11 ms·
Microsoft Explains Why the Start Menu Needed to Die
- lomegor 15y agoI somewhat agree with Microsoft, but if, and only if, they provide another easy way to run commands and see all other applications... Either way, I think Windows 7 is too different from Windows 98 to ever go mainstream. People just want a better looking Windows 98. EDIT: Meant Windows 8, not 7
- eddiegroves 15y agoThe problem with catering to the market that wants a better looking Windows 98 is there is no growth potential. Sure Microsoft would still make a lot of money, like they have with Windows 7, but the the entire PC market has weak growth forecasts so they cannot rely on x% growth in PCs to grow their sales.
- chadgeidel 15y ago"If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses". (Not) Henry Ford. The sentiment still applies. Or are you saying that already?
- aresant 15y agoI love that MSFT is building a UI in response to actual data, but something about these posts and the resulting UI seems cold and methodical. Maybe it's just the writing style that's throwing me but the leap forward in a consumer facing OS that iOS delivered felt like a more organic process. Reminds me of that quote from Jobs : "It's really hard to design products by focus groups. A lot of times, people don't know what they want until you show it to them." As a result I wonder how much of Apple's process was reactionary from data / focus groups vs. from Steve / Ives "gut"
- wanorris 15y agoAnd yet, to me at least, the Metro UI itself doesn't feel at all like the sort of result you would expect from a product designed by focus groups. As with the ribbon (which I'm also a fan of), it feels like they worked with focus groups to identify pain points, used genuine inspiration to come up with a design solution, then used more user testing to refine that solution. Honestly, it feels like Apple has been playing it too safe with their UI work the last few years, while Microsoft is doing real innovation. (Hardware, of course, is an entirely different matter.)
- pedalpete 15y agoI agree with your hardware comment, I wish PCs wouldn't look like Macs. So cold and austere. I hope with the ultra-lights, PC manufacturers start experimenting with alternative materials, like Asus did with their bamboo line. I've also always wondered why the CPU isn't stuck on the back of the monitor where it can be provided with better airflow. As far as the ribbon, I have to disagree, it seems such a hodgepodge to me, and though I like WP7, I don't think it has a warm inviting feel, it's just cool. iOS always felt boring and cold to me.
- majika 15y ago> I've also always wondered why the CPU isn't stuck on the back of the monitor where it can be provided with better airflow. That would result in increased latency between the CPU and the rest of the system. Put the the motherboard and memory on the laptop's monitor and it would start getting too top-heavy.
- pedalpete 15y agoI was suspecting something like that, though with the weight of laptops these days, I suspect the top heavy will become less of an issue. I'd guess HD,keyboard,trackpad and ports are the majority of the weight in the lower half.
- bchjam 15y agothe best feature of win7's start menu (desktop search) is still there in the win8 start screen, but I have to admit that accessing it with any frequency starts to feel a bit too alt-tabby
- chadgeidel 15y agoYeah, it's like they have 2 OSes in there. I love the new "tablet UI", but it's jarring to have to switch "home" from one application to start another. They need to include have a search box in the traditional "desktop" somewhere.
- ghurlman 15y agoHit the Windows key, start typing - just like in Windows 7. The UI is different, but the results are the same.
- kinkora 15y agoI don't know about you guys but what I took out of that article is that Microsoft is secretly/stealthily tracking its users? How do they know if someone is using the start bar "11 percent less than before"? Not only that, it goes on to even say: Instead of navigating through the nested menus within Start, or even searching for apps and documents through the live search function, users began to pin apps to the Start menu or the taskbar for even quicker access. Microsoft data found that most users (above 40 percent) didn't pin a single app to the Start menu, with steadily declining numbers pinning 1 (20 percent), 2 (15 percent), and so on. It doesn't say anywhere in the article that it was a focus/user group and it sounds like it was generalized to refer to every Windows user so how did they collate all of those data? Shouldn't someone be raising some privacy concerns? Disclaimer: I've not used Windows since XP. I'm a *nix user.
- kenjackson 15y agoWindows has opt-in telemetry data. Many of their product do too. So there is some bias to those that opt-in, but I've heard that they still get tens of millions of user data.
- kinkora 15y agoOk, makes sense. thanks for that ken.
- georgieporgie 15y agoFor years, Microsoft jammed the Start Menu where it didn't belong (Windows CE), now they're stuffing a tablet interface where it doesn't belong. I'm extremely suspicious of their interpretation of usage statistics. As a "power user" I habitually decline any offer to track my behavior. Also, as discussed in the previous article about Explorer changes, do the statistics speak to the number of people who choose other methods, or to the lack of UI discoverability? Clutter up the desktop of your freshly-bought PC with enough partner icons, and the Start Menu gets lost in a sea of visual information. The new interface reminds me of the old app-launchers/menus in the pre-Windows days.
