLOSS movement was and is inclusive by design, while this modern development is exclusive by design against people who disagree with the person's opinions.
- seneca 5y ago