3 ms·
That article is just fud. OpenJDK any version is free to use for whatever reason, period. If you use OracleJDK (which is pretty identical so unless you need su
by kaba0 5y ago
That article is just fud. OpenJDK any version is free to use for whatever reason, period.
If you use OracleJDK (which is pretty identical so unless you need support, go with OpenJDK), then you previously had to pay, but Oracle recently made the last version of it free to use. I mean, it really can’t get easier and freer. It is the same model as with Red Hat linux and fedora, hell, it is even more permissive as you can use the latest Red Hat version free of charge until the next one comes around (+1 year)
- belter 5y agoWhen a company Licensing is so complicated, that there are whole companies whose business case, is to help you negotiate with Oracle, it should make for pause and caution: "Oracle Java Release 17 Is it Free Again?" https://www.softwareone.com/en/blog/all-articles/2021/09/20/oracle-java-release-17 https://www.softwareone.com/en/blog/all-articles/2021/09/20/...
- cogman10 5y agoThe company licensing around OracleJDK is complicated. OpenJDK remains licensed under GPL. The only thing complicated here is that people seem to think that OracleJDK IS OpenJDK, it is not nor has it ever been. OracleJDK is no different than Azul's JDK. It's a JDK vendored and supported by Oracle. The long and short answer is, so long as you are using a JDK vendored by your operating system or a docker image that doesn't explicitly say "oracle jdk" you are and continue to be safe. There's no sneak lawyer trap that's going to spring. I've seen these claims ever since oracle bought sun and have yet to see oracle act in bad faith with their sun acquired open source software.
- belter 5y agoThis is the long version, regularly updated over the years. "Java Is Still Free 3.0.0 (Oct 2021)": https://medium.com/@javachampions/java-is-still-free-3-0-0-ocrt-2021-bca75c88d23b https://medium.com/@javachampions/java-is-still-free-3-0-0-o...
- bitcharmer 5y ago> That article is just fud. OpenJDK any version is free to use for whatever reason, period It literally says that in the very article you claim to be FUD. Have you even bothered to read it? Because it says everything that you did.
- kitd 5y agoYou've just done the same. The article is referring to Oracle JDK. OP was referring to Open JDK.
- bitcharmer 5y agoThe article literally says organizations are moving from Oracle JDK to OpenJDK.
- nathell 5y agoFrom HN guidelines: > Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
- galaxyLogic 5y agoThat's a great guide-line. I guess it could be generalized to "Don't refer to other commenters, only to the content of their posts".
- layer8 5y agoNote that, confusingly, there is a difference between “Oracle JDK” and “Oracle OpenJDK”. The latter has no restrictions, but only receives updates for six months (until the next major version). Oracle has a FAQ here: https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/javase/jdk-faqs.html https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/javase/jdk-faqs.htm...
- ComputerGuru 5y agoFirst, you are muddying things because it’s not a product called OracleJDK vs a product called OpenJDK, it’s “Oracle’s download called (the) JDK” vs “a different download that can only legally be called OpenJDK.” More on that below. It’s also more confusing than you indicate because you are excluding all historical context. The “regular” JDK everyone installed up until Java 8 was the “JDK downloaded from Oracle” and the open source OpenJDK was, for lack of better words, a knock-off with poor compatibility with a lot of enterprise software but used because you couldn’t include JDK in your distro’s package manager (even though it was completely free to use) because the license wasn’t GPL compatible. So everyone that cared about vendor-approved compatibility downloaded “the JDK” from Oracle as a tarball and used that. Those that were running home software could get away with using “apt install openjdk” instead. After Java 8, Oracle pulled a huge switcheroo and said everyone should use OpenJDK instead, and their licensed customers could use the Oracle-provided JDK instead. They didn’t put it behind a paywall or even login, and left it available for free. So if you missed the bit about OpenJDK being officially blessed to use or you continued to just go to Oracle.com to download “the JDK” for commercial use, you were now in violation. Some say Oracle licensing is never confusing by accident and the official recommendation to switch to a previously inferior alternative wasn’t a charitable move. If you don’t know OpenJDK is what you want, you search for “JDK” and the only entity allowed to use the plain “JDK” moniker is Oracle. Even now, just Googling for “download JDK” gives you Oracle’s JDK (that’s twenty years of PageRank and inbound links pointing to what was once a “free” download - there’s no outranking that!) as the first result. (Given Google’s IP history with Oracle, they should show “Did you mean OpenJDK?” and include those results too :D)