3 ms·
I invite you to drive three or four hours north of Toronto and see for yourself. Or just Google image search "Canadian shield", I think it will become clear to
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
I invite you to drive three or four hours north of Toronto and see for yourself. Or just Google image search "Canadian shield", I think it will become clear to you. It's beautiful country, BTW. But not farm country. (I personally would welcome the challenge, but my wife and kids would probably not appreciate it)
It's a thin layer of top soil overtop of granite, often exposed. a) it's variable terrain and mostly not level and full of exposed rocks, so not suitable for mechanized agri. Just getting a house built there with a well or basement often involves dynamite b) Trees roots can penetrate nooks and crannies most agri crops can't. c) the soil pH is wrong, it's quite acidic in spots.
It goes on like that for probably more than 1/2 of the Canadian land mass BTW.
- hervature 5y agoAs somebody who grew up 5 hours north of Toronto where the primary industry is agriculture, I find this incredibly insulting. Do you think a picture in a textbook exemplifies the entire region? Go look at satellite photos of the triangle Ville-Marie, Rouyn-Noranda, and Val-d'Or and tell me what you see? It will be nothing but farmland and this is in the dead center of the Canadian shield.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoI'm not surprised that there are areas in the Canadian Shield where soils are deeper - the Shield is very old, and erosion is a thing, and soils collect in lower lying areas. I'm guessing that the area you're describing has a lot of lakes, or swamps, or both. Might be a bunch of drainage schemes put in place to make waterlogged soils useful for agriculture? One swallow doth not a summer make. And one hollow doth not a viable agricultural soil over an entire geological structure make. (Obviously there's more than one place in the Shield where deeper soils are present).
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoWhatever, I never said anything about it being 100% monolithically seas of exposed granite. I've been around Northern Ontario and seen plenty of farmland, but it's the exception to the rule and that can be clearly seen in satellite maps. BTW that area looks neat. I'd like to visit. But it does look like the farmland there is a product of a low lying lake basin, maybe sedimentary deposits left over after glaciation? And sticks out like a sore thumb from the surrounding area. (EDIT: just read up on the "Timiskaming Graben"... cool!) I do think, on the whole, northern Ontario stands to do better out of climate change than many other places in the world.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoHa, if that graben underlies the area under discussion, then I feel very vindicated about a comment I just posted.