4 ms·
> It's really a good sign that these things keep outliving their specified life > span, though I also would assume that NASA's life span quotes are > probab
by dotancohen 5y ago
> It's really a good sign that these things keep outliving their specified life
> span, though I also would assume that NASA's life span quotes are
> probably conservative to avoid the political fallout of "failure."
Cart before the horse.
NASA designates a science goal, which often includes a detailed plan of what to explore. The administration designates a cost budget, a time budget, and a mass budget. These specs then get sent to engineers (at e.g. JPL) who do the best they can to achieve the science goal within the cost, time, and mass constraints. Sometimes they can build a craft that will outlive its initial 90-day science mission by 14 years. Often that is because they got lucky with conditions, i.e. wind cleaning dust off solar panels.
In no case have they built a craft with no specific goal, then declared it's operational life expectancy, and then went and found a mission to do with it.
- lmm 5y ago> In no case have they built a craft with no specific goal, then declared it's operational life expectancy, and then went and found a mission to do with it. What about the SLS?
- dotancohen 5y agoI concede! SLS, the jobs program, was certainly in need of a scientific mission.
- krisoft 5y ago> In no case have they built a craft with no specific goal, then declared it's operational life expectancy, and then went and found a mission to do with it. I don't think the message you responded to said that they built the craft then declared the operational life expectancy. NASA could have designated a science goal which needed 22 flights, and had the same cost, time and mass budget associated with it. Clearly that goal would have been achievable with some probability given that it was achieved. They didn't. The comment in question is speculating about the reasons why NASA might have chosen 5 flight as the target instead of 22 or 222.
- bdamm 5y agoIt's not the case that they could guarantee 22 flights for the same cost, time, and mass budget. We only know that this design worked after the fact, they didn't have that information in advance. Also, this design may only have achieved 22 flights by pure luck; maybe radiation hasn't struck a key microchip yet, or maybe the dust hasn't degraded the rotor motors as much as expected because there hasn't been as much dust as expected.
- vikingerik 5y agoRegarding that last, there have been at least two cases where a secondary mission was added later, after launch. Pioneer 11 was launched for Jupiter, then retargeted during flight to slingshot to Saturn too. And New Horizons was launched for Pluto, then retargeted during flight to encounter a particular Kuiper Belt object (which hadn't even been discovered at launch.)
- dotancohen 5y agoYes, far more than two cases. I specifically reference Opportunity. And sometimes the hardware continues working fine but there is no budget for secondary missions.