It's sort of unsurprising that "thedroidguy" like the Droid better than the iPhone. Also, his chart seems to only highlight (literally, in blue) the places whe

It's sort of unsurprising that "thedroidguy" like the Droid better than the iPhone. Also, his chart seems to only highlight (literally, in blue) the places where the Galaxy S II wins - notice how the Galaxy win in screen size is highlighted but the iPhone win in resolution isn't. He also makes implicit value judgements and doesn't tell you. For instance, both phones are on AT&T and Sprint, but the Droid is marked the winner of the category because its 3rd carrier is T-Mobile while the iPhone's 3rd carrier is Verizon. All the above said, as someone in the market for a phone, there are more relevant factors that are too specific to the individual for a website breakdown. For instance, I spend 8 hours in a pre-war building with sub-optimal cell service and most of the rest of my day in the suburbs outside of 4g coverage, so 4G isn't crucial to me (but is to other people). Similarly, how much the overall plan costs per month may determine which carrier, which has an impact on which phone. A $10/month difference in calling plan prices is $240 over the life of the contract, swamping any difference in phone price. Or you may need a phone which works with Linux/iTunes/whatever, which also limits your decision. There are a lot of these factors which vary person to person and make it impossible for anyone to say which is the best phone in all circumstances for all people.