6 ms·
Electricity map: Mapping the climate impact of electricity
- danielsokil 5y agoYes! I have finally found the ideal country to live in, starting my journey towards Kosovo.
- bb123 5y agoFrance sticks out like a sore thumb in a sea of natural gas burning neighbours. We could all be running on nuclear like them. Nuclear is safer, better for the environment and has the nice side effect that it frees us from relying on despots like Putin and the Saudi ilk to keep the lights on. Instead here we are. At the bitter end of 30 years of shit government.
- adrianN 5y agoAbout a third of all Uranium is either mined or at least refined in Russia.
- masklinn 5y agoThat's complete nonsense, unless you're asserting that Kazakstan is in Russia. Russia produces about 5% of uranium, and uranium is reduced to yellowcake on site but it is generally enriched by the country using the fuel (eurodif being a pretty significant exception). Furthermore uranium has a bunch of advantages — aside from most of the known reserves being in advanced economies (namely Australia and Canada): - because it's dense and stable (unlike gasoline or natural gas), countries can have years of enriched fuel in storage, meaning in case of supply issue they can easily wait out - ramp up of existing mines (or opening out of new mines) to compensate for one supplier shutting down or being blackballed, because - uranium requires very little infrastructure between the mine (which ships yellowcake) and the enrichment plant, yellowcake is transported in 400kg drums packed into standard shipping containers
- PinguTS 5y agoThat's just the imports of natural Uranium. In addition there are the imports of processed Uranium from Russia. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1147442/imports-of-uranium-to-eu-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1147442/imports-of-urani...
- danans 5y ago> That's complete nonsense, unless you're asserting that Kazakstan is in Russia. If the West became dependent on Kazakh uranium because they shifted their entire fossil fuel generation capacity to nuclear, it would be in Russia's strategic interest to exert control over Kazakhstan's uranium, one way or another. There may be sensible ways to replace some base load on the grid with nuclear, but not by introducing a resource dependency on the vassal of a major adversary. The thing we can do right now is focus on electrification of end uses that are still fossil fuel powered. That way the end uses are mostly agnostic of the method of generation.
- ohgodplsno 5y agoMostly because as it stands (stood), it's (was) the most economically sensible thing to do. France also gets a ton from Niger, Australia is known to have stupid amounts in their reserves (and they can't really pull the "mines are bad" argument considering just how many coal mines they have), and pretty much every country has the ability to open mines. It's just a matter of how expensive it is. The good thing with nuclear fuel is that you don't really need that much, and much of the cost of nuclear energy is in operating costs, not fuel. Additionally, had we continued research on nuclear, we might have the ability to reuse spent fuel today, which still holds a _ton_ of energy in it.
- goodcanadian 5y agoIf you had looked a couple of days ago, the UK (for example) would have been a lot greener as the wind was blowing. Today is especially bad for wind which, unfortunately, does mean more gas.
- yodelshady 5y agoYet today, France is as green as it was. And I'll bet money that, couple of days ago, the carbon put out by the spinning reserve that is necessary to cover a day like today wasn't counted. If you're going to advocate for wind, great. Can we examine your plans honestly, please? Because if you want to deliver an equivalent service to France, one where "SLA" and "disconnect the customers if convenient" are treated as different things, then our current plan is not wind. It is gas.
