8 ms·
>I think its important to recognise that quite a lot of modern web based companies are running their business on the 0 cents model. That is they take the margin
by coldtea 5y ago
>I think its important to recognise that quite a lot of modern web based companies are running their business on the 0 cents model. That is they take the marginal cost of a customer and push it down to zero and rely on scale to make a profit from it.
Well, that's their problem.
There should absolutely be a "right to speak with a human", like a restaurant must pass health inspections, and other such things.
If they can't afford it as a basic cost of doing business, they can always close.
- dmd 5y agoHow do you define "web based company"? If I slap together a 50 line program in a few minutes and offer it on my personal domain for anyone to use, do I have to publish my phone number for anyone to call if they have a problem with it someday?
- rkangel 5y agoI would probably use the word "service" and I specifically don't mean "web based service". If someone is providing a service (for money?) then you should have the right to speak to a human about issues with your service. That seems reasonable to me.
- dmd 5y agoBut people are specifically saying it doesn't have to be for money. If I've made some open source tool that people use for free, do I really need to provide phone support - also for free?
- rkangel 5y agoYou're not providing a service though are you? You're providing intellectual property for people to do things with.
- dmd 5y agoAnd if I throw an instance of it up on my web server that runs on a raspberry pi next to the cat litter in my basement? Now do I need to provide phone support to the world?
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoMinimum headcount requirement would render this irrelevant, and make sense in the spirit of the regulation.
- sokoloff 5y agoIf that is important to you, what prevents you from only doing business with companies who will operate on terms you find agreeable? Is it necessary to force others to avoid low-touch, low-cost companies/services that they appear to be perfectly happy with?
- rkangel 5y agoThe varying answers to this are effectively political positions. I would suggest that in this case (like in several others) competition is insufficient to guarantee that I have that choice. If I have a GSuite account, but I think that Google's support is rubbish who else can I go to that provides a similar level of service? To use another example - there are various consumer protection laws in the UK and EU. They cover all sorts of things like guaranteeing safety standards and requiring companies to accept returns. They have arisen over time to cover situations where consumers aren't capable of making the decision (e.g. safety which is complex or you might not find out for 10 years) or it's not something companies compete on but it's something you want for customers (e.g. returns). Different political approaches, such as the more liberal one in the US leaves it more up to competition, the idea being that competition provides for consumers and it's easier to grow and operate businesses so the economy flourishes and everyone does well that way. I'd suggest that it's not a perfect system and that you have to fill in the gaps. This is why America is rediscovering the union - in theory companies compete for the job market. If one job is incredibly shitty then employees can leave and get another one. This should provide competitive advantage to companies to make jobs non shitty and companies that don't can't hire and die out. In practice, for reasons that I don't fully understand, that hasn't worked out. Covid has been a trigger for some movement here and therefore some pressure, but it hasn't solved all the problems. Instead an alternate approach can work where employees can bargain collectively.
- sokoloff 5y agoIf no one offers GSuite or a similar competitor to you under terms that you find acceptable, do you have a right to demand that they offer “just like GSuite, only with an additional telephone hotline”? For me, that answer is a clear no, in that you are not (and should not be) guaranteed that the market provides you such a choice nor does it offer you the choice to deny others the freedom to choose GSuite as it sits today in features and pricing.
- pempem 5y agoIf you slap together 50 lines of code, can you attempt a valuation and get funding for it? :shrug: Are you 'side hustling' to make money and thus having customers?
- dmd 5y agoWhat's a customer? I don't charge money, but neither does Google. Where is the line drawn?
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoooo good point. Like if you have Google ads running on your page generating trivial income, yes it would become more challenging to define a customer. I think this would probably be addressed in a minimum size (headcount) before the regulation is required, which makes sense because the problem is businesses scaling their customer base and scope beyond their physical resources.
- pempem 5y agoGenerally if you're making money off of me or if I'm giving money in exchange for services - customer. Here are some real world examples that would hold up pre-current state: Club: even if I dont pay for a beverage or cover, I am in fact a customer. Shown by the fact that if I get injured at said club, or other events occur the responsible parties are managing/own the club. Print shop: Go into a shop, pay for a thing or service, are a customer. There was a time, that many of us can remember, where automated phone services were nascent, there was no IVR and there was definitely no complex intent recognition paired with sentiment analysis. The smallest little business needed a phone. When it rang, they answered it. Those businesses afforded it and frankly the min. wage has barely gone up since then so a business, one that exchanges a service/place/goods/my information for money, can afford to do it. I am in full agreement with my perception of OP's comment.
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoI hear you, and you're point seems logical to me. However, would this not put an end to the public web as we know it? Specifically self-hosting. What do you think about implementing this with a minimum organization size? I just do not see this same problem happening with small firms, generally they are easy to get in touch with. I wouldn't want them regulated unless the nature of the problem changed.
- fao_ 5y ago> If they can't afford it as a basic cost of doing business, they can always close. This 100%. It reminds me of the similar issue of zero-hour contracts and living wages. One person I know complained that putting restrictions on zero hour contacts, and upping the amount that he would have to pay workers, would mean he couldn't hire any (for his extremely early-stage startup with no investment(!)). In a similar vein, the answer is the same -- if you can't afford to pay employees, don't hire them. And this applies more generally than either of our examples -- if a company cannot afford to do something ethically, then it shouldn't do it at all. A business that cannot survive when forced to comply with the bare minimum of ethical practices deserves to fail. You cannot simultaneously believe in a capitalist market without embracing with open arms, the failure of companies that couldn't stick it.
