2 ms·
We have plenty of evidence of fusion consuming money in unbounded quantities -- the people spending it say they could spend a very great deal more -- and no sol
by ncmncm 5y ago
We have plenty of evidence of fusion consuming money in unbounded quantities -- the people spending it say they could spend a very great deal more -- and no solitary erg of griddable energy out, decade after decade.
The designs they publish for the fateful day they do get anything out are overwhelmingly bigger than a fission plant of similar capacity, overwhelmingly more costly to build, and overwhelmingly more expensive to operate. Leaving aside the plasma physics, no solutions are known for basic engineering questions in construction and operation.
Fission has turned out to be a dead end, for cost reasons: renewables are cheaper, and easier and quicker to field, and cost is still plummeting, making fission less competitive with each passing day. So, anything that costs more obviously has no chance.
All of this is a click away, if you care to know. Nobody is obliged to know, or care. But not bothering says all.
- willis936 5y agoYou can construct any narrative you want if you have selective perception and decide to not actually research or learn anything. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.3540v1.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.3540v1.pdf
- ncmncm 5y agoITER was supposed to cost $5 billion, originally. Now it is supposed to cost $25 billion. It is still far from done. Cost for these things only ever goes up, and can continue rising until it is actually delivered, enabling cost to rise without bound, until it is finally canceled. My prediction is that it will never be delivered, and none of the money will ever be returned. $25 billion would build a hell of a lot of solar, wind, and storage, that would start displacing fossil-generated power immediately, and then generate revenue to build out more.
- pfdietz 5y agoAh yes, that paper. I cite it often. The reactor described there has a thermal power density 1/40th that of a PWR reactor vessel. And it uses so much beryllium that using the entire world's estimated resource of that element would let you build enough reactors to supply maybe 1% of world primary energy demand.