5 ms·
It boggles the mind to read this because I’ve been using Synergy (and now Barrier, and soon Barrier’s new fork once they ship) to do the same between Mac and Wi
by rcarmo 5y ago
It boggles the mind to read this because I’ve been using Synergy (and now Barrier, and soon Barrier’s new fork once they ship) to do the same between Mac and Windows for many years, so… it’s nothing really new.
It is cute (I’m typing this on my iPad controlled by my MacBook Pro), but just doesn’t seem very reliable at the moment (and does not work at all from an older MacBook Air). There’s a bucketload of polish in the experience, but I would refrain from calling it groundbreaking or liberating… Just a little better (UI-wise) and a little worse (no PC support).
- saagarjha 5y agoSynergy/Barrier straight up don't forward multitouch, which really sucks because part of the reason I want to use a Mac is because of their phenomenal support for gestures baked in throughout the OS.
- rcarmo 5y agoActually, I think Barrier does, at least between my Mac and my PC. But it's the weekend now, so I'm not going to fire up my work machine for anything...
- johnwalkr 5y agoIt does not work well for multi touch, even from Mac to Mac in my experience.
- filiperui 5y agoYou're right. My use case is also Mac to Mac and Barrier/Synergy does not provide the UC experience. No multi gestures support - and the thing that annoys me the most - trackpad scrolling events aren't mapped one to one, you end up scrolling lines on the target, not the precision you're expecting. To be honest I'm not sure if Barrier developers could actually mimic that without resorting to some sort of undocumented APIs and/or obscure techniques.
- saagarjha 5y agoThe APIs are all there on Quartz events, it’s just that nobody seems to use them :(
- johnwalkr 5y agoIn my case, my always-on workstation is a windows machine, and I also need a 3-button mouse for a decent CAD experience. So, I just give up on gestures and multitouch anyway (I prefer this consistency over having slightly different behavior across machines). Probably for similar reasons, it would be difficult to make barrier work as we wished on MacOS and still be multi-platform.
- terhechte 5y agoI agree. I'm a Mac user, still I've been using Synergy for years to do the very same thing with a Linux Desktop. I remember using it in like 2006. Now, Synergy doesn't run on iPads, and Universal Control is certainly "better" than synergy (in technical terms) because the Apple Behemoth invested a lot of money into this, but I can't help but wonder.. why: I don't see the use case, there's not a single app on the iPad that I'd like to control from the Mac.
- wsc981 5y agoCould be nice for mobile devs though, you don't really have to switch devices to test apps anymore. Just have a nice iPad stand next to your desktop and you'd be good to go.
- terhechte 5y agoThat is indeed a nice setup I hadn't thought about.
- therein 5y agoIf you were using it as a second screen to watch something or do some basic browsing for reference material, they are probably hoping this will address the desire to cast the screen contents from the Macbook. If you seamlessly are passing your mouse and keyboard inputs, you'll likely just have your iPad do the video streaming or browsing directly.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- leokennis 5y agoThis sounds a lot like the famous comment from yore that Dropbox “was just rsync between a computer and a mounted FTP server” or something. Your comment makes it sound like not needing to setup apps, not having limitations and having all complexity abstracted away on an OS level are “polishing” or nice to have. For most people, those thing are the feature. Chance my mom will use Synergy? 0%. Chance she’ll use Universal Control at some point? I’d say pretty high.
- bitwize 5y agoBut do Synergy and Barrier Just Work? It has to Just Work, otherwise it's a defective product, or a rough prototype for some Apple product. See, that's the thing. My guess is you had to configure Synergy, and as a techie you're blind to this effort. But it is still effort, hence a time sink and a cognitive burden. The Apple version is none of these and a joy to use because Apple puts the emphasis on making it Just Work with zero configuration if possible. Hundreds of millions more people will experience multi-device control for the first time with Apple Universal Control, than will have ever heard of Synergy.
- superasn 5y ago> But do Synergy and Barrier Just Work? It has to Just Work, otherwise it's a defective product. I don't own any apple products so correct me if I'm wrong, but if there was a way to make a program to "just work" will Apple allow it? From what I've heard devs complain apple's walled garden is pretty restrictive when it comes to things you can and cannot do especially when mobile devices are involved.
- xvector 5y agoDo you really trust the average individual to install apps that with zero configuration can read your screen from any of your devices? This walled garden is 100% a feature.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI’m an Apple developer, and own lots of Apple products. Apple gear and software always has a low-level advantage, as they own the SDK, but I haven’t seen them actually use this to deliberately disadvantage competitors (unlike some other companies that I won’t mention). That said, I have seen them “Sherlock” developers, though; where they implement integrated versions of products made by independent devs. This has been fairly controversial, as they have not always paid/given credit to the developers they plowed under. That sucks, because it would, literally, cost them nothing to simply mention the product that inspired their work. I suspect that’s because lawyers. I tend to like Apple for the same reason that other developers hate them. That “walled garden” is a big fat PItA, but it is also the reason for an enormous, lucrative, market. We need to learn to take the bad with the good, if we want to be happy.
- viktorcode 5y agoI've been Synergy user years ago but then I got fed up with amount of issues that simply couldn't be resolved (third mouse button issues, wrong key mappings, special keys pressed during crossing the boundary could mess things up on the new computer). So in the end I just put two keyboard and mice for two computers on the table. Synergy left the impression as something opposite of "it just works".
- cyberpunk 5y agoAnd it doesn't even support basic gestures. Useless with a trackpad.
- sixothree 5y agoYeah, but nothing sucks quite like Synergy. On Windows if you accidentally move your mouse off of the login screen you are _completely_ unable to user your client computer. You literally need to use the power button to recover your machine. This issue persisted for years before I gave up on Synergy and all of its suckiness.