7 ms·
Considering these 'deep space' images that capture these myriad of little galaxies so far away.... The number of galaxies that must be out there is inconceivabl
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
Considering these 'deep space' images that capture these myriad of little galaxies so far away.... The number of galaxies that must be out there is inconceivable to me.
Spitballing.
Might there be some space/time mechanism at play whereby we're actually seeing the same handful or so of galaxies? Like maybe some lensing thing.
Or weirder, we're actually seeing right around the universe itself — as though seeing the back of your head in a mirror if you look far enough. Not a topologist, but seems a toroidal universe would have a property like this: look far enough and you see the back of your head. So perhaps the same galaxies seen from multiple angles at the same time appear to be a greater number of galaxies than there actually are.
- mhh__ 5y agoYou can reject some notions of repeating patterns / loops in space because it would violate Lorentz covariance. You could fire a laser in one direction and the opposite, then you know your absolute position in space.
- ISL 5y agoPeople have looked for hints of this sort of thing without success so far. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe#:~:text=In%20a%20universe%20with%20zero,the%20torus%20and%20Klein%20bottle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe#:~:tex....
- jerf 5y agoAs well as what ISL said, if the universe is toroidial it seems like it's larger than our visible horizon. While images of an individual galaxy might be hard to tell if they are repeated, we can see enough of the structure of the universe that if our visible horizon was much larger than the real value of the universe and there was wrapping going on, we'd see it. This isn't the exact sort of video I'm looking for, but it's close enough to what I'm talking about: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rENyyRwxpHo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rENyyRwxpHo Everywhere we look we see distinct structures. It is not a bad thought, though. It may well do some sort of wrapping around, just at a larger scale than we can see. It's an open problem.
- hnthrowaway0315 5y agoWatching that video will make anyone humble.
- Keyframe 5y agoEverywhere we look we see distinct structures. This might be us being in an isotropic bubble where outside of the bubble is forever gone for us to see due to expansion of universe... Not sure how CMBR falls into that however.
- jerf 5y agoHence "it seems like it's larger than our visible horizon", "at a larger scale than we can see", and "It's an open problem".
- idealmedtech 5y agoIt's been over a decade since my cosmology class, so forgive any errors, but isn't there a constant that describes the curvature of the universe [1], which so far has been calculated as "flat"? That's not to say we'll ever truly know, since you need infinite precision to rule out hyperbolic or spherical geometry, but in a flat universe, how can you have toroidal geometry? Per [2]: > The actual value for critical density value is measured as ρcritical = 9.47×10−27 kg m−3. From these values, within experimental error, the universe seems to be flat. [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann_equations#Density_parameter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann_equations#Density_... [2] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe
- Keysh 5y agoIt’s actually no problem mathematically to have toroidal topology and flat geometry. (The classic Asteroids video game, where your ship can go off the top of the screen and come in at the bottom, or similarly with the left and right edges, is an example of a flat 2D space with the topology of a torus.)
- dm319 5y ago
- grishka 5y agoBack when they were launching JWST, I kept thinking that there's a non-zero probability of it proving wrong some of our essential assumptions about the universe. Like, you know, they keep saying "galaxies that formed just X years after the big bang", but what if it turns out there was no big bang? What if our estimations of the age and/or size of the universe turn out to be wrong?
- labster 5y agoIf there’s no Big Bang then the origin of the cosmic microwave background needs a new explanation: why does it exist, and why isn’t it more red or blue shifted.
- throwawaycities 5y agoEven if there wasn’t a Big Bang, let’s say the universe was infinite, we would still have the CMB from the furtherest reaching photons from the edges of the visible universe that have been stretched to microwaves right? In other words eventually the nearest galaxies will one day become the CMB as the universe continues to expand until they are on the edge, until even they fall outside the visible universe and no photons/light outside our own galaxy will be capable of reaching us and the CMB disappears.
- cyphar 5y agoThat's not what the CMB is. The CMB is an incredibly uniform pattern which appears to have been formed by a very hot plasma at some point in the past. It's difficult to imagine an explanation other than the Big Bang (or some kind of expansion of a very hot plasma) because the uniformity means it was almost certainly concentrated in space. But yes, in the distant future, it will not be possible to detect the CMB anymore (and it's entirely possible that alien civilisations that evolve at that time would probably never have a model of the Big Bang because there would be no remaining evidence of it).
- cheese_van 5y ago
- throwawaycities 5y agoOn the scale of the universe you aren’t just seeing far away objects but seeing the past. For illustrative purposes the edge of the Universe is the edge of time, where time has any meaning to us, and beyond that is inflation where light didn’t travel freely. If somehow the Universe were as you propose and wrapping around itself so we were able to stare at the back of our heads, we would only see objects from the past to a point, and then the objects would begin to appear closer in time again until the furthest point where we would once again be looking at the present.
- Aerroon 5y agoThe universe was opaque up to about 380,000 years after the Big Bang. If the universe loops in on itself and is large enough then wouldn't we be blocked by that? And the further you go back from there the higher the density would be.
- throwawaycities 5y agoMeaning we couldn’t look straight out and see the back of our own heads. Eventually we would run into a point of the universe before time had any meaning (the opaque plasma) and there would be no looking past that back into the present.
- colechristensen 5y agoThere are as many galaxies in the observable universe as there are stars in our galaxy or… as there are bytes in 100 gigabytes. Within a factor of five or so. The universe is flat as far as our best measurements go, if it is curved, it is with a much larger radius than the ~100 billion light year width of the observable universe. It is indeed difficult to conceive but it is how it is, the universe is very big and has a whole lot of unique stuff in it. Occasionally there is a lensing thing where we see the same galaxy twice or so, but not in any way to diminish the 10^11 other galaxies out there.
