4 ms·
Portrait vs. Landscape has always been an interesting debate to me, especially in the context of filmmaking, a space where, until the advent of TikTok, basicall
by mkaic 5y ago
Portrait vs. Landscape has always been an interesting debate to me, especially in the context of filmmaking, a space where, until the advent of TikTok, basically everyone scoffed at the idea of cinema being vertical -- because, well, physical cinema screens are landscape! But cinema screens are no longer the dominant place people go for movie entertainment -- they watch instead on their smartphones, where they can choose either orientation as they please. This has led to the dawn of vertical cinema, something I find very exciting. I don't know if there will ever be vertical movie theaters (I personally doubt it), but that doesn't mean that there can't be vertical movies that are ever bit as artistically valid and "sophisticated" as their horizontal counterparts!
I've noticed quite a bit of gatekeeping around this topic in filmmaking circles -- people love to act as though horizontal is an innately superior format somehow, and that vertical is only suitable for childish, amateur productions. I think that's a rather myopic take though that doesn't consider the many factors that go into a cinematic viewing experience!
- DHPersonal 5y agoA couple excellent reasons for the gate keeping: panning and group shots are quite difficult in portrait video and are much better handled in landscape. The “uninteresting” elements of the landscape mentioned in the article are the settings for the objects (that often the photographer shot in portrait), and are often seen as essential in photography and films for setting moods and a sense of place.
- mkaic 5y agoCounterpoint -- tilts and shots of people standing up are framed very nicely in portrait. Humans might have widescreen vision, but we are vertical creatures physically. To be clear, I totally think landscape is the correct choice for a lot of things, my original comment was mostly directed at the idea that vertical is somehow not a valid artistic choice.
- LocalH 5y agoDo remember that television got its start as a vertical medium. Mechanical TV scanned vertically in the days of the Nipkow disk.