4 ms·
what if the miners are hostile to you and censor the transaction.
by paulpauper 5y ago
what if the miners are hostile to you and censor the transaction.
- Laforet 5y agoIn that case you are screwed. The odds of every single validator turning against an individual is slim, however Ethereum is not above the act of rewriting history to undo certain transactions. They already did it once with the DAO hack and the market barely moved an eyelid when the supposedily permissonless and irrevocable world computer moves to protect those who are too big to fail.
- aemreunal 5y agoIt really doesn't seem slim to me. This article [0] (which was previously discussed on HN [1]) found that "just 0.1 percent of miners (about 50 operations) are responsible for half of all mining output". So it seems like a very real threat to me. I rarely hear anyone pro-crypto talk about this implicit assumption they make about the mining being "sufficiently distributed & diverse". [0]: https://www.techspot.com/news/91937-bitcoin-largely-controlled-small-group-investors-miners-study.html https://www.techspot.com/news/91937-bitcoin-largely-controll... [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29008910 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29008910
- emerged 5y agoWhat’s so bad about a bunch of shady companies in China having the capacity to completely take over a massive global financial system?
- always2slow 5y agoThen other miners who aren't will do it for the money. But really it's the pools who would decide and as long as they don't control 51% of the network hashrate they can't dictate. Also the miners can just take their ball and go home, and they already have see: Ethereum Classic
- vvillena 5y ago51% of miners need to be censoring you. If not, the transaction will eventually get in.
- paulpauper 5y agowhich is just 2 of them
- vvillena 5y agoPlease respect the HN guidelines: this response makes clear that you were not asking a question, but fishing for debate. Let's be better.
- newswasboring 5y agoAllow me to be better. Top 3 mining pools control >51% of the hashrate today[1]. I can see 3 teams aligning to do whatever they want. I understand the standard argument is those pools actually represent thousands of individual miners, but the miners only have control over mining, not the selection of transactions (please correct me if I am wrong). edit: [1] https://etherchain.org/miner https://etherchain.org/miner
- vvillena 5y agoYou are right. Whoever controls the pool controls what goes into the mined blocks, so there's a chance they could cooperate to forbid certain types of transactions. Mining empty blocks in Ethereum is something that happens from time to time too, but usually, mining pools want to include as many transactions as possible in their blocks, as this increases profits. So yeah, it can happen in theory. However, the move to PoS will probably change this, as a valid block containing a "banned" transaction can't be easily disputed even by a majority, as long as the block is correct. The only way to try to fight it is to burn lots of ETH, meaning any pool that engages in such behavior becomes weaker.
- 5y ago