3 ms·
Same reason that you shoot at enemy conscripts in a war, drop bombs on enemy cities. Same reason why Russia is now being subjected to sanctions. To undermine th
by vkou 5y ago
Same reason that you shoot at enemy conscripts in a war, drop bombs on enemy cities. Same reason why Russia is now being subjected to sanctions. To undermine the Russian economy in a non-violent manner.
Whether or not it results in political change is irrelevant - a crippled Russia is a sufficient end all in itself, just like dead soldiers are a sufficient end all in itself during a war. Wars rarely end with a government being overthrown, but they do often end when a government decides that peace is the better option. Bombed cities, dead soldiers, and starving children are the calculus that pushes governments towards making that decision.
- hda2 5y ago> shoot at enemy conscripts But most Russians affected by these aren't shooting back. They aren't conscripts or have anything to do with the war (doubly so now that sanctions are in effect). Shooting at solders trying to hurt you is one thing, but that's not what's happening here.
- vkou 5y agoNo, but all of them contribute to Russia's economy. And that war effort can't happen without a functioning economy.
- hda2 5y agoThis line of thinking leads to bombing schools and hospitals. This is how we get war crimes. I'm glad most people don't think the way you do.
- vkou 5y agoThen you should be happy that we're talking about refusing to cooperate in economic activity, instead of bombing schools and hospitals. Me refusing to transact with you isn't a war crime.
- hda2 5y ago> Me refusing to transact with you isn't a war crime. You refusing to transact with me isn't a war crime, but your line of thinking where normal citizen activities are similar to conscripts shooting at you can certainly lead to one. It's one thing to target citizens who work on applications for the military, and another to target open source devs because they happen to be Russian. If you can't acknowledge this distinction then I'm afraid we have to agree to disagree. Also please don't put words in my mouth. Strawmen will get us nowhere.
- HideousKojima 5y ago>drop bombs on enemy cities Unless you're targeting military forces or infrastructure in those cities, bombing civilians is a war crime. Of course, who gets tried as a war criminal or not mostly depends on who wins
- vkou 5y agoIn wars between industrialized nations, most civilian infrastructure is dual-use. A factory makes widgets for a factory that makes widgets for the army. A highway is used to ship military supplies. A port unloads military supplies. An oil refinery makes gasoline for civilian cars... and diesel for tanks.
- exizt88 5y agoWoah, a case for bombing civilians on Hacker News. How far we’ve come!
- vkou 5y agoI'm not saying how I think wars should be fought. I'm describing how they are fought. Given that our militaries don't balk at drone striking weddings and funerals, I can't see how they would take much issue with dropping a couple hundred bombs on a refinery, or a rail yard, or a line of tanker trucks. Which are all things that have been done since 1945, and as far as I'm aware, nobody has been dragged off to the ICC for it.
- exizt88 5y agoEveryone except for the very jingoistic few balks at drone striking weddings and funerals. Everyone hates that! So maybe that's not the modus operandi to which we should compare OSS strategies.
- vkou 5y agoMaybe everyone in your and my social circles, but that speaks more about our bubbles. Half this country is completely fine with doing it... In a war that we had no reason to even fight! I imagine the rate of support would be higher if it was a conflict where we weren't the aggressor.