3 ms·
Yeah, let's take the obvious choice and say this survey's methods might not stand up to scrutiny. Pew, a reputable outfit, says that most Americans report havin
by jeffbee 5y ago
Yeah, let's take the obvious choice and say this survey's methods might not stand up to scrutiny. Pew, a reputable outfit, says that most Americans report having never met someone who is transgender. That obviously can't be reconciled in any sensible way with a belief that 21% of Americans are transgender.
- tedunangst 5y agoThe obvious reconciliation is that "they" all live "over there".
- jquery 5y agoThis is probably true. I'd also add though, how would most Americans even know if they've met someone who's transgender? By definition, the transition phase is transitory.
- lesam 5y agoYou could reconcile it by believing that people just don’t understand percentages.
- kiba 5y agoPerception does not equal reality.
- makeitdouble 5y agoWe’re talking methodology so I think it’s fair to dig deeper. The most obvious point is, how do you tell someone you met is transgender ? The question itself is pretty weird IMHO. It would also be interesting to see how many gay people the Americans responding to the pew survey reported to have met. All in all, these survey are about what people think, it seems pretty hard to come up with control numbers, or validate a methodology as much better than another in meaningful ways. At most we could have different surveys from different groups converging toward the same numbers.