5 ms·
I'll be replacing an aging (1950's) boiler this summer. I would love to get an air-source hydronic heat pump (air-to-water heat pump). Even with a $10K rebate,
by sokoloff 5y ago
I'll be replacing an aging (1950's) boiler this summer. I would love to get an air-source hydronic heat pump (air-to-water heat pump).
Even with a $10K rebate, it's far more cost-effective to go with a modern gas boiler (which has its own $2750 rebate) and I have no worries of ~72 hours/year of being unable to maintain temperature. (That's not that big of a worry for me and wouldn't be a blocker, but it's a small inconvenience.)
Basically, the heating contractors know the rebate amounts and, unsurprisingly, bake that into their bids. I can't really blame them for following the incentives, but it means that the energy-savings incentives don't have the intended effect.
- bertil 5y agoThe incentives are encouraging people in trades to learn about how to set-up such pumps and encourage their clients to get one. That sounds like it’s working as intended.
- sokoloff 5y agoThat's a fair point! By the time it gets to the end user's financials though, a modern gas boiler still ends up being far more attractive economically (in the land of $0.20/kWh electricity), which undermines the pace of the transition.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWhen the air-source heat pump is coupled to a good size PV array, the attractiveness equation starts to look a little different. You are never going to generate your own gas; even if you can't generate all the electricity you need for heating, you can generate a notable chunk of it (and banking summer-time excess generation can reduce your heating bills to close to zero).
- syshum 5y agoNot every lot, or every location is good for PV, further lots of utilities are working very hard to make net-metering very unattractive. They do not want to pay home owners Retail prices for electricity (and I do not blame them)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoNote: the common use of net-metering tends to involve paying the property owner cash in return for excess production, and this is definitely facing opposition. However, there are sometimes (often?) alternatives in which the utility banks excess production and trades it during times of low production on a 1:1 basis. I have not read that this sort of scheme faces the same sort of opposition from utilities (and some legislators) as "cash for kW".
- hedora 5y agoSome states allow for community net metering, where your neighborhood goes in on some solar/batteries, and the production counts toward everyone's bill. This is great for apartment dwellers / condos / low income areas, because you can structure the finances of the initial investment to look a lot like having the individual/business installing the equipment being paid retail for the surplus power.
- skybrian 5y agoCould you keep the old gas boiler as backup for the heat pump?
- sokoloff 5y agoI wouldn't keep the 1950s one, but under the terms of the rebate program, you are allowed to keep a functioning combustion boiler for extreme weather conditions; you just need to install a properly interlocked thermostat control to ensure the heat pump carries all the load when it's capable to do so. (They have a small supplemental rebate for the interlock thermostat as well.) If I went that route, I'd install a brand new small boiler (or more likely an electric resistance boiler). It wouldn't take much to take that concern entirely off the table. 30K BTU/hr (9kW) would do it, a 9kW electric boiler is cheap to buy (~$1200), and on the 3 days a year where it would be used, it would have a COP of 1.0 while the heat pump would have a COP of probably 1.5-1.6, so you're not giving up that much efficiency to make it a decision driver. Then, you also have emergency backup heat if the heat pump is temporarily down as well.
- hedora 5y agoMost central HVAC heat pumps have an option to use built in gas or resistive heating as a backup. I'd be surprised if these boilers do not.
- sokoloff 5y agoThere is no such option built into these air-to-water heat pumps, mostly because they don't have to put it in the unit like an air handler would. Instead, the answer is to put whatever supplemental resistance elements you need in an external boiler or in a buffer tank with immersion elements, either of which is easily added (because it's just water piping and pumps). https://www.nordicghp.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/001850SPC-04-ATW-65-HACW-Two-Stage-R410a-60Hz.pdf https://www.nordicghp.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/001850S...