- goodcanadian 5y agoIt was not my intent to advocate for or against wind; I merely wanted to keep the comparison fair. But, if you insist . . . The gas required for standby is miniscule compared to what is burned under load, and frankly, I would bet money that wind was curtailed before "wasting" any gas. Even if we burn gas today, gas not burned two days ago, was not burned. So, it is nonsense to dismiss the benefits of wind. I do not know what the future picture will look like, but given the relative cheapness of wind generation, I suspect there will be a significant over capacity installed. Grid storage is also coming along. New interconnects are being installed such as the North Sea link to Norway. We are currently importing 1.4GW from Norwegian hydroelectric. I suspect wind energy was exported to Norway when it was blowing. And yes, more nuclear is being built, in the form of Hinckley Point C.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoIndeed. Overcapacity for wind and solar is why batteries and other storage solutions are so important since that provides some ability to absorb the excess energy or use it when production dips. Interconnected grids provides similar grid balancing benefits. A near future thing might be lots of EVs with vehicle to grid capability adding a lot of battery to the grid. Millions of EVs would provide some non trivial amount of capacity. Several manufacturers are starting to supply cars with this capability (e.g. Ford, Kia, and a few others). And of course Tesla is already experimenting with virtual power plants as well. The future is going to be a messy process of different countries and companies rolling out bits and pieces of infrastructure and technology as it becomes available. It's a fiercely competitive space and it does not favor players that depend on costly solutions that require high energy prices to be economically sustainable. All that will happen in a market with an increasing amount of variety of supply and greater fluctuations in pricing. This actually has a re-enforcing effect. The more wind, solar, and battery comes online, the less profitable gas plants become. They only generate revenue when they are in use but they still cost money when they aren't producing. Likewise, exporting nuclear energy is not a thing when there is a surplus of cheap renewable energy unless you basically sell the energy at a loss. And turning a nuclear plant off takes a lot of planning. And turning them back on is of course expensive as well. That's one of the issues France is facing with its domestic nuclear production. It's often cheaper to import wind power from abroad and with a connected grid, power suppliers have the freedom to do so. And of course in areas where prices are higher, home owners are incentivized to find ways to reduce their energy prices by installing solar on their roofs and adding batteries to their house.
- Tade0 5y agoThe EU gets 20% of its uranium from Russia, and another 20% from Kazakhstan which, despite its recent refusal to participate in the war, is still deeply tied with Russia.
- masklinn 5y agoUnlike natural gas though, uranium is easy to stockpile and doing so is pretty standard (IIRC france keeps 2~3 years worth of fuel stockpiled, plus a 5 years strategic reserve), and there are no new pipelines to build and install if you look for a new supplier, it's "just" a question of that supplier ramping up production or opening mines for whatever price they are interested in. The steps inbetween are pretty much standard international shipping in intermodal containers.
- smotah 5y agoThe main difference is that: - the weight of uranium compared to the weight of coal needed for the same amount of energy produced is absolutely ridiculous: 2.5 metric tons vs. 7 grams of uranium 235. That make it easy to stockpile it for years to come - Some "waste" are already being recycled and used again - uranium is uniformly distributed on earth, there's not the same geopolitical issues that we experience for fossil energy sources such as oil and gas - I'm not sure whether those 20%/20% proportions are true since some EU countries does not disclose the part of uranium imported from each countries - Australia, Niger and Canada are also some major players for EU uranium import, none of which want to back Russian war, quite the contrary according to the UN vote.
- panick21_ 5y agoJust to think France would have been nice and green for decades. Imagine if people at Kyoto would have just said 'right, climate change, lets are just start building nuclear power plants as fast as we can'. But thanks to amazing green environmental organization like Greenpeace and all the fear-mongering for decades the world has missed multiple opportunities to turn into a nuclear society. Had governments been willing to pay extra for clean energy (and air), nuclear would have taken of in the 70s everywhere. But coal and later gas was just to cheap for anything to compete. Germany is specially interesting. They have on the forefront of green revolution. I can't even remember the amount of think pieces hailing Germany as this amazing government lead push to green energy. Germany was held up as the global model over and over. The amount of times I have heard talk about German investment in solar is almost mind-blowing. But when I look at this map, its always brown. And Germany as an engineering society could have easily spent the last 2 decades putting up nuclear reactors. If France could do it in the 70-90, Germany could have done it 2000-2020. Likely by now they could finish multiple reactors a year. And once you have the workforce and production capability for that pace could have built them all over the East. What this map really shows is that if you combine nuclear with hydro you are like gone do amazing. My own country, Switzerland, sadly had a vote (direct democracy ftw) and now nuclear research and new nuclear is basically illegal. Its a damn shame. The world has just totally fucked up the response to climate change.
