4 ms·
There's been a big shift in the whole software industry from "enable what the user wants to do" over to "we want the user to do this". Back in the '90s, we woul
by ryandrake 5y ago
There's been a big shift in the whole software industry from "enable what the user wants to do" over to "we want the user to do this". Back in the '90s, we would go out, talk to customers, find out their needs, gather requirements, and write software that enables them to do what they want to do. Now, in a lot of software companies, it's the opposite. Product leadership starts with "What do we want users to do?" and then every software decision is in service of encouraging / forcing / channeling users' behavior into these paths. I've sat in product meetings where people would just say "No, the user should not be allowed to do ABC, we (Company) need them to do XYZ!" It's arrogance, it's hubris and it's everywhere.
The slogan "Where do you want to go today?" is dead. It's now all "This is where we will let you go today!"
- srvmshr 5y agoThat misguided notion of product features and integration, where the user has minimum role, started out at Apple. The standard pattern used to be talking to OEMs and discussing what users wanted from them. That review phase generated update ideas for next release and so on. Apple turned that question on its head and made it "the one last thing" show business. We have employed a generation of PMs now who idolize Steve Jobs' mantra: "Users dont know what they want until you show it to them". EDIT: We does not mean I am employed by Apple. It signifies the general trend for companies to enable product development by PMs
- devmunchies 5y ago> We have employed a generation of PMs now who idolize Steve Jobs' mantra: "Users dont know what they want until you show it to them". just because a bunch of dumb PMs are pushing hot garbage to the user doesn't mean that statement is false. There almost always IS a way to improve and innovate a user experience—a new experience that the user hasn't thought of before. Its just that the PM incentives aren't aligned with the users these days.
- srvmshr 5y agoThat is a good observation. The whole GTalk-Hangout-Chat saga at Google is testament to that misguided ideology.
- thereddaikon 5y agoAgreed. I think it was Henry Ford who said that if he had asked customers what they wanted, they would have told him a better horse. Innovation is the act of giving the users something they didn't know what they want. But that's not what these anti-user dark patterns are. They are the end result PMs trying to hit their KPIs by any means necessary. And those happen to not track things like users satisfaction and trust.
- astrange 5y agoNote that Apple doesn’t have PMs.
- freedomben 5y agoAbsolutely, although something that really grinds my gears is that there's sometimes this weird Orwellian lie that they really start to believe, that they actually are doing it "for the user." There's something deeply disturbing about mass group delusion.
- Gigachad 5y agoThe skype thing kinda makes sense. People want software which just works without configuration. When you sign in to an iphone or macbook, it immediately sets up facetime which is always active waiting for a call in the background. No one complains because this is expected and it has always happened. But then Microsoft wants to give their users the same conveniance as Apple users get with their "just works" setup and people call it user hostile and malware. It makes perfect sense that users would like a way to call other windows users in a way that doesn't involve installing things and fiddling around with more accounts/configuration.
- kyriakos 5y agoI see your point but maybe the reactions are because most of these efforts feel half baked? For example they are forcing teams on users, which I use as a daily driver at my work and I feel that it's the worst piece of software I have to use. On top of that the way things are integrated always looks and feels forced. Like going into lengths to hide control panel in windows 10 even if it's still there and while the settings app which replaces it only has a fraction of the functionality.
- Gigachad 5y agoI agree it’s an implementation issue. Windows always feels like annoying nagware while macOS and iOS largely get out of your way. Teams would pop up with a window on every boot to annoy you while FaceTime just sits in the background. But the power users on this site would rather we have some kind of advanced configuration page where every single feature of windows should be opt in. While simultaneously praising the Apple “just works” system.
- vladvasiliu 5y ago> While simultaneously praising the Apple “just works” system. Because included into that "just works" system is just leaves you alone. Maybe if the "helpful" Windows feature wouldn't nag all the time, as you put it, the power users wouldn't complain about it and look for ways to turn it off. I've been using a Mac for more than 10 years now without an iCloud account. It asked me once whether I wanted one, when I bought the computer new, I said no, and it's left me alone ever since. And I went through I don't know how many "major" upgrades. Windows bugs me all the time. So there's really no reason for me to complain about FaceTime, or whatever. I don't even know it's there if I don't go looking for it specifically. Whereas Windows, it's in my face, all the time. So there's a direct benefit for me to look for ways to shut that crap down. Maybe, just maybe, if Teams isn't installed it will shut up and leave me be. At least until the next update brings it back...
- zaphirplane 5y agoIt’s probably driven by all the unicorns and massive tech companies that got where they are by building what they think the customers will want. Not defending, but I do recall the ford quote of “If I’d asked customers what they wanted, they would have said ‘a faster horse’”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- numpad0 5y agoI guess the ultimate goal is profit, and strategy was implementing what users wanted. “Strategy is how not what” etc etc. The goal is now growth, not even profit, and control over users is strat. What comes next? Jerk(2nd derivative of speed, rate of acceleration changes)? — the speed at which users conform a platform? Capitalism is so ripe for disruption, or innovation, it seems!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoIndeed. One need only look at something as simple as UI styling to see the drastic difference. It used to be that the user could set every aspect of the UI widgets to pretty much whatever they wanted in terms of color, don't, and size. It wasn't even really noteworthy to come across someone who used italic comic sans in their title bars on a purple and green widget scheme. Nowadays getting a bespoke dark mode for applications is an advertisement worthy feature.