4 ms·
if your site is running on apache with default logging, or a shared host like DreamHost, you are probably not fully in compliance with the letter of the GDPR si
by shadowgovt 5y ago
if your site is running on apache with default logging, or a shared host like DreamHost, you are probably not fully in compliance with the letter of the GDPR since you're logging IP addresses and aren't using them for necessary site operations.
... especially if the log just grows and grows and never rotates. The GDPR is a very wide-reaching law.
Of course, there's no real need to worry since, practically speaking, it was intended as a cudgel to beat FAANG with and not a dagger to stab indies with. If you're comfortable with the safety of your operations being "The folks with legal power to enforce won't wield it on you", you have nothing to worry about.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoThe problem is, they can enforce it on you at any time of their choosing should you do something deemed unpopular or troublesome. While the cudgel was intended for FAANG, the dagger still hangs to stab any indie that gets out of line. Why would I rely on the kindness of government not to enforce a poorly written law?
- shadowgovt 5y agoYour position is mine, which is why I'm surprised at how broad the support for GDPR seems to be around here. "Broad government power is okay as long as they're clubbing the right people" is certainly a mood.
- mariusor 5y agoI don't think "enforce" means what you think it means. If you are contacted about a GDPR matter usually you have time to fix it before it's "a violation" that incurs penalties.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoIt's "squishy" terms in law, like "usually" that I find bothersome. Granted, I haven't read the complete specifics of all of the minutia when it comes to the GDPR, I'll admit. I do keep cookies by default though, as a habit, which seems to be in violation of GDPR rules. Should I start publishing a blog or some such which was antithetical to the prevailing party doctrine, that happened to gain traction with the public, terms like usually tend to go out of the window. Al Capone wasn't indicted on bootlegging after all.
- M2Ys4U 5y agoEnforcement action must be "proportionate", so even if you are pulled up by a supervisory authority it's unlikely they're going to give you a massive fine straight off the bat - especially if you are trying to comply and can demonstrate that.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoI think everyone seems to be missing the point of what I'm saying, and maybe it's my fault. In the defense of the law that people have given to me, so far, the terms "Usually" and "Unlikely" have come up. Neither of those terms are very satisfactory if I write a critical piece critical of the government and am taken to the full extent of the GDPR's breadth, with little ability to fight it, being a small, independent, self published journalist who had a friend set up a server using the default Apache settings(this is an example - I am not). In such a case, a massive fine would not only bankrupt that person but would silence such critical dissension from occurring in a much needed vocal minority. Investigative journalism from non-corporate outlets, through non-corporate outlets is a wonderful thing, which has become a rarity, and has the potentiality of becoming illegal due to clerical mishaps. While I do understand the necessity of a user's privacy, I also understand the necessity of "removing the tumor and saving the leg", to borrow a colloquialism. Broad-brush approaches have quite a few down-stream consequences, which are seldom realized until it's too late. We've only to look at "the war on terror" and the domestic surveillance that came about in the name of "safety" to understand that =/
- Jensson 5y ago> In such a case, a massive fine would not only bankrupt that person At worst you are fined for 4% of your annual income, it wont bankrupt you. No government is going to go through all that hassle just to fine an independent journalist for a paltry sum. If they really wanted that power they would add defamation laws like UK where they can put you in jail for speaking negatively about public figures. And until the thing you fear happens at least once to a small business we can assume it will never happen. In the extremely unlikely event that it really happens you pay a 4% fee of your annual income, that hurts for sure but it isn't life altering.