3 ms·
> Everyone deserves an attorney, not just even when accused of heinous crimes, but especially when accused of heinous crimes. Yes, but no lawyer should be for
by mschuster91 5y ago
> Everyone deserves an attorney, not just even when accused of heinous crimes, but especially when accused of heinous crimes.
Yes, but no lawyer should be forced to defend a specific person either. Effective representation requires at least a basic level of trust and communication between client and lawyer - the consistent negative outcomes associated with poor persons unable to afford their own lawyer and being forced to rely on public defenders who are often overworked and underpaid are long known [1] [2], not to mention that unlike e.g. Germany, DAs in the US are not required to also search for evidence that is helpful to the defense.
In the end, issues of payment aside there will always be a lawyer interested in taking on any case - no matter how heinous - simply because of the publicity that showing good work in defending a client will bring.
[1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/27977109 https://www.jstor.org/stable/27977109
[2] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/17/poor-rely-public-defenders-too-overworked https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/17/poor-r...
- Ekaros 5y agoWhat about public defenders? I think it is reasonable for them to defend anyone qualified. Or then arrange funding for private defence.
- vkou 5y agoThe amount of help you can expect from a public defender is nearly zero. Specifically, they'll do two things for you - they will tell you how fucked you are, and that you should take a plea bargain. Their budget, and therefore, the amount of hours/resources they can devote to your case is a tiny fraction of that of the prosecutor's office. If everyone on trial had to use a public defender, you'd see this system get fixed by next year. But they don't - which is why people like the author of TFA can wring their hands over how unfair it is that Weinstein is poo-pooed for getting the legal representation in the world. What a travesty! What an injustice! What a generation-defining moment! But please, pay no attention to how the animals and proles get to navigate the legal system. They're finding quite the hill to die on.
- mschuster91 5y agoI would rather have a system like here in Germany for criminal trials where the defendant chooses the lawyer they work with and the lawyer gets paid a set hourly rate by the government.
- torstenvl 5y agoAs a quasi-PD, I may be biased, but I have seen hourly-rate lawyers pass up excellent resolutions to a case for no good reason. My last jury trial is a good example. There was a lot of mitigating evidence and the prosecutor didn't have a grudge against our client. A non-criminal disposition was discussed and tentatively agreed between myself and the prosecutor. Retained counsel advised against it and client proceeded to trial. Lost on the merits and now has a conviction for a dozen counts of fraud. Then mitigation evidence came in during sentencing and he got no jail time, just had to pay restitution. But he still has a criminal record. And he didn't need to have one. But the retained counsel got paid, so...