3 ms·
I’m just a Joe Average W-2 working stiff, but if I ever needed an attorney, I’d expect that I could divulge all the facts of my situation to them without those
by sokoloff 5y ago
I’m just a Joe Average W-2 working stiff, but if I ever needed an attorney, I’d expect that I could divulge all the facts of my situation to them without those specific disclosures being subject to subpoena (5th Amendment and all).
To me, it’s not about “should this specific thing be cloaked behind privilege?” but rather “to make the attorney-client relationship productive and to make representation effective, they should be privileged”.
“You have nothing to fear if you have nothing to hide” is not an argument for much of anything and certainly not for by default removing the privileged nature of communication between an attorney and their client.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoExactly. Employees would be very reluctant to divulge anything if they thought it wasn't privileged. It would be an awful scenario where a bunch of bad stuff would keep happening and would never be stopped because you couldn't ever talk about it.
- vba616 5y ago>To me, it’s not about “should this specific thing be cloaked behind privilege?” but rather “to make the attorney-client relationship productive and to make representation effective, they should be privileged”. If Bob Jones emails Joe Schmoe and cc's Dewey Cheatham & Howe, maybe the communication to the lawyers is privileged, but why would the communication to Joe be privileged? It's neither to a lawyer nor asking for legal advice.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoFrom a practical perspective people usually say "hey John (at Dewey), what are your thoughts on X?" They also put "privileged and confidential" in the subject and/or email body.
- vba616 5y agoIf the email is going to other people than John, each copy received is treated as a separate document under a different custodian. At least, this is how I recall it working. Recovering a unified concept of an email is done afterwards.