3 ms·
This is just another example of Apple suffering from its own actions. It was all excited about how H.264 was a FRAND standard, ignoring it's own previous statem
by ZeroGravitas 15y ago
This is just another example of Apple suffering from its own actions. It was all excited about how H.264 was a FRAND standard, ignoring it's own previous statements about how such standards could lead to dominant players abusing other parties. But it had a market lead and a business model that fitted with the status quo so it was full speed ahead. And now the shoe is on the other foot.
From Apple's previous statement on this matter:
"While the current draft patent policy does state a “preference” for royalty-free standards, the ready availability of a RAND option presents too easy an alternative for owners of intellectual property who may seek to use the standardization process to control access to fundamental Web standards. A mandatory royalty-free requirement for all adopted standards will avoid this result."
- cube13 15y ago>This is just another example of Apple suffering from it's own actions. It was all excited about how H.264 was a FRAND standard, ignoring it's own previous statements about how such standards could lead to dominant players abusing other parties. If Samsung has granted a license(either with royalties or royalty-free) to everyone else besides Apple, they aren't following the FRAND standard. If they have, and this is a result of negotiations falling apart(which is highly unlikely, considering that these are "essential to the reliable functioning of telecom networks and devices", and the iPhone 1 presumably infringes on these), then Samsung has a case. Otherwise, Samsung may be violating agreements that they have with the standards agencies. This will be pretty interesting how it plays out.
- mattmanser 15y agoThe iPhone 1 won't, it's to do with CDMA which is only the iPhone 4 had as I understand it. The iPhone 4 with CDMA was also only available in the US though and that area is already under litigation. See http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/oct/05/samsung-apple-iphone-4s-ban http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/oct/05/samsung-app... for more info.
- cube13 15y agoThe article states that the patents cover WCDMA, which is apparently one of the standards used by GSM, and the standard that Apple used with the 3GS(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Mobile_Telecommunications_System#W-CDMA_.28UTRA-FDD.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Mobile_Telecommunicat...). CDMA is a superset of that, apparently, and can also apply with certain GSM providers.
- vetinari 15y agoWCDMA is basis for UMTS, which is also called 3G. Plain-old GSM (2G and EDGE) is TDMA-based.