3 ms·
No, Okta also supports various forms of 2FA/MFA, Active Directory integration, LDAP and SCIM user provisioning. Not to mention the fact that even if there are o
by paxys 5y ago
No, Okta also supports various forms of 2FA/MFA, Active Directory integration, LDAP and SCIM user provisioning. Not to mention the fact that even if there are open source alternatives out there, setting up servers, configuring them correctly and managing/updating them isn't exactly a simple enough operation for the average company admin.
- compsciphd 5y agofor companies that are alrady gsuite users, what does okta provide over what one can get with gsuite saml integration?
- paranoidrobot 5y agoGSuite's SCIM options are lacking. So for example if you want to use AWS SSO tied to GSuite, you have to manually manage users, group membership, etc inside AWS SSO. Similarly for a bunch of other products. A couple of companies I've worked for now use GSuite as their primary accounts, and while a ton of things authenticate through GSuite (either as a built-in integration, or as SAML) - when you onboard/offboard users it involves going into a bunch of different systems to create/invite, set up group memberships, and then later deactivate accounts. We're still considering Okta to solve all that workflow stuff. Yes, even after this event. I believe Okta can also do custom security flows that GSuite can't. So, if you're on a trusted device+network, then you might not need a 2FA challenge. Or conversely if you're trying to access a sensitive service - then always require a 2FA challenge every X hours.
- compsciphd 5y agoyes my company makes us do the 2FA every 9 hours for github (so annoying) via okta, though apparently our gsuite logins via okta are much longer lived. though that sort of answers a followup Q, it would seem that there would be a market that punts the authentication to gsuite's saml, but automates the user creation and the like on the different services (and deactivation), but one still wouldn't have the "custom flows" as you said. but if the custom flows aren't that important, I'd rather trust google to handle my authentication than okta, and in my pseudo-okta without authentication scenario, even access to my pseudo-okta would authenticate via google.
- beachy 5y ago> even if there are open source alternatives out there This reads to me like you are unfamiliar with keycloak, which is a very mature and capable solution with plenty of support for everything you mention other than SCIM. Hosting it is not overly challenging, running it in a container would suffice for most companies. Updates are in my experience a smooth process. I'm not claiming it's as easy as an "auth as a service" platform, but as we see, that comes with its own costs.
- ownagefool 5y agoKeycloak supports 2FA/MFA, Active Directory, LDAP. You might need a plugin for SCIM, but it does a whole load of other wonderful things, and it doesn't cost $2 per user per month. You will have to find someone to host and patch it, but we shouldn't pretend it's up there with write your own crypto. Using saas is fine too. Often there cheaper than hiring a person until you need said person anyway, and at that point they're just a single point of failure, and people do underestimate the effort to run a production service well. But we shouldn't be so anti-intellectual that we pretend that it's the only way to do things, and that well supported foss products don't exist.
- matt123456789 5y agoKeycloak has nearly all of this built in. You don’t need to be a crack sysadmin to set it up. If all you need is a 2FA-enabled OIDC endpoint federating to AD/LDAP to serve as SSO you can be up and running quite quickly. [1] 2FA/Time based OTP: https://www.keycloak.org/docs/12.0/server_admin/keycloak-images/otp-policy.png https://www.keycloak.org/docs/12.0/server_admin/keycloak-ima... [2] LDAP/AD (Kerberos) https://dmc.datical.com/z_resources/images/assets/screenshots/administer/keycloak-ldap.png https://dmc.datical.com/z_resources/images/assets/screenshot... [3] SCIM (third party) https://github.com/Captain-P-Goldfish/scim-for-keycloak https://github.com/Captain-P-Goldfish/scim-for-keycloak
- paranoidrobot 5y agoRe SCIM: That plugin is adding a SCIM provider to Keycloak. i.e provisioning/managing users in KeyCloak Most of the time I'm talking about SCIM outbound, so provisioning/managing users in some other random service (like Trello, Github, whatever). That's the major value-add for Okta.
- matt123456789 5y agoI see. Thank you for clarifying. Here’s the author of the Keycloak SCIM plugin on that functionality: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/58566587/does-keycloak-support-scim#comment124235777_61884365 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/58566587/does-keycloak-s... So will likely require some changes to Keycloak internals in order to address that reliability issue, which will enable building a reliable interface for your use case.