3 ms·
It's hilarious to see everyone in the linked Twitter thread lose their minds over this feature. It's neat, I'm sure, but we have had Mouse without Borders and s
by paxys 5y ago
It's hilarious to see everyone in the linked Twitter thread lose their minds over this feature. It's neat, I'm sure, but we have had Mouse without Borders and several other similar apps for over a decade now doing exactly this.
- planb 5y agoI have this Logitech software that does the same on my Windows work PC and Mac home Mac, and I can drag the mouse over and use it on both machines. Unfortunately, it does not work when my PC is on VPN (which it is all the time). Apple uses a separate Wifi connection for Universal Control, and it simply always works.
- grecy 5y agoAnd this is what Apple has been doing for well over a decade now. Pulling to together a bunch of related ideas and solutions that on their own are nothing overly special, but combined turn into something "wow". Their genius isn't necessarily in being first or even inventing something (touch screen phone), it's tweaking the edges and getting it "just right".
- hughrr 5y agoThat’s what I pay them for. I don’t want to be experimented on like the bleeding edge companies are doing constantly. I want something solid that works. Of course it’s not perfect but the whole ecosystem integration and solidness is far far far above anything else out there.
- makach 5y agothis - I used so many different tools and methods to get this same functionality. It's not new or novel. But apple gets it right. They spent the time to make it appear magical.
- quitit 5y agoIt also solves some other "ecosystem" problems. For example I have a few iPad apps installed on my Mac, the reason being that I wanted keyboard/mouse and easier copying of content into and out of the iPad app while I was working on my desktop machine. With universal control I don't need to have the dual installs anymore, nor have to deal with the problems that would come with that (e.g. having to duplicate content across both installs). There's also plenty of apps which the developer has barred from installing on macOS where this is the only real solution.
- notriddle 5y ago> There's also plenty of apps which the developer has barred from installing on macOS where this is the only real solution. You can bypass that with iMazing. It’ll export the raw iPad app, which you can then install on your Mac, and it’ll probably run fine.
- Jcowell 5y agoThis was shut down in the latest updates where it would check the app I believe. There’s a workaround kind of but it’s too troublesome to go through.
- xenadu02 5y agoIdeas are cheap. Hacking together a PoC is too. Shipping some kind of product is a bit more difficult but the first to ship is usually a complete failure. You can point to almost <i>any</i> product category - whether computer related or not - and this holds true. Revolutionary ideas are ahead of their time both technologically and culturally. The makers don't know how to put the ideas to productive use. Then people flail around throwing product ideas at the wall to see what sticks. The implementation is often full of caveats, missing features, or is mere novelty (it folds! why? ... shutup, it folds ok). Getting the details right is <i>really</i> hard and takes a lot of work. The last 10% takes as much work as the first 90%. Then the next 10% also takes 90%. Repeat a few more times and somehow it ends up being 1000% more difficult than you expected at the start. Often it requires merging multiple major ideas to create something that is more than the sum of its parts (then you get to watch fools who only got 1 of 50 parts correct claim they invented the whole thing). Be assured that if you are successful a lot of people will rush to make sure you don't get any credit. I recommend you ignore them... their opinions don't matter and listening to them won't help you make better products or delight more customers. Stay focused on what matters. Even if Slashdot calls your product "lame" it can still make a few billion. Even if HN says your idea can be done already trivially by "any linux user with curlftpfs" you can still create a startup, IPO, and become very rich. Even if someone says "we have had Mouse without Borders [...] for over a decade" you can still deliver a better experience that people will pay money for. Just because there are existing "solutions" out there doesn't mean they are a) good or b) doing the job customers actually want them to do.
- staindk 5y agoSure... but it seems that all the available solutions have their quirks and oddities. Some people (like yourself and the author of the top-level article) seem to think it is literally perfect, while others have issues and irritating experiences (see this [1] comment from this very thread). Of course if Apple senses there is something cool out there that looks like it has only had e.g. $200k spent on it they could decide to put a bunch of devs on the same issue, spend much more money/time, and get a better product out. IMO that doesn't automatically mean they should go around calling it revolutionary if it does similar things but better or whatever. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30732528 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30732528