5 ms·
Before we all pile on Russia, if you aren't aware of the rule change that FB made to allow violent statements against Russians (but not against any other group)
by freedomben 5y ago
Before we all pile on Russia, if you aren't aware of the rule change that FB made to allow violent statements against Russians (but not against any other group), you should learn about that.
The Moscow Court:
> A Moscow court on Monday banned Facebook and Instagram as "extremist" organizations, after authorities accused U.S. tech giant Meta of tolerating "Russophobia" during the conflict in Ukraine.
And that is at least somewhat true by Facebook's own rule[1]:
> “As a result of the Russian invasion of Ukraine we have temporarily made allowances for forms of political expression that would normally violate our rules, like violent speech such as ‘death to the Russian invaders’. We still won’t allow credible calls for violence against Russian civilians,” [2]
Now that said, Russian authorities were already looking for excuses to ban (and I believe already had effectively banned FB), so it didn't really matter. But, FB played into their hands by giving them a (somewhat) legitimate reason.
Note: I'm not making a value judgment here, just stating facts.
[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/mar/11/facebook-and-instagram-let-users-call-for-death-to-russian-soldiers-over-ukraine https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/mar/11/facebook-...
[2]: https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/exclusive-facebook-instagram-temporarily-allow-calls-violence-against-russians-2022-03-10/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/exclusive-facebook-inst...
- NationalPark 5y agoThe reality is a lot narrower than you're implying, however: “We are issuing a spirit-of-the-policy allowance to allow T1 violent speech that would otherwise be removed under the hate speech policy when: (a) targeting Russian soldiers, except prisoners of war, or (b) targeting Russians where it’s clear that the context is the Russian invasion of Ukraine (eg content mentions the invasion, self-defense, etc),” ... Meta spokesman Joe Osborne previously said the company was “for the time being, making a narrow exception for praise of the Azov regiment strictly in the context of defending Ukraine, or in their role as part of the Ukraine National Guard”. Specifically the rule change that FB made to allow violent statements against Russians (but not against any other group) is an overstatement that is not factual, because it implies that violent speech toward Russians is generally tolerated on Facebook.
- freedomben 5y agoWhere did that quote come from? I know that FB took some flack for their rule change and issued a second statement on it that walked things back a bit. Is your quote from that?
- NationalPark 5y agoFrom the article you linked in your comment
- freedomben 5y agoAh yes, that was from the email that they sent to moderators, not part of the (original) public statement (unless I'm misreading). But yes thank you, that's good to point out
- tyrfing 5y agoThe original articles were based on internal emails that Reuters obtained and published without any comment or public statement.
- freedomben 5y agoAh interesting, thank you, I was wondering why the original was impossible to find. I'm going to verify this and then I'll update my original post with this info cause IMHO that's quite relevant.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- myrmidon 5y agoJust out of curiosity (I'm a non-native speaker): Is there a difference between flak and flack? Are these regional variants, maybe a US/UK thing? Would you use either, depending on exact context (literal flak-cannon vs "taking flack" phrasal verb)?
- mrits 5y agoFB did not "play into their hands". Facebook made a sane decision that most corporations are incapable of making. You don't want to ban Ukrainians for talking about killing Russian soldiers, it should be encouraged.
- pessimizer 5y agoWould you want to ban Afghans from talking about killing American soldiers?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoAfghans in Afghanistan? No.
- vkou 5y agoYou wouldn't, but Facebook would. And that's fine, they are allowed to make that decision.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Dharmat55 5y ago
- yucky 5y agoCounterpoint - encouraging the average Ukrainian to "kill Russian soldiers" puts their lives at risk as well since the Russian soldiers are better armed. And lets say they get geeked up and start firing into the street form an apartment building, to which the Russians respond by launching a missile into and killing others who weren't trying to engage the soldiers. The sane response would be to consistently call for non-violent posts only on the platform.
- mrits 5y agoYou certainly fall into the category of good men that do nothing. The rest of us will fight to preserve the freedoms we have and those of others.
- darthrupert 5y agoCalling for death to Russian invaders or dictator Putin is not russophobia, so that whole argument falls flat right there. If the distinction is unclear to you, here's a quick tip: if somebody hates you for what you are, that's racism (or some other form of deplorable hatred). If someone hates you for what you do, that's not racism.
- freedomben 5y agoI never said it was russophobia. that was a quote from the court. > If the distinction is unclear to you, here's a quick tip: if somebody hates you for what you are, that's racism (or some other form of deplorable hate). What if somebody hates you for something that another person of your race did, but that you personally didn't do, especially if you personally radically oppose it? Is that racism?
- darthrupert 5y agoYes, that's racism. But also yes, it's easy to imagine situations where the distinction isn't that trivial anymore.
- true_religion 5y agoSure that’s racism. However, I don’t see much evidence of radical opposition to war from people in the Russian military. And even if there were some, it would still be fine to call for a fight against the majority who are obediently serving. Merely having an ethnicity, can’t be your shield if your military sieges cities and bombs them.
