3 ms·
There's certainly a lot of hate for Mozilla based on the specious argument that actively trying to deny other people the right to marry the person they love isn
by DonHopkins 5y ago
There's certainly a lot of hate for Mozilla based on the specious argument that actively trying to deny other people the right to marry the person they love isn't hate.
That's a pretty lazy and entitled argument to make when you're not on the receiving end of Brendan Eich's irrational homophobia and attempted sabotaging of your own marriage.
The word "hate" having too many meanings isn't a problem. People trying to deny other people's humanity and human right to marry the person they love is a problem, whatever word you choose to label it with.
- sph 5y agoWhile I agree on the principle of same-sex marriage and people should be able to do and love whoever they want, > People trying to deny other people's humanity why was Proposition 8, the proposal to ban same-sex marriage, a referendum, if by your standards one choice is good and the other is denying other people's humanity? What is the point of democracy and referendums if one possible answer is deemed incorrect and inhumane a priori? That said, I think we're straying too far off topic, and I usually am one that hates when any discussion about Mozilla or Brave touches on Eich's controversy. So I will stop now.
- DonHopkins 5y agoFor the same reason legalizing slavery should not be up to a referendum, and "states rights" don't include the right to deny other people's humanity by legalizing owning another human being as property. If you will recall, the United States fought a bloody war about that, and the traitors on the pro-slavery side lost. And I'll remind you that the US Supreme Court already strongly affirmed that human rights are not up for a vote, when it legalized same sex marriage. https://whyy.org/articles/supreme-court-affirms-my-human-rights-are-not-up-for-a-vote/ https://whyy.org/articles/supreme-court-affirms-my-human-rig... >Supreme Court affirms my human rights are not up for a vote >Human rights should never be subjected to a popular vote. The will of the people does not matter in the slightest. The Supreme Court did not give LGBT citizens anything today. Countries merely recognize the rights that already exist, and protect them. >“…the right to marry is a fundamental right inherent in the liberty of the person, and under the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment couples of the same-sex may not be deprived of that right and that liberty. The Court now holds that same-sex couples may exercise the fundamental right to marry. No longer may this liberty be denied to them.” -Justice Anthony Kennedy >Human rights do not stem from the will of the majority in any nation. Ayn Rand (even a broken clock is right twice a day) said, “…individual rights are not subject to a public vote; a majority has no right to vote away the rights of a minority; the political function of rights is precisely to protect minorities from oppression by majorities.” If this is true, the inverse is also true; a majority has no right to permit or grant the rights of a minority. You yourself just admitted that "I usually am one that hates when any discussion about Mozilla or Brave touches on Eich's controversy", after complaining that hate has too many definitions. With such a low bar for hatred, which you admit to yourself, how can you at the same time deny that Brendan's dehumanizing homophobic anti-human-rights beliefs aren't hateful? Your hatred of discussions about Brendan's beliefs doesn't ruin people's lives or deny their humanity. But Brendan's hateful beliefs about same sex marriage do ruin people's lives and deny their humanity. So why don't you just stop hating those discussions, and learn to tolerate free speech? And why doesn't Brendan Eich simply stop hating gays, and tolerate same sex marriages, which the Supreme Court has affirmed is a "fundamental right inherent in the liberty of the person"? Isn't it ironic that so many of the same people who attempt to raise the goalposts so high by redefining "hate" to not include denying another person's basic human rights as hatred, also claim to hate Mozilla so much? Why is Brendan Eich voluntarily deciding to cancel himself by resigning from Mozilla of his own free will so much more of an atrocity to some bigots than Brendan denying other human beings against their will the simple universal human right to marry the person they love?