4 ms·
People I know who were recently unable to buy houses in California include a long-time staff engineer at Google and a heart surgeon married to a brain surgeon.
by jeffbee 5y ago
People I know who were recently unable to buy houses in California include a long-time staff engineer at Google and a heart surgeon married to a brain surgeon. I know this data is nationwide but the crisis in California has become so acute that even people with 98th-percentile incomes are looking around and saying how fucked up everything is.
- twox2 5y agoWhy is everyone so obsessed with buying a house. Why is that the measure of quality of life to strive towards?
- lkxijlewlf 5y agoIt would be preferable to own a home in retirement so that if all else goes to shit, you have a roof over your head.
- sjg007 5y agoIt's basically a hedge against rent and cost of living. In many markets rent is now higher than a mortgage. The goal is you are over a lifetime net-zero in housing cost or maybe make something back. Flippers and builders usually make 30% b/c they have cost advantages.
- twox2 5y agoIs rent really higher than a mortgage though or does that fail to take into consideration things like taxes, HOA, etc.? If rent were higher than a mortgage, wouldn't that suggest that most of the tech folks CAN in fact afford property in these markets?
- reducesuffering 5y agoRent is usually simultaneously lower than the extras-included mortgage payment but higher than the net worth hit. A Bay Area $1m home might rent for $4k, have a $6k mortgage new, but only drain your net worth $2k. (because of $ towards principal, housing appreciation/inflation, tax deductions, etc.)
- sjg007 5y agoNo, not if you don't have the downpayment.
- newaccount2021 5y agonice dodge. why not tackle head-on the brutal reality that even very-well-paid individuals can no longer afford to purchase a dwelling in the same city they work in? we're moving from a 99/1 economy to a 99.99/0.01 economy
- twox2 5y agoIt's not a dodge, it's a genuine question. The same tech bro's crying that they can't afford to own a house in SF can comfortably afford the rent, so what's the big deal?
- randomdata 5y agoThe significant rise in price of housing has left people who own housing a whole lot richer, at least on paper. Those who don't own housing want to also become rich and they see emulation as the way to achieve that. Case in point: Ten years ago I pointed some people living in the higher cost big city complaining about the high cost of housing in the city to a home for sale in a small town for $80,000; something they considered cheap. At the time the prices were stagnant, though. Their response: "Why would I want to own that? That would be awful." A similar home in the same neighbourhood just sold for $436,000 after two days on the market. Now that price is rising, making it look like a way to get rich, everyone suddenly wants to own it. It is still every bit as awful to own the house, but the quest for riches offsets that. Should housing lose its ability to make people rich, interest will quickly wane. People will move on to the next get rich quick scheme.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoSome people value security and independence. Owning provides both of these and renting does not.
- Workaccount2 5y agoUnable to buy a house, or unable to buy the house someone in their position 10 years ago could buy?
- jeffbee 5y agoI'm sure they'll both eventually find houses but given a certain size family and desire to not move away from current schools and work, inventory is in the single digits. One of these people has been consistently outbid on offers even though they are offering well above list prices, the other had to walk away from their most recent offer after the seller demanded another half million dollars on top of an all-cash, no-contingency offer that was half a million above asking. Incumbent land speculators are taking literally all of the money out of the California economy.
- colinmhayes 5y agoLVT now!
- sjg007 5y agoThey will be well positioned to buy however when prices collapse.
- paulpauper 5y ago"when" People have been predicting this for a decade. Crashes are rare. Events like 2006 are much rarer than media hype would suggest.
- sjg007 5y agoIt is the running joke...
- dam_broke_it 5y agoPrices in Sunnyvale went down a fair bit in 2001/2002.
- paulpauper 5y agoThey have to either be horrible at managing money or have other expenses or are being impractical. I am sure a 200-500k salary is enough to buy a decent home almost anywhere in California. Just run the numbers. "According to website HowMuch.net, your household needs to make roughly $95,000 a year to be able to afford the median home in L.A. which they value at around $480,000."
- jeffbee 5y agoYes, their personal habits are so awful that they are out on the market making all-cash offers for $3 million. Give me a break. To illustrate how out of touch someone like you who obviously lives in a house bought by some other person is, please consider that the actual median home price in L.A. is $950k, double what you mentioned, while the actual median household income is $65,290, only a fraction of what you cited.
- mrep 5y agoWhat is their search criteria because I just pulled up zillow and found hundreds of houses under $3 million. Do they need like 10 bedrooms?
- kube-system 5y agoCalifornia, and especially the bay area, has been in housing crisis for most of my adult life. A 98th percentile income doesn't give you much buying leverage if you're only competing with other people in the 98th percentile (or higher).
- rhexs 5y agoIf a heart and brain surgeon can’t afford a house in California, they need to look at their spending. Are they trying to qualify for a 20 million dollar mortgage or what? That’s an absurd anecdote.
- dam_broke_it 5y ago1 million over asking would make anyone blanche....
- reducesuffering 5y agoIt is absurd. Bay Area prices are far too high, but there are still many suburbs in Bay Area proper that are $6k/mth payments. With current 1.5% 30-year mortgage premiums over 10-year treasury rates, you're effectively only paying (1.5% * mortgage) per month + property tax, because most of that money is saved going into principal of the house loan and the house price keeping with inflation. So net worth wise, you're only wasting around $2k/mth to live there... (out of a $30k/mth after-tax making staff engineer, and assuredly a $35k+/mth after-tax making surgeon couple) Of course, if you're too uppity to live in places like San Leandro, that's a you problem.
- spacemadness 5y agoIt makes me physically ill seeing what houses have gone for in the bay after all the bids are in. A couple I know have been searching for a year and they’ve been consistently outbid by people offering 40% over ask which is obnoxious.