3 ms·
As a corollary to this: it's perhaps not surprising that the remaining conflict we do see is spearheaded by our increasingly aged heads of state, men and women
by woodruffw 5y ago
As a corollary to this: it's perhaps not surprising that the remaining conflict we do see is spearheaded by our increasingly aged heads of state, men and women who grew up in the shadow of WW2 and the peak of the Cold War.
- simonh 5y agoYet in the article he says “ The upside is that — and this is admittedly a strange time to suggest it — the world is going to be a lot less violent”. Saddam Hussein was hardly a teenager when he invaded Kuwait, and Putin is no spring chicken. I don’t know what the answer is, but I suspect this guy doesn’t either. It’s a shame though, since the collapse of the Soviet Union the share of the worlds population dying in warfare has collapsed. It was already on a strong downward trend after the end of WW2. Let’s hope Ukraine is an outlier.
- ilammy 5y agoI think woodruffw meant that the conflict in the Old World might be spearheaded by those people who still have a romantic infatuation by war, which has been steadily declining since like WW1 but manages to hold on in some capacity to these days. Eventually we'll get to the point where people – contemporary young people, future born people – would not see physical violence as a means of settling political disagreements. Partly because they would know how precious life is in a low-fertility environment.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoEver heard of a Second Congo War? Of course, not. Who ever cares about what happens in Africa, right?
- simonh 5y agoYes I have, it was horrible with millions dead. Few wars are not horrible whether in Africa or anywhere else. The fact remains that globally deaths per 10k people due to war was in serious decline at that time.
- selectodude 5y agoAfrica is one of the few places that doesn't have a birthrate problem.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoBecause they have a very high child mortality. When child mortality goes down, birthrates plummet.
- ffwszgf 5y agoUltra orthodox women in Israel have the highest life expectancy and a negligible child mortality rate but they’re having more kids than any African country. Oman is a fairly developed country and they have twice as many kids per woman compared to poor Ukraine and almost-starving North Korea. Cultural background is a huge influence in fertility. African immigrants in Europe have more children the poorer they are, the opposite of locals.
- simonh 5y agoThe birth rate in Oman has collapsed since the 90s to a bit above replacement level. You’re right about the Haredi though. Congratulations, on a discussion of demographics across billions of people, you found one community of less than 2 million that buck the trend. Good for you. Cultural background can have an influence, sure, but generally not enough to have a macro level effect. Hence the global trend.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Tepix 5y agoPutin was born in 1952. If he were 10 years older he his first hand experience of the terror of war might have prevented him from starting this one.
- kurthr 5y agoKim Jong Un is not old (nor his sister). Putin was only 8 during the Cuban Missile Crisis so he only sees a caricature. I'm not sure a younger generation growing up without fear of nuclear war is a safer thing. I suspect that most of the current heads of state being old and belligerant is correlation rather than causation. Don't worry, there will be inexpensive automated drones to do the killing soon enough.
- woodruffw 5y agoKim Jong Un is a funny case. There's a reason we call North Korea the "hermit kingdom." Putin was a child during the missile crisis, but he cut his teeth in the KGB of the 70s and 80s. His mentors and leaders were, in all likelihood, veterans of the Great Patriotic War. (To be clear: I don't think that the risk of war ends with the deaths of these particular generations of leaders. But I do think we're seeing a particularly outmoded approach to war at the moment.)
- ThrowawayR2 5y ago> "(To be clear: I don't think that the risk of war ends with the deaths of these particular generations of leaders. But I do think we're seeing a particularly outmoded approach to war at the moment.)" It will still be older people calling the shots, since they have had time to accumulate power and rise in the ranks, but the risk of war increases with the elders of future generations because they have no direct experience or cultural memory of its horrors; "Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it."