- xdennis 5y ago> allow violent statements against Russians Nonsense. It's against Russian invaders, which makes complete sense. When they come in to bomb schools and maternity wards how else are you going to stop them without killing them? The Russians are acting like victims even when they're Nazi invaders.
- vkou 5y agoI don't think[1] FB had any problem with banning people who made 'violent statements'[2] against coalition forces in, say, Iraq. There is an obvious contradiction in social media rules about violence. Encouraging violence = bad. A politician encouraging violence (By drumming up support for a war) = good. Wishing death and ruin upon our soldiers = bad. Wishing death and ruin upon enemy soldiers = good. It's perfectly fine to be partial about this sort of thing (Facebook does not exist in some weird non-political, non-aligned space - it is an American company, with a large overlap with a broadly western worldview), but once you are, you do need to accept that you are serving as a propaganda organ. [1] But I don't know for sure. [2] I mean, there's a wide range of things that are encompassed by this.
- freedomben 5y ago> Nonsense. It's against Russian invaders, Are you saying that "Russian invaders" aren't "Russians" ?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoOf course Russian invaders are Russians. But it's against them as invaders, not against them as Russians. What do you want? A way of opposing the invasion that doesn't involve shooting the invaders? That would be nice, but we don't have one of those. (Putin does - he could order a withdrawal right now if he chose.) So if we're going to do more than say "tsk, tsk" in response to the invasion, it's going to involve killing invaders. And those invaders happen to be Russians, so it's going to involve killing Russians - not because they're Russians, but because they invaded Ukraine. This is all really obvious. I can't tell if you're just being super pedantic, or if you're trying to obscure reality.
- 5y ago
- tomjen3 5y agoThey didn't allow that, they only allowed attacks on Russian soldiers.
- rendall 5y ago> ...change that FB made to allow violent statements against Russians. Yeah, that's not what happened. Not sure what your deal is, but you yourself know that's not what happened given your own quote.
- freedomben 5y agoAre soldiers in the Russian army not Russians? Do you consider members of your country's army to be fellow citizens of your country? Or do you think of them as different?
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoLet's imagine the issue is about gay people who murder their partners. Reframing it as "against gay people" might be technically true, but factually incorrect.
- freedomben 5y agoThanks that's an interesting point. I'll have to think on that a bit.
- pphysch 5y agoThat's a contrived reframing. Why not have the issue be about "people who murder their partners"? What does their sexuality have to do with anything? If someone made your issue, I would immediately assume it was a veiled act of prejudice (e.g. replace "gay" with "Black"). A more honest reframing would be VK allowing/encouraging people to say "Death to America" and death threats against American soldiers, due to illegal invasions in Afghanistan/Iraq/Libya/Syria/etc. How do you think Western governments would respond to that, if it became a big deal?
- rendall 5y agoThe OPs claim is that allowing violent rhetoric against the Russian army is anti-Russian. True or not, how "Western governments would respond to" allowing violent rhetoric against US soldiers, isn't relevant to that claim. And, no, violent rhetoric against an invading national army is not equivalent to violent rhetoric against an ethnicity. The idea is offensive.
- giaour 5y agoYou're trying to unfairly paint Facebook as having crossed a Rubicon with this decision. If the rules banned any exhortation to or glorification of violence, recruiting ads for the armed forces would have never been permitted. If Facebook forced itself to be blind to the difference between criminal violence and acts of war, Al Qaeda, Isis, and extra-legal militia groups would have been allowed to advocate for their violent ends. There is nuance to take account of here, and "just stating facts" is either a naive or disingenuous way to engage.
- freedomben 5y ago> You're trying to unfairly paint Facebook as having crossed a Rubicon with this decision. No, I'm not, and frankly I don't appreciate the assumption of bad faith. My personal opinion is that FB made a good decision, and I support it. But I don't want to pretend that everything is completely binary and/or happens in a vacuum. I strongly believe that if humanity is to move beyond our current hyper-polarization, we need a renewed interest in separating facts from beliefs/opinions/perception. Please point out any of the facts that I have that are incorrect. If you're arguing a similar position of most modern journalists that facts themselves aren't enough because people might reach incorrect conclusions with them, so we need to editorialize a bit to ensure people reach the "right" conclusion, then we have a philosophical disagreement. I'll still assume good faith on your part though, something you aren't willing to do for me.
- giaour 5y agoIt's the parenthetical "but not against any other group" assertion you made that is factually incorrect. Facebook repeatedly allowed statements celebrating military defeats of Isis and urging the local population to resist. These statements came from the then-president of the US and were not something that just flew under the radar. > No, I'm not, and frankly I don't appreciate the assumption of bad faith. I did not assume bad faith, and if you reread my comment, you will see that I said your position was either naive or disingenuous. My hunch is that the former is accurate and that another party that made the argument in bad faith in the hopes of taking advantage of others' naivete.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slibhb 5y agoIt's very odd to see a company release an statement containing the sentence "death to the Russian invaders". No company run by adults would trip over that wire. The policy itself aside, there's no reason to provide that specific example.