- bluedanieru 15y agoAre you sure that's the data they're basing all this on? Terribly unscientific for them, if so.
- georgieporgie 15y agoNo, not at all. But that's the problem: to my knowledge, they haven't disclosed much about their methods of collecting data, nor how they've come up with their percentage numbers. Since Microsoft seems to be ruled by politics and pet projects, I'm extremely suspect of the objectivity of their statistical analysis.
- DaveMebs 15y agoThey are looking at the change in usage, not the total usage. Your complaints would be more apt if they were just looking at data for a single release, rather than a trend across releases. If users are switching to another method, regardless of what it is, you can argue that this is a failing of the Start menu.
- cletus 15y agoI actually found the Start menu incredibly useful in Windows 7. Admittedly it was a usage pattern they indicated: I would pin commonly used apps to the Start Menu and would rarely if ever open up beyond that. I would also use the auto-complete to find things as a second (distant) use case. One thing that always annoyed me about the Start Menu was how companies would use it. For example, shortcuts notwithstanding I would have to go: Start > Programs > Firaxis > Civilization IV > Civilization IV Beyond the Sword The part that really annoyed me was putting the company name in there. I don't care. In fact it may not even be obvious who the company is that makes something you want to use. I actually bought a copy of Windows 7 retail version for the explicit purpose of using it from computer to computer for years to come, probably in XP-like time frames (ie 5-10 years). Microsoft needs to realize that these infrequent expensive upgrades (largely for features nobody cares about) are a decade out of date. Honestly, there's still nothing wrong with XP. Microsoft just went out of their way to kill it by deliberately not supporting it with things they definitely could've. One of the great things about XP was the low resource requirements (minimum 128M of RAM). IIRC 64-bit Windows 7 is at 2GB minimum now. For what exactly?
- vogonj 15y agoWhen Windows XP was released, the newest Mac computers were the Power Mac G4, the PowerBook G4, and the white iBook G3. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh#History) The iBook shipped in only one model, with 128MB of RAM. The PowerBook G4 started at 128MB of RAM and topped out at 256MB of RAM. The Power Mac G4 started at 128MB of RAM and topped out at 512MB of RAM. The smallest amount of memory you can get on a Mac nowadays is 2GB, and you would've had to buy an entirely new computer at least once to get Lion running in the intervening time. (Whereas, if you didn't buy a new computer since Windows XP came out, you could run the 32-bit version just fine with 1GB of RAM.) Methinks you doth protest too much about expensive upgrades.
- vogonj 15y agoIncidentally, the total upgrade price from Windows XP to Windows 7 Home Premium is $109 at Amazon right now, and to Windows 7 Ultimate it's $171.(http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=windows+7+upgrade&x=0&y=0 http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dap...) By comparison, OS X 10.1 was the latest version of OS X available at XP RTM. OS X 10.2 would've set you back $129, 10.4 another $129, 10.6 another $30, and 10.7 another $30. (I don't believe that you can skip OS X release-level updates, but I'm not a Mac user, so I don't know; if you can, feel free to correct me.) Even if you magically bought a computer in 2001 which would still run Lion today, you would've spent $310 on OS upgrades, for a period of time for which upgrading Windows cost less than half as much.
- orthecreedence 15y agoI'm a bit scared and annoyed of this new interface. I use the start menu such an incredible amount that having it bring up an entire new screen would undoubtedly interrupt a lot of the workflows I'm used to. It seems everyone is converging on mobile, as if it's going to replace the desktop. It's not. Desktop will always be here, and to pretend it's going away and force tablet interfaces down everyone's throat is a pretty bold/stupid move in my opinion. Then again, I'm biased because I'm not a complete moron when it comes to computers. Maybe 99% of the market will LOVE not having a start menu. Is my monitor a touch screen? No. So let's not pretend it is. I don't care about pretty interfaces or big video buttons that play when I hover over them. I want something I can launch programs with. Is it really hard to do something like if(is_computer) { show_useful_start_menu(); } else if (is_tablet) { show_retarded_start_menu(); } I understand I'm the minority, but if they do away with the start menu, I'll probably stay on windows 7 forever.
- zhwang 15y agoI've been using the Windows 8 Developer Preview for a while now as the primary OS on my laptop, and I've been primarily working on the desktop view (well, given that there's essentially not many Metro apps available). Once I got used to the Start screen I've found it okay to use. I had initial concerns that the constant transition away might be jarring but turns out it's a non-issue. I've also found that the Start menu search in Windows 7 was quite slow, and that in W8 it's actually responsive! Have you given the new interface a chance?
