3 ms·
An important thing to bear in mind is that the legal profession is largely self-regulated, and lawyers have a monopoly over the legal system. State bars and bar
by rayiner 5y ago
An important thing to bear in mind is that the legal profession is largely self-regulated, and lawyers have a monopoly over the legal system. State bars and bar organizations are largely unaccountable to the public. If these organizations abandon principles of neutrality and objectivity, and become overtly ideological, they can use their power over lawyers to exert tremendous, anti-democratic influence over every aspect of life. Everyone should be worried about this.
And when I say everyone, I mean it. People assume that it's just "conservatives" complaining about these ideological changes. But to be clear, all of the people quoted in this article--like the overwhelming majority of lawyers--are liberals: David Boies, Andy Koppelman, Nadine Strossen, etc. Indeed, they're probably well to the left of your average Democrat.
Also, when it comes to the legal system, you shouldn't disregard complaints from "conservatives." The reason legal process works is because, even though it results in winners and losers, everyone at least everyone agrees in the process and the principles underlying it. The faith Americans have in the legal system is remarkable given that 90% of lawyers are liberal Democrats, while most Americans are Republicans or conservative Democrats. (Fun fact: about two-thirds of the country still opposes the half-century old Supreme Court precedent banning school prayer.) Abandoning the dedication to neutrality and objectivity that has been championed by even liberal legal organizations up to this point will have profoundly negative consequences for the rule of law.
- olsonjeffery 5y ago
- FooBarBizBazz 5y ago> "The majority of Donald Trump supporters are women and people of color" Interesting semantic game. I had to stop and think for a second, but, yes, that is probably literally true (albeit just barely). Of white Trump voters, probably a little under half are women. Some of-color people (that semantic boundary is itself flexible) also voted for Trump, probably enough to make up for whatever man/woman difference there was among the white voters, plus enough to get over the 50% threshold. So yes, literally, "the majority of Donald Trump's voters in 2016 and 2020 were women and people of color" is probably true. Interesting trick.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoMathematically that should be "OR", not "AND"
- zugi 5y agoGood point, to keep up the game how about: "Women and people of color constitute the majority of Trump supporters" or "The majority of Trump supporters is comprised of women and people of color"
- coffeecat 5y agoScott Alexander pointed out on his old blog that compared to other recent Republican candidates (Romney and McCain), Trump performed about the same among white voters and over-performed among non-white voters. The notion of Trump as the "white man's candidate" is mostly BS. https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/16/you-are-still-crying-wolf/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/16/you-are-still-crying-w...
- rayiner 5y agoOn many important questions with a close nexus to the law, lawyers as a group are to the left of not only Republicans, but many Democrats. E.g. most lawyers support using race as a factor in college admissions and hiring decisions. Most Democrats (as well as most Black and Hispanic people) oppose using race as even a "minor factor" in admissions decisions (https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americans-say-colleges-should-not-consider-race-or-ethnicity-in-admissions https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americ...), and oppose using race as a factor in hiring decisions, even if that results in less diversity (https://www.vox.com/2019/5/9/18538216/diversity-workplace-pew-poll https://www.vox.com/2019/5/9/18538216/diversity-workplace-pe...). Likewise, most lawyers are liberal on criminal justice issues. Meanwhile, a 2014 Sentencing Project study found that two-thirds of Black people (90% of whom vote Democrat) think the criminal justice system "is not harsh enough." https://news.wttw.com/2019/04/11/how-black-leaders-unintentionally-contributed-mass-incarceration https://news.wttw.com/2019/04/11/how-black-leaders-unintenti... Most lawyer's support Roe v. Wade's rule that states cannot prohibit abortions before fetal viability (around the end of the second trimester). But 65% of people think abortion should "usually be illegal in the second trimester" (i.e. after 13 weeks): https://apnews.com/article/only-on-ap-us-supreme-court-abortion-religion-health-2c569aa7934233af8e00bef4520a8fa8 https://apnews.com/article/only-on-ap-us-supreme-court-abort... Most lawyers are aggressively secular, and lean toward a mode of excluding religion from schools similar to France. Meanwhile, most Americans say that religion has too little presence in schools: https://news.gallup.com/poll/18136/public-favors-voluntary-prayer-public-schools.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/18136/public-favors-voluntary-p.... Specifically, 73% of Republicans and 51% of Democrats think there is too little religion in schools. Insofar as judges (and Supreme Court Justices) come from the pool of lawyers, it's important to observe that lawyers as a group are well to the left of not only Republicans, but many or most Democrats on these issues.
- diputsmonro 5y agoHave you considered that maybe it's not the lawyers that are out of step with the American people, but that maybe the American people are out of step with how to effectively conduct a democracy? For example, lawyers should be aggressively secular. The separation of church and state is one of the most important pillars of a fair democracy, and should be steadfastly defended by our legal professionals regardless of the current ebbs and flows of culture and religion. Personally, I think that the Reagan Era ushered in a wave of cultural conservatism that is far out of step with a healthy democracy, and lead to a toxic abundance of corporatism, deregulation, and rugged individualism, and that the "woke wave" that conservatives complain about is in many ways really just a cultural pendulum swing back to a healthy center. Democrats are to the right of most lawyers, sure - but the Democratic party would be considered right wing in most other western democracies. America is so right-leaning that being a centrist in a global sense makes you more to the left than our left wing party. So I don't think this data shows that our legal system is being corrupted by a sudden surge of radical leftists. I think it shows that American culture is going off the deep end and that our lawyers are trying to keep us tethered to the realities of democracy. These people get decades of education about the concrete function of legal institutions, and undoubtedly know much more about what is actually effective than your average American that just spews their untested opinion at a polster.