- SomeCallMeTim 5y agoBut you can comply with ethical business practices without hiring employees to deal with hundreds of thousands of callers. Automated moderation is a thing, and actually responding to support tickets instead of ignoring them is also a thing. I think you underestimate how many services you rely on that wouldn't be able to survive with a legal requirement that they were required to take calls from any human that wanted to contact them. Presumably those services are useful to you and you wouldn't want them to be closed down, yes? And similarly, you wouldn't want to be paying the $50-100/month for each service that would likely be required if every single one had to support a fully-staffed call center to deal with not only customers but potentially affected non-customers (as in the Giphy example in the parallel comment thread).
- thfuran 5y ago>the $50-100/month for each service that would likely be required if every single one had to support a fully-staffed call center You're estimating what, that every customer would on average spend at at least an hour a month on the phone with each and every service they do business with?
- SomeCallMeTim 5y ago
- ChefboyOG 5y agoA "right to speak with a human" makes sense to me on an industry-by-industry basis, in the same way that construction companies and restaurants have different regulatory agencies and checks. Applying it to all businesses sounds like a bad idea, however. Financial institutions? Certainly. Healthcare companies? Makes all kinds of sense. But I don't see an ethical imperative for, say, Giphy (pre-acquisition) to provide that kind of support.
- BoppreH 5y ago> But I don't see an ethical imperative for, say, Giphy (pre-acquisition) to provide that kind of support. Giphy hosts user-generated content and encourages sharing. Imagine someone uploads a gif of you and fake subtitles of racial slurs and calls to violence. It starts trending. Your friends and families are asking you about it. You've submitted a request to remove it, but got no response yet. You can't get hold of any human at Giphy. You get a call from your company's HR. Giphy definitely needs human customer support.
- lghh 5y agoHas this actually happened? Additionally, you are not a customer of giphy. So now giphy has to reasonably have the amount of human customer support for non-customers? So, essentially everyone on earth?
- BoppreH 5y agoThe scenario above was fictitious, but people need content removed all the time. Here's an article [1] from The Guardian about Pornhub being slow to remove revenge porn and CSAM. And in this thread you'll find a business owner trying to remove a bad faith review. Yes, you'll need more staff depending on your business' impact on people's lives, regardless if they are "customers" or not. If you have so many complaints you can't pay enough people to deal with it, you should not be in business. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/dec/16/pornhub-untold-damage-pain https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/dec/16/pornhu...
- 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> There should absolutely be a "right to speak with a human", like a restaurant must pass health inspections, and other such things. > If they can't afford it as a basic cost of doing business, they can always close. If you're not paying for a service, are you even really a customer? Hacker News is free. Do you really expect to be able to pick up the phone and call someone at Y Combinator to discuss your Hacker News account? Do you really think it's a good idea to make this a legal right? Or how about GitHub? If they were obligated to provide phone support to anyone with an account, their only option would be to disable all free accounts. If you wanted to use GitHub, you'd have to get a paid account. The whole idea is ridiculous. Unless you want most of the free internet to disappear completely (or move overseas) then it's a non-starter.
- pempem 5y agoI think we can presume the author means: goods/services I have exchanged funds for. Additionally I would point out that Gmail makes plenty of money off our data and we all have written about or thought about how 'users are the product'. Not sure why there's seemingly a heightened emotional response here.
- msla 5y agoThere's always an answer. If you don't pay for it: "You're not the customer, you're the product." If you do pay for it: "You get what you pay for." If you pay for it and have a contract specifying you will get it: "Not worth taking it to court." If you do take it to court: "We must stop all these frivolous lawsuits!" There is always an answer.
- throwbigdata 5y agoRespectfully, you’re begging the question that it would be frivolous. If the contract says they must have a human respond within so much time and the company fails to do that, the lawsuit would not be frivolous to a rational person.
- 5y ago
- rpdillon 5y agoI think a better requirement (that is, more likely to achieve the desired result) may be to make it clear on signup that there will be no human support provided. I suspect this would be enough to allow customers to make an informed decision, so that folks that value real support can choose companies that provide it. Today, I can sign up for a service online and only find out in my moment of need that there's no hope of getting help from a real person. But perhaps people would still just choose the cheapest option regardless.
- raelmebrand 5y ago> If they can't afford it as a basic cost of doing business, they can always close. Why do you choose such a company to do business with at the first place? > Part of me thinks (perhaps naively) if I had the ability to speak with a real person over the phone, we could sort this out instead of constant emails or creating tickets that go into a black hole. As more companies outsource, automate, or severely cut their customer service department, there needs to be some kind of pressure to stop these frustrating experiences from happening. Look at Dell or HP customer service. Google, Github or Digital ocean will become the same. Yes, you will never get the product designer or systems or devops engineer from those companies. The customer service will repeat the same thing million times over. (I lost Apple account, and unlike Google, I could reach Apple but they just repeated the same thing. (i.e) password is wrong; not our problem). Also note that if there is direct connection to devops or dev, people ask silly questions to waste time. (i.e) These companies pay just $5000 per year to run their entire business with profits 100X and expect $10,000 per month DevOps will troubleshoot their problems. > Voting with our dollars doesn't work when these companies are so integrated with our lives. Example please. As long as it is not w e a p o n s all is wide open market.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoThe problem is companies compete and the ones that reduce their costs for support drive the other ones out of business. This has evolved to the stage where it's endemic in what used to be well functioning societies, that day to day civic economic interactions are now broken, which is what the posted talked about. The answer is regulating to avoid this race to the buttom.
- xeromal 5y agoI agree with you, but it does make me wonder what the outcome would be like? What goes away? I genuinely don't know.