3 ms·
First, because Russia certainly has the potential to be winning. Russia could still wind up with air superiority unless Ukraine is very, very careful. Somethi
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
First, because Russia certainly has the potential to be winning. Russia could still wind up with air superiority unless Ukraine is very, very careful. Something could happen to motivate the Russian troops. Putin could decide to start using tactical nukes. So it seems really unwise to assume that things are going to keep going as well as they have. There's a fear that the other shoe could drop and it all turns into a disaster.
Also, Ukraine is "winning" by not having been totally overrun. They may not be winning in terms of total casualty counts. (They probably are winning in terms of total armor destroyed.) They are currently losing in terms of territory taken - not nearly as badly as we feared they would be, but they are in fact losing. (The fact that they're only losing a little bit counts as a major win against the expected outcome, though.)
So all in all, it's fine to say "things are on an optimistic trajectory" or some such. "Winning" seems a bit too strong, though.
- dane-pgp 5y agoThat's a fair analysis. The author even admits: > the war is not over, and that the weight of numbers still favors Russia. Is there going to be some phase transition at some point where one or other side runs out of some critical resource like tanks or soldiers or money? What is the weakest link in their war machines, and how close is each side to having that link broken?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThe "phase transition" might be when Russia's supply situation goes critical. Yesterday I saw a claim that it would happen in three days, so Friday. Is that claim correct? I hope so, and it sounds reasonable... but I don't know.