- verisimi 5y ago> Germany was held up as the global model over and over. They were/are, but IMO, Germany seem to be in a terrible position re managing their energy needs. They have had huge price increases - partly because they have had such dependence on Russia, and because they have removed their own power plants.
- panick21_ 5y agoHow are they the model when France had green energy since the 90s? CO2 saved earlier is far more helpful.
- 5y ago
- mattlondon 5y agoHow frequently does this live data update? It is showing "estimated" data for e.g. the UK from 0800, and it is now 1020 so it is over 2 two hours old? Comparing the data from https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ https://gridwatch.templar.co.uk/, there seems to be some real discrepancies, e.g. - Solar: 4.23% vs 13.81% - Wind: 18.8% vs 8.5% - Gas: 37.1% vs 41.24% I am not sure who I would trust more - I guess if the data from electricity map is an estimate that is close to 2.5 hours out of date, that might explain some of it. Cool UI though
- ohgodplsno 5y agoHint: if it's just two hours late, you can come back in two hours. The numbers remain true in terms of carbon intensity.
- jka 5y agoThe parsers[1] that ElectricityMap uses are open source and use a variety of different data sources. Here are the technical requirements for each data source: https://github.com/electricityMap/electricitymap-contrib/wiki/Technical-requirements-for-parser-data https://github.com/electricityMap/electricitymap-contrib/wik... (to answer your question, the list mentions that a data source is required to be: "Updated in real-time with less than 2 hours of delay." ... "Can have a longer delay, but then the country won’t be colored on the map") [1] - https://github.com/electricitymap/electricitymap-contrib/tree/a053de7ee83061d4c4aa4d61dff72b187898372f/parsers https://github.com/electricitymap/electricitymap-contrib/tre...
- possiblelion 5y agoI don't think this is a fair representation - for example it makes Estonia and Kosovo stand out in the world as the worst offenders. However they have relatively tiny populations (1.3 million and 1.9 million respectively); the actual CO2 impact of them is miniscule in the world, even if per-capita CO2 seems high.
- Sankozi 5y agoIf we divide whole map into small enough regions then all of them would be "green" by your reasoning. All kinds of problems can be "solved" that way.
- EForEndeavour 5y agoRelated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modifiable_areal_unit_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modifiable_areal_unit_problem > The modifiable areal unit problem (MAUP) is a source of statistical bias that can significantly impact the results of statistical hypothesis tests. MAUP affects results when point-based measures of spatial phenomena are aggregated into districts, for example, population density or illness rates. The resulting summary values (e.g., totals, rates, proportions, densities) are influenced by both the shape and scale of the aggregation unit. > For example, census data may be aggregated into county districts, census tracts, postcode areas, police precincts, or any other arbitrary spatial partition. Thus the results of data aggregation are dependent on the mapmaker's choice of which "modifiable areal unit" to use in their analysis. A census choropleth map calculating population density using state boundaries will yield radically different results than a map that calculates density based on county boundaries.
- woile 5y agoi think you can read the map as "the effort each country has done to go green". and then it's valid.
- lbriner 5y agoThe same logic means that they should find it easier to create a solution since they only have to supply a small number of people so I guess it balances out.
- dang 5y agoRelated: Live electricity production/consumption CO2 map - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28223366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28223366 - Aug 2021 (36 comments) ElectricityMap – Live CO₂ emissions of electricity production and consumption - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24747927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24747927 - Oct 2020 (101 comments) Electricity Map – Live CO2 emissions of electricity consumption - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17772529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17772529 - Aug 2018 (71 comments) Live CO2 emissions of electricity consumption - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15998650 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15998650 - Dec 2017 (135 comments)
- olau 5y agoNote that electricitymap.org does not have a complete model of the grid and the involved power plants so the estimates should not be trusted blindly.
