3 ms·
> Is Mozilla relevant anymore? Despite the Mozilla leadership and the at times questionable investments, Firefox could never be more relevant. We need a non-C
by echelon 5y ago
> Is Mozilla relevant anymore?
Despite the Mozilla leadership and the at times questionable investments, Firefox could never be more relevant.
We need a non-Chrome browser just as we need multiple operating systems with different design paradigms. It gives us flexibility, increased surface area for experimentation, and acts as an anchor for web standards (at least as long as non-Chrome browser share remains).
If running instructions should be free, so should reading information. Even if Chromium is itself open source, Firefox (and mostly Safari) keep Chrome from turning into a thin client that bakes in Google's self interested designs for the web.
I think Mozilla corporation should be acquired or merge with Canonical, Framework, or some other open-minded computing company. The leadership should build a strong "complete package" offering: laptop, phone, operating system, browser. That makes more sense to me than continued investments into weird side projects with little chance of developing traction.
And by weird side projects, I don't mean their efforts in VR or discontinued efforts in TTS. I think building open platforms in these domains makes a lot of sense. I just don't know if Mozilla should be the folks to do it. Their core mission - web - should be their singular focus.
The absolute best thing Mozilla could do, though, is spend money on marketing and partnerships to improve Firefox adoption and stem the losses. After they get growth back, the next thing to do is to develop stable, sensible revenue streams. The browser has become a commodity, which is why I think premium hardware sales could do the trick. Especially if it's "ethical" open hardware.
nrp (Framework founder's HN username), you should go have a chat with Mozilla folks sometime. Now isn't the time to consider an acquisition, but after you achieve growth and scale - please buy them out. Tout them as part of your offering, and use them as an additional funnel to drive Framework hardware sales.
- encryptluks2 5y agoThey already do spend a lot of money on marketing. The issue is they spend a lot of money to market that they value privacy and then their actions show otherwise. I also think having Canonical aquire them would be a terrible decision. They need to spend less money on marketing and more on developing what they claim to support.
- wolverine876 5y agoHow much do they spend on marketing? > market that they value privacy and then their actions show otherwise Which actions?
- fwn 5y agoI can't speak for the user posting earlier and I don't know anything about the Mozilla marketing budget, but: On the android platform Mozilla removed all extension sideloading capabilities. Even their store extensions are now almost entirely off-limits for the user unless they create a Firefox account and link it to their device through some extension list ID. The former just feels like an evil powergrab, the latter feels like a privacy reducing growth hack. I really want Firefox to be great and do use it on all platforms, but many recent decisions regarding their products are not great. In addition to that it seems that their toxic culture does appear to leave its mark on the brand.
- encryptluks2 5y ago> Mozilla’s marketing budget is between $20 million and $100 million https://digiday.com/marketing/after-mozilla-stopped-spending-on-facebook-the-company-increased-its-focus-on-offline-marketing/ https://digiday.com/marketing/after-mozilla-stopped-spending... Sadly, they mention here their Manifesto which states: https://wiki.mozilla.org/MarketingGuide https://wiki.mozilla.org/MarketingGuide > Individuals’ security and privacy on the internet are fundamental and must not be treated as optional. However, if you look at what settings are enabled by default and with the recent announcement of them tracking installs and downloads, they are no better than Chromium.
- throwmeariver1 5y agoFirefox is irrelevant with a marketshare of 7% and it's not needed. What is needed is a true competitor for Chrome not a long forgotten fever dream.
- rhdunn 5y agoHow would such a competitor be created and work? How would they gain sufficient market share? How do they gain influence in the standards organisations to push for changes they want instead of what Google wants? If such a competitor were to use Chromium/Blink, how do they differentiate from the other browsers? How do they avoid changes that Google push into Chromium/Blink that they don't want? Where do they get the resources to develop standards they want to support like MathML or several of the CSS drafts? If such a competitor were to create their own web stack, where do they get the resources and time to build the HTML, CSS, and JavaScript to a level that is competitive?
- throwmeariver1 5y agoThat's for anyone who wants to join the browser game to figure out. Mozilla is going downhill fast so everyone clinging to it is just delaying the inevitable. The new winning browser is either going to be a forked or new engine it certainly is not going to be Gecko with the Mozilla Foundation at the helm. It's just stupid to pretend that there is hope for Mozilla or Firefox if there is no purge at the top.
- account42 5y agoI think Canonical would be the second last "open source" organization (after Mozilla) that I would want in charge of Firefox development. They are almost as hostile to running an open source project rather than an (open source) product as Moz corp.