4 ms·
Just to think France would have been nice and green for decades. Imagine if people at Kyoto would have just said 'right, climate change, lets are just start bui
by panick21_ 5y ago
Just to think France would have been nice and green for decades. Imagine if people at Kyoto would have just said 'right, climate change, lets are just start building nuclear power plants as fast as we can'.
But thanks to amazing green environmental organization like Greenpeace and all the fear-mongering for decades the world has missed multiple opportunities to turn into a nuclear society.
Had governments been willing to pay extra for clean energy (and air), nuclear would have taken of in the 70s everywhere. But coal and later gas was just to cheap for anything to compete.
Germany is specially interesting. They have on the forefront of green revolution. I can't even remember the amount of think pieces hailing Germany as this amazing government lead push to green energy. Germany was held up as the global model over and over. The amount of times I have heard talk about German investment in solar is almost mind-blowing.
But when I look at this map, its always brown. And Germany as an engineering society could have easily spent the last 2 decades putting up nuclear reactors. If France could do it in the 70-90, Germany could have done it 2000-2020.
Likely by now they could finish multiple reactors a year. And once you have the workforce and production capability for that pace could have built them all over the East.
What this map really shows is that if you combine nuclear with hydro you are like gone do amazing.
My own country, Switzerland, sadly had a vote (direct democracy ftw) and now nuclear research and new nuclear is basically illegal. Its a damn shame.
The world has just totally fucked up the response to climate change.
- verisimi 5y ago> Germany was held up as the global model over and over. They were/are, but IMO, Germany seem to be in a terrible position re managing their energy needs. They have had huge price increases - partly because they have had such dependence on Russia, and because they have removed their own power plants.
- panick21_ 5y agoHow are they the model when France had green energy since the 90s? CO2 saved earlier is far more helpful.
- ovi256 5y agoPeople who choose the narrative of who the model is are thought leaders like journalists, academics and politicians. They are narrative and process oriented, not outcome oriented. This means that when a process started with good intentions fails horribly (like Germany's decarbonation) they do not change opinions - Germany tried to do the right thing (even if it was a risky bet without precedent) so it's blameless. There is no course correction - the process was correct wasn't it ? Furthermore, they have entrenched this mode of functioning in Western societies, who have become process not outcome oriented. People interested in hacking and startups are probably among the most outcome oriented, so have trouble understanding how this process oriented mindset without course correction can exist.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoBecause France is planning to follow Germany's lead? Would be weird to hold France up as a model. "Let the Nuclear plants you built a generation ago slowly age out and be replaced by renewables that Germany helped establish" isn't something most countries could emulate, they'll jump straight to the renewables, because they're cheaper and better.
- panick21_ 5y agoBecause the same culture unfortunately prevails. France is no longer as green as it was because of that.
- ohgodplsno 5y agoYou can thank 30 years of sabotage by ecologists for our nuclear industry stagnating, and 20 years of complete incompetence by our politicians.
- masklinn 5y ago> You can thank 30 years of sabotage by ecologists 40+. The protests against superphenix started immediately and the rocket attack on the site was in 1982. The attacker was Chaïm Nissim, who’d go on to get elected in geneva as a member of the swiss green party.
- mro_name 5y agoa nuclear society is neither green nor sustainable.
- adrianN 5y agoIt is pretty green compared to the alternatives. And if we wanted to we could build breeder reactors that stretch our nuclear fuel reserves to a few hundred years at least. It is an open question whether 100% nuclear is cheaper or more expensive than 100% renewables though.
- kergonath 5y ago100% nuclear is not economical or practical. Nuclear is poorly suited to regular spikes and short-term load balancing. It shines when you need reliable, cheap electricity 24 hours a day, all year round (or at least for several days). 100% solar and wind also isn’t economical or practical. Their output is more cyclical and less reliable, and they tend to fail together. The best way to run a power grid is actually to balance nuclear, wind/solar, and hydro (which has its own set of advantages and drawbacks). So, the “100% this or 100% that” question is a red herring. We must use all the tools available (because the situation is actually quite dire), where they make sense.
