2 ms·
As someone teaching electronics, media technology and programming at a art university I'd argue that the space between those who chose a solution because they d
by atoav 5y ago
As someone teaching electronics, media technology and programming at a art university I'd argue that the space between those who chose a solution because they didn't know it any better and those who considered every available option and made the rational choice is not only big, but the borders are foggy as well.
At least with my students who are usually not experts at electronics, programming or similar things, the chosen solutions are often ridiculously naive. They would probably also work 90% of the time — however they would (and do!) pay that naive approach by gaining an unreliable, expensive, overly complex rube goldberg type of system that falls appart when the stars don't align in just the right way.
People like these are extremely grateful when you sit down with them for a while, analyze their problem, explain some possible solutions to them and then in turn discover that there is a solution that is magnitudes less work, has magnitudes less moving parts and will probably also work in a decade. And you can do that without forcing your language or other strong preferences on them.
There are many companies who chose the solutions they chose because they cannot imagine something else, they only have an employee who does x etc as well — but assuming you can just recommend a thing and everything complicated about the problem would be neatly encapsulated and solved is naive as well.
- oriolid 5y agoFrom the other side of the fence, more often than not when someone offers an open source or COTS replacement to an in-house system the result is that it replaces easily 90% of the functionality, but for the last 10% you need to either serious mental gymnastics to fit your system into the third party system's way of doing things or just put more effort into patching it than doing it from scratch would have needed. Sometimes the 10% is not really needed, sometimes it's the whole reason why the product was built.
- analog31 5y agoTo be fair, this also happens if you switch to a commercial system, or from one commercial system to another. I can't count the number of times I've arrived at a health clinic, and was told: "Please bear with us, we just switched our system to **, and it has effectively shut us down."
- MartinCron 5y agoOr even, "we've just upgraded to a new version of our health system and it has effectively shut us down"
- oriolid 5y agoMedical information systems are the worst, because the poor people who have to use them can't influence the initial choice or development of the thing.