3 ms·
The problem with a ruling like that is that, by not addressing the existing rulings, it limits the value of an otherwise good precedent. If you don't address a
by Natsu 15y ago
The problem with a ruling like that is that, by not addressing the existing rulings, it limits the value of an otherwise good precedent. If you don't address an issue, legal types usually assume that you cannot, so it's a good way to lose that part of the argument. If you've read enough legal briefs, you will no doubt have noticed how many times they call each other out for failing to argue something or another. Parties in a lawsuit who don't raise some important issue or say what they're supposed to generally don't get another chance to do so, which is how we end up with crazy boilerplate that tries to cover every little thing.
That said, I'm glad this judge did the sensible thing.