3 ms·
The Gödel thing isn't quite as a big a problem as it seems. One way of looking at it is that there will always exist true theorems that you cannot prove. That
by jfengel 5y ago
The Gödel thing isn't quite as a big a problem as it seems. One way of looking at it is that there will always exist true theorems that you cannot prove.
That may seem surprising, but I don't think it is. There are infinite sets and infinite things you can say about them. It's not really a shock that there might be some properties about that set you can only prove by inspecting all of the elements, but you can't actually do that in finite time -- even though it's true. The sets are infinite, the theorems and their proofs are (by definition) not.
That doesn't mean that the foundations of math are fragile. It just means that there are facts you don't know. But you already knew that, too.
The specific theorems that can't be proven are just a subject of your axiom set. You can prove, or disprove, any specific thing you want, by taking it as axiomatic. It's just a question of whether anything interesting follows. That's a judgment for mathematicians, not a fact of mathematics.
I am, of course, handwaving like crazy, and probably driving the mathematicians nuts. Even though I said that the theorem is less surprising than it might seem, the fact that you can prove the theorem itself strikes me as very surprising.