- vonadz 5y agoIn regards to plant data, https://findenergy.com/power-plants/ https://findenergy.com/power-plants/ is pretty interesting source, although it's not in real time. We ended up using EPA recommendations for emission coefficients (https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-07/documents/emission-factors_2014.pdf https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-07/documents/em...) but at one point we experimented with using a UN study that had emission factors listed for renewables and nuclear (I think they took into account the construction of plants), and nuclear was at something like 25 KG of CO2/MWh compared to most coal plants that are around 1000 KG of CO2/MWh.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoSo, why does Rocky Mountain both have 78% renewables and the second highest carbon impact of the US? I see that it's using coal, but why so much?
- Reventlov 5y agoI believe something is fishy with the hydro storage number from electricy map, as they report roughly 4000% of hydro storage energy in use (with regards to installed capacity). Would be nice to make some bug report :)
- boringg 5y agoI'm just going to put it out there that this is a great start and has some distance to go depending on its end point. Interesting concept (I have seen iterations of it in the past but maybe not at the whole global level). You'll notice that it strongly favors hydro electricity (for which you can only be blessed with rivers or not) or Nuclear. Things I take issue with: 1. How do you lump all of California under one value given there are 4 large utilities that have their own value but include LADWP and the balancing authority? 2. Since the visualization is by state but not the size of impact it also makes smaller inefficient areas look like they have as large an impact. I do appreciate the flow of electricity across states though. In the end I'm not sure the value prop - is this for policy planners? It's not high quality enough to be for energy trading or asset deployment. I had thought of doing something like this mapping out a couple years ago but couldn't figure out what the exercise was going to do in the end outside of some interesting visualization and then fairly complicated analysis of different energy systems. Either way good work for the people who've got the project to this point.
- kergonath 5y ago> Things I take issue with: 1. How do you lump all of California under one value given there are 4 large utilities that have their own value but include LADWP and the balancing authority? The issue is data acquisition. In regions where they have more granular input, you have a better resolution. > In the end I'm not sure the value prop - is this for policy planners? It’s for outreach and communication with the general public. It’s trivial to put a map on Facebook to show how well/poorly a given place is doing. It’s also interesting to have a quick look depending on the conditions, like the wind turbines output during a storm, or during a heat wave, or to see just how efficient PV production is under various conditions.
- powerbroker 5y agoThe trick with the electric grid, is that you basically have network of leaky plumbing, with pipes of various sizes, with heterogenous congestions throughout. For example, the EIA estimates that the U.S. grids loose some 5% of energy in line losses between the generator(s) and the consumers. On top of that, that in states with high renewables, like Texas, you occasionally have grid congestion that causes wind turbines to curtail, or shut down, in order to balance the generation with the consumer's loads. A rough picture, seemingly updated every 5-15 minutes, of the broader 'nodes' in the U.S. grids can be seen at https://www.eia.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/dashboard/electric_overview/US48/US48 https://www.eia.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/dashboard/electr... Drill down deep enough into the data, and you will unearth the recent tracking of renewables in each of those nodes.
- StillBored 5y agoThe green areas on this map all have one thing in common, they are backed either by hydro or nukes. The large wind providers (notice Texas, central Australia, etc ) are really burning natural gas/etc because the wind is rarely meeting even 50% of its nameplate capacity.
- masklinn 5y ago> wind is rarely meeting even 50% of its nameplate capacity. That’s hardly news though. In the US, the capacity factor of wind averages around 35%. The world over, it can range from 15% (though obviously you’d hope for some analysis before building to avoid locations where it’s that low) to 60% or so (according to the wiki, for Eolo in Nicaragua). Solar is both better and worse: more regular, but less evenly distributed, for PV solar the CF ranges from 20% in the south (e.g. AZ) to 10 when you reach the canadian border.
- pstuart 5y agoWe should be subsidizing home solar installations at 0 percent interest that can power the air conditioning. Everybody wins - less load on the system, people stay cool affordably, and more jobs selling, installing, and maintaining these systems.
- bernardv 5y agoLove the color-blind mode on this map. Well done.