- glenstein 5y agoWhat's interesting to me is, relative to human scales, cosmic space is so much more ridiculously vast than cosmic time. Our size as a percentage of the size of the universe is tiny, and our age as a percentage of the universe's age is still tiny. But the second number is gargantuan in comparison to the first.
- Trasmatta 5y agoIt always seemed odd to me that we're so close to the apparent start of the universe. 13.8 billion years isn't that long ago, given how big the future time horizon is.
- Jweb_Guru 5y agoWe are close to the beginning of the universe, but we are about halfway through the lifetime of our sun, which formed right around when 50% of all sunlike stars that will ever be formed, had been formed. So we're actually around average in many ways.
- Trasmatta 5y agoOh, that's interesting! That does make more sense. Most of the sun like stars that will ever exist are formed in the early universe, so it makes more sense that's why we exist when we do.
- mrtnmcc 5y ago>> The number of galaxies that must be out there is inconceivable to me Don't worry, there are many times more galaxies in the observable universe than neurons in the human brain. Nobody can conceive of it.
- eldenring 5y agoThere's really only like 2 trillion galaxies in the observable universe which isn't that much more than the number of neurons.
- asah 5y agoTIL there's about as many galaxies in the observable universe as trees in the planet. https://www.google.com/search?q=how+many+trees+are+on+earth https://www.google.com/search?q=how+many+trees+are+on+earth
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoYes but that’s just the observable universe. My understanding is that the observable universe is only a fraction of the total universe. However that was something I found hard to verify so I could be wrong.
- willis936 5y agoWe don't have an upper bound on the size of the universe. It's difficult to construct falsifiable models about things that can't be directly observed, but it may well be infinite.
- ggm 5y agoThat number nobody can conceive of... add one to it
- stavros 5y agoI don't need to be able to conceive of every individual grain to be able to make inferences about sand.
- vishnugupta 5y agoYour comment reminded me of this story where a space program director decided, on a hunch or whim, to point Hubble at a seemingly empty space for 100 hours. The rest, as they say is history. Galaxies went from being rare things to abundant ones. Turns out the universe is teeming with them. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/when-hubble-stared-at-nothing-for-100-hours https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/when-hubb...
- supernova87a 5y agoIt wasn't quite that dramatic a whim or lucky hunch as it's made out to be. There was input from galaxy researchers on such an idea, and I think it was viewed as a bit of a calculated risk compared to other normal proposals to spend the telescope time on well-known targets visible with a few hours of observing. Especially when proposals outnumber available time by a factor of approx. 7, people will question why you should gamble on something unproven. Hence "director's discretionary time". But of course it was a smart move in setting up the field for "what's the next big thing", because if you were to find something interesting, it obviously drove the call for larger and larger telescopes to study farther and farther things. Just studying the crap out of brighter nearby things would have been relatively predictable/boring by comparison. (I exaggerate a little)
- rbobby 5y agoMaybe it's a quantum observer effect and the galaxies only exist because there's an observer. Dark matter/energy is need to make things balance only because we haven't been looking in all the right places. The universe would be an odd old place if that was true.
- implements 5y agoPerhaps it’s all procedurally generated, and every time we build a new telescope there’s a supernatural sysadmin out there going “Oh, ffs! - We need more new hardware!”.
- dom96 5y agoSurely if we do live in a simulation then the engineers just need to simulate our minds. It's easy to fake what we see then as an optimisation instead of generating a whole universe.
- mac01021 5y agoThat assumes we're the object of the simulation rather than a byproduct. Maybe what they want to simulate is a universe and we've just happened to pop up in a small part of the simulation.
- mensetmanusman 5y ago“ Might there be some space/time mechanism at play whereby we're actually seeing the same handful or so of galaxies? Like maybe some lensing thing.” Good question. People have been wondering this and have studied whether it is possible a la periodic boundary conditions for example. https://aapt.scitation.org/doi/abs/10.1119/1.13499?journalCode=ajp https://aapt.scitation.org/doi/abs/10.1119/1.13499?journalCo...
- justin66 5y ago> Might there be some space/time mechanism at play whereby we're actually seeing the same handful or so of galaxies? That strikes you as the sort of thing nobody would have noticed throughout centuries of study?
- lamontcg 5y ago> Might there be some space/time mechanism at play whereby we're actually seeing the same handful or so of galaxies? Nope. Current evidence is that space is infinite. Even if that was all wrong, then its incredibly large due to inflation and our past light cone is one tiny bit of it. As time goes on we're seeing more and more of it, and parts that used to be in contact before inflation are only just coming back into contact again (their past light cones overlapping). Those are all unique galaxies. An awful lot of physics would have to be wrong for that to not be true. "Space, is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mindboggingly big it is. I mean you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space."
- peter303 5y agoI predict astronomers will observe and catalog all trillion observable galaxies in a century. It was probably inconceivable a century that we'd observe and catalog two billion stars in the Milky Way by now. But with improving technology we have.
- dm319 5y agoYes, I wonder about this also. Wouldn't need to be toroidal - could just be spherical, but would need to wrap in a 4th spatial dimension. It would explain a lot of things, like the expansion not having a clear centre, the requirement for dark matter (expansion would happen in an orthogonal dimension), background radiation (which I never quite understood) and the size of the universe. But that was a high-school idea, and I'm sure some clever physicists and astronomers will tell me why this isn't the case.