4 ms·
You keep repeating variations of this: > What OP said is that violent rhetoric against an ethnicity (Russians) is allowed, which is not true. No, that's NOT w
by freedomben 5y ago
You keep repeating variations of this:
> What OP said is that violent rhetoric against an ethnicity (Russians) is allowed, which is not true.
No, that's NOT what I said. And you should know this, as I already told you at least once: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30755880 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30755880
What I actually said:
> Before we all pile on Russia, if you aren't aware of the rule change that FB made to allow violent statements against Russians (but not against any other group), you should learn about that.
I consider members of the Russian military (who, by the way, are mostly there by force, not free choice) to still be Russians. Unless you want to turn my statement into a strawman that you can easily knock down, then you should be making the argument that members of the Russian military aren't Russians.
- rendall 5y ago> I consider members of the Russian military... to still be Russians. therefore FB allows violent statements against Russians This is sophistry and a category error; and even were it arguable, it is literally incorrect. The Russian army is comprised of other ethnicities and nationalities as well. https://www.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-701018 https://www.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-701018 Advocating violence against an invading army: ethical. Advocating violence against members of an ethnicity: reprehensible. Conflating the two, so that people might believe that one is the same as the other: confused at best, if not evil. Which is what you are attempting to do, here. I keep "repeating variations of this" because it is exactly what you wrote. You conflated "Russians" with the "Russian army". When called out on it, you doubled down "Well, Russian soldiers are technically Russians so...." You did that. No one else.