3 ms·
Because Tesla knows that the vast majority of people will never need it. Most people use their cars for well under 100 miles per day. With a battery-electric c
by jfengel 5y ago
Because Tesla knows that the vast majority of people will never need it.
Most people use their cars for well under 100 miles per day. With a battery-electric car, you can charge it at home. You never go to a station for anything -- not fuel, not fast-charging, not battery swapping. You come home, plug in, and get on with your life.
People will make a few long trips per year, and those cases are well handled by the supercharger network. It doesn't take long, and corresponds to down-time that most drivers should be taking anyway.
There is nothing for them to gain by a massive redesign that would gain most users little to nothing. Instead, they take the stable battery pack and design around it, even making it a structural part of the vehicle to save weight.
Replaceable battery packs for cars solve a non-problem. People who would want them would do better purchasing a gasoline car, which are readily available and will remain so for quite some time.
- dvirsky 5y ago> you can charge it at home Most people in most big cities don't have private parking they can equip with a charger, and they struggle to even find parking at all. You'd have to make every single parking space in a big city a charger to make this approach scale.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Most people in most big cities ... should use fast chargers, if they have no 'at home' option. Most people in the US live in single family detached homes and can get enough juice from a 120V outlet to meet their daily driving needs.
- dvirsky 5y agoMost of the world is not the US. And fast charging of ~1 hour or even 25 minutes is an inconvenience that would make people choose a non EV.
- rootusrootus 5y agoWe're not far from 15 minute charge times (and in some regards already there). That's fast enough.
- jfengel 5y agoMost people in big cities don't have cars. Most of the cars in a city are commuters, who go home every night to the burbs. It's the same reason cities have relatively few gas stations. People who insist on having cars in cities will either find places to charge, continue to own gas cars, or switch to ride sharing plus public transport. It is not a case for Tesla to change their entire design.
- lkbm 5y ago> Because Tesla knows that the vast majority of people will never need it. I don't know what portion of US drivers park either on the street or in a parking garage, but I'm pretty sure it''s tens of millions of people. Driveways pretty much don't exist in my neighborhood. It's all parking garages and street parking. Lining every parking garage and neighborhood street with dozens of chargers may be the optimal solution, but I'm skeptical.
- avianlyric 5y agoI think people overthink how complicated EV chargers are (specifically slow chargers). At they’re core, they’re just a normal 3-pin plug with a fancy computer controlled switch. All of the heavy lifting is done by the car, it has the inverter, the battery controller, and all the monitoring equipment. All the charger does is tell the car how much power it’s allowed to use, authenticates the car, and flicks the switch on at the command of the car. The charger also has a cheap-as-chips current transformer so it can make sure the car doesn’t consumer more power than it allowed, and will flick the switch off if the car misbehaves. The car is responsible for everything else. So at the end of the day, and on street slower charger is a metal post with a plug on the outside, and a Raspberry Pi and relay inside. They can, and will eventually be, dirt cheap to manufacture. As for power cables, well, and can just slice into the cable already powering houses and lampposts.
- stetrain 5y agoAC slow chargers (for overnight or at work) are cheap and simple. Basically the same as installing an outlet for a clothes dryer or oven with a circuitry box to act as a relay and monitor. DC fast chargers are more complex and expensive but still way cheaper than a robotic mechanical battery swap system that works across multiple makes and models of car. And more of these are being installed literally every day: Tesla: https://supercharge.info https://supercharge.info Others (US): https://fastcharger.info https://fastcharger.info We're getting to the point where many newer EVs are coming with 300+ miles of range that can do an 80% charge in 20 minutes. The swappable batteries seems like a great solution for mopeds etc. but for giant car batteries I think better and cheaper batteries will outpace any advantages that battery swapping has within a few years.
- throw_nbvc1234 5y ago> It doesn't take long Is there public data about how big the network would need to be if 90-100% of long distance travel is switched from 5 min gas station stops to super charging; both in terms of throughput and latency? And/or studies of (probably rare) mass transit events that may or may not be expected; thinking natural disasters and large events away from population centers like burning man or Coachella.