4 ms·
When do you think America's political divisions got so tribal? I couldn't tell.
by HWR_14 5y ago
When do you think America's political divisions got so tribal? I couldn't tell.
- thehappypm 5y agoFacebook launched its news feed feature in 2006, and set the stage for a generation of doomscrollers.
- HWR_14 5y agoSo, you don't think there was tribalism pre-2006? I'm just curious, do you remember that time? Was it much better then? I ask because it seems like we have mostly the same politicians (McConnell, Pelosi, Biden, even Trump ran as an independent) as we did then.
- irrational 5y agoI remember pre-2006. I was in my mid-30s by then. I don’t recall much open animosity between Republicans and Democrats. Certainly nothing like today. There was a lot of coming together post 9/11. I do think social media was the main instigator of the country falling into open tribalism.
- pigeons 5y agoI can't think of how to make a more constructive response, but I too remember pre-2006 (that really seems funny to say), and I'm just laughing at your response. The laughing isn't to ridicule it, I just think its truly funny how much I disagree. I guess back then it was talk radio that was blamed for stoking the animosity.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoWhile the tribalism definitely existed back then the amount and openness in which it existed was so much less as to be categorically different. For example, people openly blaming one tribe or the other for some aspect of reality that doesn't even fall nicely along party lines wasn't just a fact of discourse back then like it is now.
- HWR_14 5y agopost-9/11 coming together is an interesting confound. How to you disambiguate a reversion to a more tribal pre-9/11 nature from social media's influence?
- GeekyBear 5y agoIf you are optimizing for keeping eyes glued to screens to deliver more ads, people being hateful to each other is very engaging. This certainly predates social media (tabloids, tabloid television), but social media definitely took things to a new level.
- barry-cotter 5y agoThe broadcast media stopped being the way a huge majority of people got their news starting in the 80s with cable. So the US returned to normalcy, with large portions of the population absolutely hating each other. The post civil war era was also abnormally amicable. Conservative Democrats found it easy to work with liberal Republicans and their constituents would still vote for them out of tribal/regional loyalties. Hating the political opposition is the norm, not the exception.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> Hating the political opposition is the norm, not the exception. Not in a healthy democracy, but I guess that is the exception as well.