4 ms·
* ... not by pumping cool air in, but by pumping warm air out.* Technically not correct. A heat pump does not pump air in/out of a building. It pumps a refri
by jqpabc123 5y ago
* ... not by pumping cool air in, but by pumping warm air out.*
Technically not correct. A heat pump does not pump air in/out of a building. It pumps a refrigerant around in a closed loop. Part of this loop is inside and part is outside.
When used for heating, the efficiency of a heat pump system declines as the outside temperature drops. At a temperature of around 32F, a heat pump essentially becomes useless. As a result, most have an auxiliary fallback heat source.
- lasson 5y agoHow do freezers work if heat pumps stop working at 32F?
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoFreezers use a different refrigerant that gives them a different working temperature range. Additionally, for proper efficiency the key components of the system need to be sized for your target temperature and the temperature range of your ambient air.
- jqpabc123 5y agoWith heat pump systems, "inside" is the temperature being controlled. "Outside" is uncontrolled --- it's where heat is being dumped to or pulled from. Don't confuse the two. The efficiency of a home heat pump declines as the air temperature outside the home drops. A freezer is working in reverse so it's efficiency declines as the air temperature outside the freezer box rises. Neither a heat pump in an Alaskan winter nor a freezer sitting on a Florida back porch in summer are operating very efficiently.
- MauranKilom 5y agoI believe the point was that both a pump for heating in winter as well as a fridge/freezer try to move energy from the colder to the warmer side. Seeing as freezers can successfully extract energy from the side that is below freezing, it stands to reason that the same should be possible for a "keep your home warm, even in winter" heat pump. Now, the original claim of "heat pumps don't work below freezing" is trivially wrong (and so the question by lasson was justified), but the overall point is that heat pump efficiency gets worse the more you need it in the case of keeping your home warm.
- jqpabc123 5y agoSeeing as freezers can successfully extract energy from the side that is below freezing... Invalid assumption. Whether it can or not depends on the environment. Most ordinary freezers are designed to operate within a relatively luxurious temperature controlled in-door environment. Stick one in the sun on a Florida back porch in August and you may well discover it can no longer successfully "extract energy from the side that is below freezing". Same thing (only in reverse) can happen with a home heat pump in an Alaskan winter. There is another important element here --- energy loss and insulation. At a certain temperature (whatever it may be), the energy lost to the surroundings will start to exceed the capacity of the heat pump. At some point; speaking in practical terms, the heat pump becomes essentially worthless. You need either a bigger heat pump or you need more insulation to stop the loss --- both of which cost money and can't be obtained/installed immediately.
- Siecje 5y agoWhen the heat pump can't keep up you use resistance heating in the air handler. Since this only runs for a short period of time it doesn't make a big difference in cost.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DiabloD3 5y agoOlder ones stop working at around 32F. Modern ones meant for colder climates start losing efficiency at 0F. I live in Maine, we rarely get nights that are subzero, my heat pump works fine except for those 3 or 4 nights out of the year. The heat pump dramatically decreased my power bill vs baseboard electric.
- sokoloff 5y agoHeat pumps in heating mode lose efficiency on a continuous (with lowering temperature) basis; the colder it is outside and/or the hotter output (air or water) you want to get from the unit, the lower efficiency they have. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/e-efficiency-of-an-Air-Source-Heat-Pump-at-different-ambient-air-temperatures-and-with_fig1_266471673 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/e-efficiency-of-an-Air-S...
- teruakohatu 5y agoThat is true, but the curves have improved dramatically since 2006 (when that graph you linked to was posted). At 0C they are still much more efficient than electric.
- lsaferite 5y ago> At 0C they are still much more efficient than electric. Are you referring to resistive heating?
- derkoe 5y agoCan confirm that. Our heat pump (cheap all-in-one, 8 years old) works down to -10°C (14°F) without issues. Modern ones work down to -20°C (-4°F). Water based heat pumps work with any outside temperature. In any case a heat pump is the cheapest way to heat a building.
- sokoloff 5y ago> In any case a heat pump is the cheapest way to heat a building. That very much depends on the cost of your electricity and fuel. In MA, where I pay about $0.20/kWh and around $1.60/therm (both delivered), natural gas is around 2/3rds the cost of a heat pump in the coldest months (and loses only slightly in the shoulder months, when the heat pump is more efficient but you don’t have as much heat loss).
- wernerb 5y ago33F is 0 degrees celcius for those lucky enough to have enjoyed the metric system
- michaelcampbell 5y agoWell, 32F is 0C if we're going to go that route.
- yardshop 5y agoWell, also, 33F converts to 0.55555(etc)C, so if one's device didn't show fractional degrees and didn't round normally, 33F would look like 0C. But yes, 32F is 0.0C.
- arpinum 5y agoModern heat pumps, for example by Mitsubishi and sold in the UK, maintain a COP > 2.5 at -7C.
- earleybird 5y agoIf you have more details I'd certainly appreciate it. We're running a now 25 yr old whole house forced air system - 4 ton. Fuzzy memory but as I recall it probably has a CoP of around 16 with defrost cycles when the temp goes below +5C. It has been mostly maintenance free for those 25 years excepting on time when it started icing up - needed a recharge of refrigerant as it seemed to be a bit low - tech figured a slow leak somewhere but never found it. The system works fine and my best guess is that it is somewhere around 3:1 in favour of heat pump over resistive heat (electric baseboard or radiant panels).