3 ms·
There are many, many assumptions to such calculations. Here's PG&E's best guess at g CO2 / kWh based on time of day/year in California (page 2): https://ww2.a
by hedora 5y ago
There are many, many assumptions to such calculations. Here's PG&E's best guess at g CO2 / kWh based on time of day/year in California (page 2):
https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/classic/fuels/lcfs/fuelpathways/comments/tier2/2021_elec_update.pdf https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/classic/fuels/lcf...
If you only charge from noon to two in Q1, then use have zero marginal emissions per mile driven (this is the best case). If you only charge from 7-8pm you emit 142.06 gCO2e/MJ.
1 megajoule = 0.2777777778 kilowatt-hour
Converting gives us ~512 g CO2e per kWh.
Car efficiency is measured in miles per kWh. 4 miles per kWh is doable (some cars are better, some worse). So, that's 128g CO2e per mile.
50 miles per gallon would be great. A gallon of gas emits 20 lbs CO2, or 0.4lbs per mile, which is 181 grams per mile.
So, if you only charge at the worst possible time in California (basically forcing PG&E to use natural gas plants to charge your car), then a 50 mpg car is still 50% worse than a slightly larger EV.
In practice, you charge during off peak hours. At night, emissions are about half worst case. During the day, they're 10% of worst case.
- bsdetector 5y agoIf you just apply CA's 49% natural gas (according to DOE) to the 45 mpg for 100% natural gas you come up with a gas-burning car needing >90 mpg to be cleaner -- well higher than the 70 mpg you calculated vs charging on natural gas -- but easily achievable with hybrids. I feel like there are many people who see 30 coal / 45 nat gas and take offense that it doesn't make EVs sound particularly good. This is why I called it a more honest presentation because EVs in terms of CO2 are fairly bad in WV and marginal in DE or MI or many other places compared to a high-mpg regular car. Instead of taking offense and setting out to correct the record, understand that not sounding particularly good is an accurate view. Even in CA, the mpg needed to be cleaner than EV formulation makes it clear that driving a 100 mpg hybrid for instance is so good that any further gains are of little consequence.