6 ms·
> Lines 1, 2 and 3, together, uniquely determine special and general relativity, cosmology, the Hilbert Lagrangian and Einstein's field equations, as told here.
by gus_massa 5y ago
> Lines 1, 2 and 3, together, uniquely determine special and general relativity, cosmology, the Hilbert Lagrangian and Einstein's field equations, as told here.
This is a huge exaggeration.
For example 1 says "W=∫L" but L is never defined. The definition of L hides a lot of details, in particular that each point of the universe is equivalent, so there is translation invariance that using the Noether's theorem implies the conservation of momentum.
There are many definitions of L, for example if you are analyzing bead that locked to a circular wire, it's usual to define L with a coordinate that follows the shape of the wire. There are also definitions of L in spherical coordinates, where each coordinate is different. Anyone with a Major in Physic has nightmares about the posibilites to define L.
For example in 2 "v ≤ c" can be true in a stupid universe where the force is bounded and there is enough friction everywhere. Imagine a universe that is full of "water" or "aether" or other magical thing with magical friction. And for some reason the force is bounded, for example like the post says in 3 "F ≤ c4/4G"
Also, I can't imagine how it is possible to rediscover all thermodynamics from "S ≥ k" in item 5.
- nimish 5y agoIt's also wrong: the path must be a stationary point of the action, not minimal. In GR you maximize proper time to get geodesics.
- PrettyPebble 5y agoFor deriving special and general relativity, see https://www.motionmountain.net/maximumforce.html https://www.motionmountain.net/maximumforce.html The page also cites the papers proving the statement.
- user-the-name 5y agoThat page has zero words about actually deriving anything.
- PrettyPebble 5y agoSee Physical Review D 104 (2021) 124079. Html page is updated.
- didericis 5y agoThese kinds of comments block me from doing a physics dive; I don’t know where to start/am worried about starting from a bad point. I don’t know whether to follow some of the trails the linked author has laid out if I want to learn more, whether you’re nitpicking, or whether you’re advocating for a much better approach that starts with the details you say this obfuscates. When I was younger and had more time I’d be willing to eat the inefficiency, and the bigger reason for not doing a deep dive is the difficulty, my own laziness, and lack of practical need, so take what I’m saying with a grain of salt, but the time needed to parse criticism like this to see whats legitimate and whats not drives me a bit nuts. I’ve done enough self learning to know that there is no perfect starting point/backtracking is inevitable, but something about the modern intellectual landscape feels very noisy/jargony and particularly prone to inefficient learning. When you say “there is translation invariance that using the Noether's theorem implies the conservation of momentum”, I have no idea what that means. It sounds like a description of a turbo encabulator. I’m sure its not, and that your description is much more efficient than spelling it out from the ground level, but it annoys me how difficult it is to distinguish between a legitimate domain expert jargon meant to condense complexity and unnecessarily obfuscatory jargon that works more like a status/club membership symbol. Maybe its always been like this somewhat and that problem is inevitable, idk.
- posterboy 5y agoPhysics is most illustrative in experimentation and good enough approximations. None of the above plays a role in undergrad as far as I can tell, unless perhaps if going for ivy league. There is a very good starting point following the historic developments, maybe iron age stuff, a bit of platonic philosophy, including logic, rhethorics and philology on an a-level level. purely theoretical physics is rather math heavy final year, post grad stuff.
- hither_shores 5y agoThe linked page is crankery, but most of the physics it's vaguely gesturing at is standard undergrad material. QFT is not, but it's not too far out of reach either.
- 5y ago
- amluto 5y agoOof. I don’t see how you recover any of thermodynamics. S ≥ k is a really odd axiom to start with. It certainly doesn’t superficially imply the second law. It’s also rather at odds with the usual statistical formulation in which the entropy of a system in its unique ground state (or simply a system without meaningful microscopic states) is zero. Imagine trying to describe the behavior of a single (idealized) particle in a box using this law — you would get very confused very quickly. For non-physicists: you can model a gas as a bunch of almost entirely non-interacting particles in a box. You can assume that there is some way for them to exchange energy, but you don’t need any details at all of how that works. With some care (and IMO a really fascinating series of arguments) you can derive the ideal gas law and a whole lot of useful thermodynamics. As a first hack at reducing it to one sentence, I might try “at equilibrium, each unit of phase space (or each discrete microstate in a discrete system) is equally likely.” (I personally find statistical mechanics much more intuitive than classical thermodynamics. I have always felt like E, H, F, and G are mathematically correct quantities that come from manipulating partial derivatives but that they mostly lack intuitive value. The quality of the average thermodynamics textbook doesn’t help.)
- mananaysiempre 5y ago> The quality of the average thermodynamics textbook doesn’t help. The very beginning of Huang’s statistical mechanics text is a really good, really short summary of axiomatic thermodynamics. The bulk of the book is 60s-era stat mech models, but the first couple dozen pages contain a surprisingly lucid exposition of the classic story of Clausius, Thompson, and Carnot. Rumer and Ryvkin is also a good book that explores things purely from a perspective of phenomenological axiomatics before plunging into statistics, and includes for example a discussion of how the potentials determine the equilibrium state under various conditions. Unfortunately, neither of these subsumes the other, and I wouldn’t really recommend either as a first-time introduction, so that mental spot is still empty for me. But as a way to demystify thermodynamics (which I find myself reaching for every few years with disturbing regularity) they serve well. (I also have a stack of various people’s notes that finally made the Legendre transform click for me lying around here somewhere, if anybody wants them.)
- 7373737373 5y agoKind of the same as positing that a Lisp meta-circular evaluator or Smalltalk (syntax) fits on the postcard. There are so many more elaborations on semantics and further definitions missing
- noobermin 5y agoAs a recovering theoretical physicist, things like this which is primarily an attitude are tiresome. I'll even go further down the line, just because you can write down the "equations of motion" often doesn't give you anything but another starting point. I will always be amused when people who study particle physics do everything after 2nd quantization and thus assume that literally understanding plane wave interactions explain all physics, rather than such methods are actually reductionist and have their own attendant assumptions that fail at certain points (like the UV limit for QED), but that means you really don't "understand" all physics just by writing down the Lagrangian for SM, it's just a starting point. "Understand" for a scientist shouldn't be abstract, it should be "given x equations/model I can predict y output" which is very hard for a lot of physics, otherwise there wouldn't millions of scientists doing things other that just doing string theory derivations everyday. Equations of motion is not understanding.