- smotah 5y ago> 100% nuclear is not economical or practical. Nuclear is poorly suited to regular spikes and short-term load balancing. While using only nuclear power plants for all the domestic electricity generation of a country doesn't make much sense, some reactor design, notably French ones (in particular composition of the control rods and their placement in the core, among other things) allows for very flexible control over power output. [0] EDF makes the surprising claim that their plants are as flexible as gas plants, which are generally considered as the go-to method of load following. Also curious to why 100% nuclear wouldn't be economical, wouldn't this hypothetical situation benefits from the economy of scale and grid management simplification? [0] https://hal-edf.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01977209/document https://hal-edf.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01977209/document (PDF)
- TZVdosOWs3kZHus 5y ago> Germany is specially interesting. They have on the forefront of green revolution. I can't even remember the amount of think pieces hailing Germany as this amazing government lead push to green energy. Germany was held up as the global model over and over. The amount of times I have heard talk about German investment in solar is almost mind-blowing. Unfortunately the last two cabinets (8 years) did a poor job in continuing a most promising change to more renewable energies. The business lobbying that took place at that time is unbearable. This graphic[1] (in german, but you get the idea) shows the expansion figures for renewable energies and it is clearly visible how photovoltaics in particular have been severely limited since 2013. Absurd rules were created, for example a levy for privately generated photovoltaic electricity. Or artificially created requirements to keep plant sizes small. After laws were changed in favour of large investors, fossil energy companies now adorn themselves with large projects, although a large part of the expansion is still done by private individuals. After an entire industry has been destroyed, there are now complaints that there is a lack of skilled workers and that the number of new installations cannot be increased quickly enough. It all makes me want to puke. We could be somewhere completely different today, but greed and lust for power prevent us from doing anything good for the general public. [1]: https://www.erneuerbare-energien.de/EE/Redaktion/DE/Bilder/Grafiken_erneuerbare_Energien/Diagramm-18.png;jsessionid=667C56F182E11E5E1828A7259564D411?__blob=poster&v=11 https://www.erneuerbare-energien.de/EE/Redaktion/DE/Bilder/G...
- cinntaile 5y ago> Absurd rules were created, for example a levy for privately generated photovoltaic electricity. This makes sense since you stress the grid requiring the grid operators to invest.
- namibj 5y agoNo, you misunderstand. This is a tax on electricity, unless consumed in the immediate vicinity. It applies of you build the solar farm and the power line yourself. And did normal grid, in addition to grid fees.
- 5y ago
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoElectricity isn't the only source of carbon, ghg or other pollution. And indeed, it's one of the easier ones since wind and solar are the cheapest sources of electricity these days (partly thanks to Germany's foresight and early investments) If I was going to ding Germany for anything (because they've been pretty much world leaders on the whole climate thing) it would be their initial reluctance to embrace EVs but they seem to be over that now. And they stepped back slightly on their climate leadership under a right-wing government but greens seem to have more influence currently so getting back on track. But generally their carbon intensity of the whole economy is trending in the right direction, despite doing more heavy manufacturing than most other EU countries.
- ohgodplsno 5y ago>wind and solar are the cheapest sources of electricity these days *because they are absurdly subsidized, as opposed to other methods of production which have been repeatedly fucked over the years.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoEarly government support of R&D and market support is one of the things that Germany (and a few other countries) contributed to the current success of renewables. So that is in part why they are cheap, but they are also simply cheaper now due to their scale of production. Nothing 'absurd' about that though so not quite sure what you're claiming is happening. Presumably something along the lines of there being a big conspiracy to hide the true costs of renewables which hurts the real cheap energy sources, which are fossil fuels. Which feels backwards to me.
- _ph_ 5y agoNo, they are currently not subsidized at all. What was done was guaranteeing minimum prices for renewable energy. These prices used to be way higher than market prices to make renewable energy generation economically feasible. This way especially important in the first decade of this century and back then you could call the renewables heavily subsidized. But recently market prices for electricity were by far exceeding the minimum guaranteed prices, so you can't call those renewables as "heavily subsidized".
- pjc50 5y ago> Greenpeace Reminder that Greenpeace started out fighting against nuclear weapons and their testing (which so annoyed the French government that they simply murdered an activist) and nuclear dumping, both of which put considerable quantities of radioactive material into the air and water. Chernobyl has been in the news again since the site was occupied by Russian troops. That and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zaporizhzhia_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zaporizhzhia_Nuclear_Power_Pla... have apparently taken shelling damage but as yet no leaks have been reported. The potential for an accidental or deliberate disaster that covers Western Europe with radioactive material and takes out a season's agriculture remains. Is everyone happy with Iran having a buildout of a dozen or more reactors to replace their oil usage? More prosaically, the cost of solar only goes down, while the cost of nuclear seems to only go up.
