18 ms·
One in Three U.S. Workers Are Earning Less Than $15 an Hour
- listless 5y agoI don’t know where these people are working. Here in the south where the cost of living is SUPER low, Hardee’s will pay you 16$ an hour to start. Waffle House will give you 18. Panera Bread $20. I don’t think this data has caught up with wage increases after the labor shortage.
- fundad 5y agoThose are posted signs but do you know anyone who was offered that. They could just post that to look like they’re not avoiding hiring.
- puffoflogic 5y agoStop listening to BlueAnon.
- gruez 5y ago>Those are posted signs but do you know anyone who was offered that. Well this is HN, so I'd hazard to guess that most people don't know many people who take those jobs. >They could just post that to look like they’re not avoiding hiring. Seems like a conspiracy theory to me unless there's some sort of evidence that they're ignoring applications.
- unmole 5y ago> They could just post that to look like they’re not avoiding hiring. And achieve what, exactly?
- fundad 5y agoProfit. They need to recoup Covid losses with higher prices and smaller staff.
- unmole 5y agoWhat you're saying is: 1. Pretend like you're hiring staff 2. ??? 3. Profit What is happening in step 2 that is leading to step 3? And more importantly, why does step 2 need step 1?
- fundad 5y ago“higher prices and smaller staff“
- unmole 5y agoAgain, why do they need to pretend to hire people? They can just keep the smaller staff.
- fundad 5y agoI didn't say it was some evil strategy but those signs aren't just for potential candidates, they know customers see them too. I think the appearance that the service industry is working harder at hiring than they are is an effort to justify higher prices to customers. Remember demand has kept up despite higher prices and in many cases reduction to quality of service. Doing the same thing is the natural state for a business operator, even if they want to hire they may not have time to interview. There is no benefit to taking signs down in that case when every other restaurant has them up.
- dv_dt 5y agoThere is also the question of if a full time schedule is available at some hourly wage, or if they expect to pay part time, with on call availability.
- bsagdiyev 5y agoI saw a sign for Papa Johns the other day offering a $1000 signing bonus. Of course they don't specify anything else, so who knows how it's paid out. My girlfriend was offered something similar as a teacher but the bonus was paid over 12 months so came out to something equivalent to $80/mo -- not really helpful.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y ago$1000 dollar signing bonus might be the most money they have had all at one time in one place. $80 a month could be a full tank of gas. Just pointing out it can be a big bonus relatively.
- netizen-936824 5y agoAh yes, let's throw them pennies so they may afford transportation to slave for minimum wage that they can barely survive on in the first place.
- listless 5y agoThe point though is well made. A 1000 signing bonus is a HUGE improvement over no signing bonus and a wage that you can barely feed one person on. Remember - these jobs require no skill or prior experience.
- netizen-936824 5y agoI don't think that every single human should be required to be heavily specialized just to earn a livable wage, that's ridiculous
- yahn00 5y ago
- parkingrift 5y agoI'm sorry, but what an absurd comment.
- tetsusaiga 5y agomy favorite part is "swamp climate"
- yahn00 5y agoIt’s not made without personal experience But of course the only experience out there is yours, so others comments are open to mockery and sarcasm Relativity means you can’t really speak truth for anyone else, which I accept is true for me too I speak from personal experience. How you feel about that speech means as much to me as my comments do to you
- yahn00 5y agoNo more absurd than the working conditions of the majority in the US Sorry reality sometimes intrudes on your cognitive clean room
- parkingrift 5y agoBad troll is bad.
- yahn00 5y agoAnon is unimportant altogether
- DistantCl3ric 5y ago$15/hr * 40hr/week * 52week/year = 31200USD = 481000ZAR. It took me at least 5 years as a software engineer with a CS degree to reach that per year in South Africa. I understand cost of living adjustments etc etc but $15 per hour in SA would help so many people dramatically. We have a huge number of citizens living below the poverty line. For perspective, our minimum hourly wage is 23.19ZAR per hour which is roughly 1.49USD.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dudul 5y agoI don't think you understand cost of living as well as you think you do.
- tnzk 5y agoWhat would be the cost of living on average in US? I don't know what's the good way to compare between countries though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dghlsakjg 5y agoNumbeo is a site that offers comparisons between cost of living in various cities. It tells me that rent for a 1 bedroom in Johannesburg is around $440 USD per month. In Denver, a mid level American city, you would be paying $1790 usd. Also keep in mind that if you want health insurance in the US, you might end up spending $5k-$10k for just the insurance, getting care for anything beyond a yearly checkup is going to cost more.
