6 ms·
The Look of Gentrification
- Lammy 5y ago> No, the neighborhood gentrified because you got here. > Most neighborhoods in the Bay Area, Los Angeles and New York City have been highly gentrified without any major changes to their built environment. It's interesting how the language has gotten reversed on this over the years. As originally defined by Ruth Glass in "London: Aspects of Change" (1964) the word "gentrification" referred to property owners making changes to the built environment to attract middle-class renters, but the new renters themselves weren't the "gentrifiers": https://hakka3.files.wordpress.com/2017/11/glass-aspects-of-change.pdf#page=4 https://hakka3.files.wordpress.com/2017/11/glass-aspects-of-...
- aspenmayer 5y ago> but the new renters themselves weren't the "gentrifiers" I think this is an interesting historical point, though the distinction is somewhat without a difference. Compare gentrifiers to carpetbaggers; carpetbaggers were a specific subset of Northern gentrifiers of the South during post Civil War Reconstruction. We don’t really have carpetbaggers per se anymore, but gentrification is still with us, unfortunately. It just morphed into redlining and urban renewal. As a value neutral process, we can examine its effects, but it doesn’t exist in a vacuum, and it doesn’t occur naturally; those gentrifying do themselves have values, and their actions or lack thereof reflect those values. Gentrification is a consequence of housing being treated as an investment vehicle, instead of being acknowledged as a basic human right.
- AvocadoPanic 5y agoFormer Californians bringing their California money to flyover states and buying stuff? They don't have literal carpetbags. Southpark City People
- aspenmayer 5y agoSpeaking of South Park, this season has to be the best yet. They have really outdone themselves in the satire department.
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoI thought redlining was solved solved. Can you share an example of implicit or explicit redlining (which I interpret to mean realtors, banks, and other institutions enacting policies that restrict black people from purchasing homes in certain areas or neighborhoods. Sorry to ask this sort of question, it’s frankly a pet peeve of mine in internet discourse. In this case though I truly am looking for whatever answer(s) you have handy, cheers
- acdha 5y agoRedlining doesn't have a simple solution — after 1980 or so it was probably not the case that someone would outright be turned down for a mortgage but that bakes in a lot of inherited inequality (your ability to qualify for a mortgage in a pricey part of town, or feel welcome in that neighborhood, will vary depending on your race and your parents' economic status) and there were a lot of dubious practices which followed boundaries based on those historic redlining practices. For example, during the previous mortgage bubble the people targeted by predatory lenders and foreclosed on rather than negotiated with were disproportionately non-white. Just recently there was a lawsuit against Wells Fargo alleging unfair lending practices and given how many examples there have been over the years of different credit scores or loan terms for people who appear quite similar financially, I'd be surprised if there wasn't a fair amount of truth to it: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-19/wells-fargo-sued-by-black-borrower-for-refinance-redlining https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-19/wells-far... The interesting question is whether this is intentional human discrimination or more subtle things like algorithms laundering old historical data. For example, if someone was training a model on borrowers' applications and credit histories versus loan default rates it would not surprise me at all to learn that it picked up on details like traditionally Black neighborhoods, colleges, societies, etc. and used that to “objectively” give a higher risk score because the algorithm doesn't have a way to recognize that many old outcomes were due to things like discrimination at work (“last hired, first fired”), being offered less money for the same job, higher likelihood of bad judicial outcomes (e.g. disparate prosecution rates & sentencing for things people of all races do like use marijuana), etc.
- Zababa 5y agoFocusing on a specific point: > They don’t have to think about the ramifications of searching for homes in a housing market where they’re outbidding lower income people of color. I've thought about this but in a different context, when I was looking for a job. I was a bit troubled by the fact that getting a job meant that someone else wouldn't have it. In the context of a "regular" software engineering job, my reasoning was that it was "okay"/"low impact" because there is a big demand for that job right now, and it's a job where you don't have a big impact on decisions. When buying stuff like a can of tuna or a car, it's usually easier to make the ethical choice because usually there are enough for everyone. But for things like homes and jobs, that may not be the case. This makes me wonder how people handle those kinds of decisions. Maybe giving part of what you earn can help "offset" that? Can the ramifications of one person searching for homes in a housing market where they're outbidding other people be calculated? I hear a lot about "carbon neutral" these days, I wonder if we'll have a "socially neutral" one day.
- janmarsal 5y agoWhy are both gentrification and white flight supposedly bad? I'm a bit of an outsider to this whole topic but to me it seems like a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation. Even if those people just give up and try to isolate themselves from the rest of the society to some middle class concentration camp it's called a "gated community" and also bad.
- Jtype 5y agoBecause people like to complain about change, and people like to blame white people for all of societies ills at the moment.