- conorcleary 5y agoNot only that, the potential risk that contemporary nuclear energy (worse yet, older tech) keeps increasing as the world becomes more complex. You could make a list very very long by jotting down the threats that would be caused by and directed at a nuclear installation of any size. Frankly, I don't trust the Human to manage the risk of a nuclear installation. Look what Humans are doing elsewhere in every other domain. We don't need the sun to be brought to Earth.
- panick21_ 5y agoThis is quite simply contradicted by evidence. And newly built nuclear plant would be incredibly safe. And if we actually build really modern plants they would be absurdly safe. People make way to big a deal of how amazingly complex nuclear plants are. Its not some magical spell that prevents demons from entering the world. And the potential of accidents even in case of terrorist attack (or whatever fantasy scenario) is far smaller then people want to claim.
- teachrdan 5y agoBut OP isn't talking about newly-built plants. OP is doing what many pro-nuclear folks do, which is to posit a counterfactual history where we built dozens (hundreds?) of nuclear plants in the 70s. That would leave us with many, many obsolete nuclear plants reaching the end of their intended lifespan all at once over the last few years. (Nuclear plants were typically permitted to operate for 40 years, although may have successfully applied for extensions and continue to run today.)
- kkfx 5y agoThe "response" have issues from being done by neolierals. Nuclear (actual, so fission) is expensive and dangerous enough to be a government-only show, It's not something that can be offloaded to private hands. Because of that neoliberals hate it. Modern p.v. and eolic means tons of small "products" to be sold and sold regularly because as long as tech improve after 10 years even if a plant is still fully functional it's about time to refresh it. As a result means a very profitable business for private companies (just try to track those behind Greta Thumberg, you'll end up quickly to giants like ABB, Ökoworld AG, Dii GmbH, Enel, EDF, Endesa, Abengoa, Siemens, Cevital and various investments banks). Oil giants are sitting on big money but they know their business sooner or later will end at least because of more and more scarce resources, so they like to diversify their investments. That's is. France have more nuclear because France have more public (have had, at least, with recent government and projects things goes very badly here)... "New" nuclear projects are stuck for similar reasons: investors want profit, the service is just a mean to elicit profits, not a purpose and the profit a reward. Swiss is luck to a certain extent because of it's small size and a certain policy toward autonomy, they aren't really autonomous especially recently but at least hydro thanks to the orography can play an important role and probably can still grow a bit toward many smaller-size plants so just pushing nuclear a bit they can be almost autonomous again. France to be autonomous must re-nationalize EDF erasing Hercules project and other disastrous neoliberal moves. Others are almost doomed: Germany have not good enough infra in the whole country, it's private-based development under USA control have had so negative effects that I do not know how they can be back in power, Italy is also doomed, Spain might have a bit more chances but I'm not much sure and other countries are completely out of the game. Having a small p.v. with lithium storage I've reasoned a bit just in terms of personal energy autonomy in Green New Deal terms: having built s new house (Minergie-alike (BBC) if you are Swiss) I already have all electrical and winter heating demand far less energy than an old house, winter cooling is needed thanks to the climate only during the sunny days where there is plenty of electricity however try to be almost autonomous (witch means near-zero consumption from the grid, but with the grid as a cheap backup, cheaper than running on a generator) would mean are 30-40k euros more in both battery, a geothermic heat-pump since the actual heating (hot water stored in the garage + VMC + low inertia heat transfer to the house) stress batteries too much in many winter nights. Enlarging that to all houses: we can build something similar for individual homes in perhaps 50+ years. We still have to power industries. Even if in a soon future we can use e.v. as part of the house power plant (both to recharge them when not used, thanks to more than one car and WFH, and when they supply energy to the home microgrid) we are still not autonomous in a safe manner, the investment is a significant fraction of the entire home value and the worst part: it does not last longer. Batteries really used can last from 5 to 8 years while formally they'll last 10. That's means around 10-12k euros per year, doable for middle-class that will be impoverished by such hi prices but not doable for most others, a vast majority of the citizens. And still nothing to produce enough of such gears for even just only the middle class. Nothing for the industry, hospitals, shipping, airplanes etc. Long story short the actual new deal is a way to elict money from all to enrich few, making all much more surveilled (IoT is mandatory in such systems, and done in connected and proprietary ways) and poor. Witch is actually the 2030 Davos agenda. It's almost NOTHING for climate change (the sole part is that the need of new home might means homes able to offer better climate comfort, hopefully built in hydrogeologically safe places). Oil&gas will remain probably as long as we have them in sufficient quantities and nuclear will be kept going hoping for fusion, but all in a world ruled by private bodies so a world that can't really innovate.