- DistantCl3ric 5y agoIn SA we also have to use private health insurance as the state run facilities are really bad. We have no safe public transport and those who can afford their own car usually have one. Our policing is sub par and many have to pay for private security. We also have a very high income tax rate. Up to something like 45% depending on your level of income. If I for instance saved 10% of my salary vs someone earning comparatively the same in the US, I would have far less buying power in the world in general. Overseas holidays are something very few can afford. Spending ZAR overseas is rough.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoThis kind of thing is always shocking to sheltered middle class people in their bubble. You start to think everyone lives like you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- txsoftwaredev 5y agoIs it not common to have started out working minimum wage jobs? I started out as a teenager making a little over 5 bucks an hour, like all my other peers at that time.
- BoiledCabbage 5y agoA third of the country aren't teenagers I believe is their point.
- endisneigh 5y agoHard to really understand significance of this without normalizing for cost of living in each state. In particular I’d like to see this normalized by the median rent for a one bedroom apartment. Looking at the map, most of the lower paid folks live in cheaper areas, which is to be expected.
- bennysomething 5y agoAlso what ages people are when they are earning this really matters too
- PenguinCoder 5y agoWhy? Labor is labor.
- m-alsuwaidi 5y agoBecause as you’re growing up you’re supposed to get work on yourself, get more skills hence leading to higher paychecks. So no, labor isn’t labor.
- bennysomething 5y agoIf labor is labor should everyone be paid the same? Edit: age matters for a number of reasons, as employees gain more experience they become more valuable and take on more responsibility. Also the amount of money a person needs as they get older usually increases (care for children and possibly their own parents etc). Earning minimum wage at 21 is very different than being 41 on minimum wage. Often businesses hire young staff as an investment, they are untrained and at first add no value and this is reflected in the wages. However as they progress they earn more (certainly true of me I started on a really low salary , barely minimum wage).
- inamberclad 5y agoOf course the lower paid people live in cheaper areas, where else can they live? $15/hr is no longer a sufficient/comfortable wage for anyone in the US.
- legitster 5y ago>The subminimum wage, again, is sort of a legacy of the racist and sexist creation of minimum wage policies in this country,” It's kind of crazy how much liberty authors of studies have these days to speak outside the scope of their study. This explanation is handwavey at best or downright fraught if you actually look into the history of said rules.
- yahn00 5y agoIt’s kind of crazy how you think free speech takes a back seat to your sensibilities. No one else has to live in your mental box.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gruez 5y agoI don't see how you can read the parent comment and conclude that he commenter wants "free speech" to "take a back seat". It's one thing to make unfounded claims outside your field of expertise on your personal blog or whatever, it's another thing entirely to do the same thing but on a report for a respectable organization.
- rayiner 5y agoThat history being that minimum wage was partly motivated by attempts to exclude Black workers from the job market. Same thing with gun control—it was efforts to disarm freed slaves. (Colonial powers disarmed their colonies too.) Of course there are non-racist reasons for both the minimum wage and gun control! But these “taint by association with racism” arguments are always deployed in an extremely selective way. The Senate is racist because it supposedly was to help slave holding states (which isn’t true) but gun control isn’t racist even though it was definitely popularized in response to the perceived threat of armed Black men.
- scohesc 5y agoI don't understand the concept that each state needs to have their minimum wage immediately changed to $15 an hour. There's are hundred of thousands of possible factors that go into paying people in different economic areas with vastly different policies, laws, costs of living, etc. Not even including non-economic based policies that have had unintended effects on the economies of each individual state. Saying that "everybody should make 'x' dollars per hour" is so narrow-minded to me, but I'd welcome someone to help me understand. If you raise minimum wage up from (say) $8 to $15, what happens to everybody else in the state - do their wages go up by $7, or is their labor now worth $7 less because of this? Is this just a new phenomenon where everybody thinks their opinion is fact, and critical thinking is taking the backseat to what people "feel" is right - completely disregarding any other factors that might make the situation as a whole _worse_ than before?
- ydlr 5y ago> what happens to everybody else in the state - do their wages go up by $7, or is their labor now worth $7 less because of this? My neighbor having more does not mean I have any less.
- parkingrift 5y agoA federal minimum wage is preposterous. The cost of living between states is astronomical. Any federal minimum will create waste on one side and want on another. The "living wage" in Alabama is $13.77, but its' $18.62 in New York.[0] Honestly, even statewide minimum wage is fairly ridiculous. Within the state of New York there are counties with a living wage as low as $13.23 (Wyoming County) and as high as $21.77 (New York County). This is a "problem" to be solved at the county level exclusively. [0]: https://livingwage.mit.edu https://livingwage.mit.edu
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> Any federal minimum will create waste on one side and want on another. Who can afford the waste, who will be wanting? While that's probably not the point I think it's a very convenient bonus to many people advocating for a federal minimum.
- rayiner 5y ago> Who can afford the waste, who will be wanting? Big companies like Amazon can afford the waste and small businesses will be left wanting.
- bhupy 5y agoEven Canada doesn't have a Federal minimum wage on the private sector; it's entirely left to the Provinces.