- orangecat 15y agoDesktop will always be here If Microsoft and Apple have their way, desktops will only be for developers and "professionals". The mobile transition allows them to fix the bug that users can install software that interferes with their business plans, and without giving them a cut.
- bluedanieru 15y agoWell goody for them. As a professional developer I'd like my OS without a start menu that takes up the entire screen, thanks. Oh who am I kidding, my Windows OS is a games launcher and web browser these days, and nothing more. I don't mind how retarded Microsoft and Apple want to get, what concerns me is Canonical and their "me too" attitude with regard to stupid design decisions.
- pmr_ 15y agoI actually found one change to the Start Menu the enabling change for me: Typing the name of something and (often) just getting the application that I wanted to start. Just saying what I want and let the machine to the finding for me just feels like the way things should be done to me. I'm finding it hard to believe that people are actually pinning infrequently used things like the Control Panel to the task bar or is there another way to access it that I don't know of? Isn't that leading to visual clutter? Users never cease to amaze me.
- barista 15y agoWhat I will be missing if the start menu goes away is the usability of it being there een if I am running something in full screen. I know that I can take my mouse to lower right corner and minimize everything and start typing to find what I want but its just the visual feedback I get from the start menu is very reassuring. How would it work if I don't remember the nname of that new program that I installed 3 months ago and never really used it since.
- Roboprog 15y agoControl panel has the Display widget embedded within it. I seem to frequently need to adjust that on laptops with various external monitors.
- r00fus 15y agoI actually found one change to the Start Menu the enabling change for me: Typing the name of something and (often) just getting the application that I wanted to start. Just saying what I want and let the machine to the finding for me just feels like the way things should be done to me. > So they ripped off OSX Spotlight (which stole it from Quicksilver/etc) - I've used spotlight to launch apps with 3-4 keyclicks since forever: OSX: CMD+space,Fir<return> = Launch Firefox and Win7: WINkey, Fir <return> = Launch Firefox
- evanw 15y agoAfter getting hooked on a keyboard-based launcher like Launchy (http://launchy.net http://launchy.net), I pretty much stopped using the Start menu entirely.
- Shenglong 15y agoI feel old when I say this, but: most Microsoft changes make me angry. I don't understand why my desktop path needs to be changed 3 times between ME -> XP -> 7 (for example). With that being said, I found W7 to be pretty intuitive. I don't use the start menu for much other than quick access to programs that I don't want to clutter. The start menu is on the corner, and easy to click. It's easy to de-click if I need to, and I don't need to minimize anything to access it. This will be a sad day.
- Roboprog 15y agoI hear you: the UI is shuffled each time, but it still seems to run slow and complicated, and programming windows is ... more work than I care to take on, if there is an alternative. (this from somebody who had been using DOS / Novell / Windows / Borland dev stuff for about 10 years before ever picking up Linux -- MS totally lost me just before the underwhelming release of '95)
- Hominem 15y agoThis makes sense to me. Many people, including myself, just dump icons on the desktop. Every time I open the start menu it seems like I am digging forever to find what I want.
- Masse 15y agoI can sort of see why they do it, and it might be good enough for many people, but it makes me think what happens to the rest of the programs. For example I have maybe 5-7 programs I use daily, but every now and then I might need another program. Do I need to clutter my desktop or go search the program files?
- darasen 15y agoNow will they kill the registry?
- Roboprog 15y agoOh dear. I remember using Winders 3.0/3.1. They had this thing call "Pogrom Manager" (or something like that). In it, you could make a bunch of little boxes, each of which held several things you could click on and run. It was actually fairly useful, when you weren't just using winders to switch between mess-doss apps. (and frankly, Dr. Dos did a good enough job app switching if you weren't actually running any gooey apps) Then, out came winders 95 with its fancy pants "start" menu, and some Rolling Stones song about making a grown man cry, or at least some part of that song. I didn't really like the start menu, too much chasing things down multiple levels of moving targets. So now, start menu will die. Die, start menu, die. Only to be replaced with something that looks much like Pogrom Manager, only with more pixels and bits per pixel to dress it up nice. Just goes to show you the MicroSlop can admit a mistake, even if the mistake is old enough to get a driver's license.
- Derbasti 15y agoSo... The Start Menu needs to die, therefore make it a whole frigging screen instead of a popup menu. Very similar to the New Explorer thing: most people don't use 80% of explorer menu features, so put them in the ribbon where they take up even more space. I don't get this line of reasoning.
- majmun 15y agoI'm not suprised startmenu lost usage in win7. It is because in windows 7 they kindof made it less user friendly you must operate startmenu in small box in bottom left corner and not like before where you can expand menu on whole screen. and you can't change it to classic start menu.