- danShumway 5y agoThey're not bad at a conceptual level, it's entirely about context. People are looking at a broader pattern where minority communities are largely abandoned or attacked when they have troubles. However, whenever they build something popular or suddenly have something of value, then the spaces they inhabit rapidly evolve to push them out, and (whether purposefully or not) eventually the benefits of whatever infrastructure or invention or good fortune gets thrown their way end up going primarily to white people. You might draw a comparison here to movements like "none of us without all of us" or to conversations about appropriation. My understanding is that they're driven by the same ideas. Subcultures and minority cultures have noticed that they are widely demonized as being too niche or having bad culture, but then whenever they make something popular, that gets absorbed into majority cultures, the majority culture makes most of the profit, and in many cases it's forgotten that it even originated out of the minority/niche culture in the first place. Gentrification and white flight can't be separated from the prevalence of arguments over the "problem" of Black culture and the prevalence of bad-faith arguments (even on HN) about how Black communities need to address their own problems. ---- Two examples, just off the top of my head that might make this pattern clearer: - The Freedom House Ambulance service was the first ambulance service in the entire United States, created to serve Black community members largely by Black community members. They single-handedly revolutionized how paramedics respond to medical emergencies. Once it became clear that ambulances and immediate medical care before (and during) transportation drastically increased survival rates, nearly all of their resources were redirected to majority-white neighborhoods and the communities they were originally trying to serve were left with practically nothing. - Black hair and pride about hair has been a contentious issue among the Black community for ages; kids that let their hair grow naturally were demonized, Black hairstyles were seen as indicative of flaws in Black culture. Black communities fought really hard to see their hair as a point of pride and as a legitimate form of expression that didn't need to be suppressed. At which point the hairstyles started getting adopted outside of Black communities. The problem isn't that the hair styles are being "stolen", it's that none of the demonizing or suppression was ever addressed. Black people were criticized for something that then became wildly popular but the benefits of that thing never work their way back to the community; the stereotypes about their communities persist even after the things they were criticized for are adopted into the wider culture. ---- So conversations about gentrification, white flight, appropriation, etc... make a lot more sense when you view them through that lens. It's not about where white people are allowed to live, it's about selectively benefiting from the best of Black culture and communities while abandoning and demonizing those communities for everything else about them -- sometimes even benefiting from aspects of Black culture that were demonized only a short while ago. It creates a feeling of being "farmed" or "dissected". Black communities that become attractive to white people quickly become white communities (and the people in those communities often end up either displaced or forced to change their culture). Communities that are struggling turn back into Black communities. You talk about feeling like it's a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation, and my understanding is that's also exactly what it feels like in those communities. You can revolutionize American health care, but you aren't going to get the benefits from that. You can fix up a community and start generating business profits and opportunity, but those opportunities aren't going to go to you. And if that community gets messed up or runs into hardship, you're going to get stuck with the bill. There isn't a way to get out from under the rest of society. Even if you build something or create an environment that the majority culture wants -- that doesn't elevate you or your community; they take that thing and then they leave you behind. ---- In contrast, I look at other forms of appropriation, and they don't really bother me that much. I'm a Christian, I heckin love it when I see Christian imagery adapted and cherry-picked out into foreign films from cultures that don't have much Christian influence, because it's fun to see people remix and pull out parts of something I'm familiar with in unfamiliar contexts. Likewise, when I see bad hacker movies that misunderstand computers, that doesn't make me angry, it makes me laugh. If a nontechnical person starts using terminology that originated in hacker spaces, that's great. But I can have that reaction because of the context -- modern Japanese movies and culture aren't demonizing people like me or redirecting resources away from me because I'm a Christian. Likewise, I'm advantaged in my day-to-day life because of my technical competence with computers, not disadvantaged. Not that this is at all the same as gentrification, but in contrast to the above, I do get angry when I see attempts to appropriate Free/Libre software terms to promote non-Libre ideas, even when that appropriation isn't necessarily purposefully malicious. Because I know where that process tends to end up, and I get angry about attempts to pull out the best of FOSS communities and terminology while abandoning the ideals that spurred people to create that software and to evangelize that terminology and create that goodwill in the first place. So it's not that moving into a minority community or moving out of a minority community is inherently bad. It's the context and overall trends. Neutral and even natural actions take on a different tone when looked at as part of a broader system that has predictable effects.
- pc2g4d 5y agoComplaining about gentrification is like complaining about the day being hot and the night being cold. There are reasons for things. Look at those, then adapt.
- pydry 5y ago>Those who fought attempts to grow the housing capacity of our old neighborhood got what they wanted: all the same old houses, parks and stores. But at the expense of the people who had lived there in the first place by trading them for new arrivals. Population growth does not require displacement when you prioritize making space rather than the aesthetic of buildings. This was a side effect of untaxing land (e.g. prop 13). Nobody is going to fight a new development that threatens their home equity more than a newcomer who is up to their eyeballs in mortgage debt. The "aesthetics" of a neighborhood suddenly take on new meaning when you're staring down the barrel of negative equity. This is also why rent control's effect on inhibiting new building is grossly exaggerated (& may even be negative). Getting rid of it pushes up rents which pushes up house prices which ramps up NIMBYism that inhibits housing development. The greatest level of home building in New York coincided with the greatest level of rent control. There is a very clear and identifiable villain in California here for deliberately engineering this situation: Howard Jarvis. He is now dead but his lobbying lives on under the equally villainous Jon Coupal.