3 ms·
>First, the lack of skin in the game leads to very poor participant behavior. is there a reason why they can't require some amount of money down (eg. a few tho
by gruez 5y ago
>First, the lack of skin in the game leads to very poor participant behavior.
is there a reason why they can't require some amount of money down (eg. a few thousand dollars), or does that go against the ISA philosophy?
- eropple 5y agoMy understanding is that a lot of the folks you'd want to target for something like this don't have appreciable funds to put down in the first place.
- majormajor 5y agoPlans like these are generally intended to help precisely those people who don't have a few thousand dollars lying around. (Heck, even many traditional students taking out loans would be hard pressed to put a few thousand dollars down instead of taking out a student loan. That's a lot of money to most people in the US.)
- ratzkewatzke 5y agoI think that the explanation about credit scores probably applies here; much as people with good credit scores had better options than ISAs, people with some cash to put up do as well.
- cribbles 5y agoBack in 2015, when this type of thing was still novel, I participated in an ISA program that required a $3,000 deposit. It was refundable if you failed a (demonstrably) good-faith effort to applying for jobs, or rolled into the payment once you landed one. This was a substantial amount of money for me at that time, but I probably wouldn't have applied for the program had it not been for the ISA. I was unwilling to take on new debt, and I didn't have enough money for an upfront payment. The deposit seemed like a reasonable expenditure to save toward precisely because the ISA showed that the program itself had skin-in-the-game.
- brimble 5y ago"A few thousand dollars" is an absolute shitload of money to most people who aren't riding the computer programming bubble, and especially young people. It may as well be $50,000 for how hard it would be for them to come up with without taking out a loan, the same way I'm not any more likely to be able to jump 20 feet in the air than I am to be able to jump to the moon. I haven't had to count pennies at the gas pump rather than just filling it up all the way every time, or keep a running tally of what's going into my grocery cart, in many years, but I remember what it was like. $1,000 was a fuckton of money at the time. An unexpected bill for a couple hundred dollars might ruin my whole month, and maybe the next one too.
- twblalock 5y agoPeople who can put money down generally have access to other, more traditional loans (or don't need loans at all).