3 ms·
So they can get of their chairs and dethrone the dictator. It's kind of more important right now than writing software.
by scotty79 5y ago
So they can get of their chairs and dethrone the dictator. It's kind of more important right now than writing software.
- brandonmenc 5y agoI don't want to hear anyone in this country [the US] complain about the Electoral College or gerrymandering the next time we decide to pull another Iraq War but they're opposed to it. Just like, overthrow the government - it's so easy! And if you don't have the guts - well, don't be mad when someone deletes all your files, you collaborator!
- scotty79 5y agoYes. Exactly. US citizens are responsible for that corrupt systems that there are in place there. And all the war profiteering those systems allowed. Many average Americans directly benefited from US wars as military employees and contractors.
- cartesius13 5y agoAverage Americans most definitely benefited from US military shenanigans but that kinda besides the point here I think. The main point is that "just overthrow your government, bro" is not a thing people can go out and just do and these comments make it seem that they're negligent if they don't start doing it right now. "Just do it, bro. It's so easy"
- diordiderot 5y agoThe point of sanctions is to make doing nothing worse that doing something. If the USA was economically isolated as a result of it's invasion, I'd be willing to bet the iraq war would've finished much sooner
- mardifoufs 5y agoIf Americans were singled out by the entire world, forbidden from traveling and targeted by even the software the install it would have just led to much much more patriotism and unity. There is no better way to unite a divided group than to target it as a single entity. Makes it a lot easier to set aside your differences and a lot harder to dissent within your group. That's what happened after 9/11, no one paused to think what actions lead to that event or the geopolitical context. It just united every American overnight. In a way that already has happened in Russia. The sanctions did not lead to less (or more) support for the war. The initial sanctions were justified as they targeted the russian state, but the knee jerk reaction of also imposing sanctions that explicitly were aimed at the population lead to nothing but resentment against the west. Whether you are on the morally right side or not, it does not matter in that context; you cant really debate your way into convincing someone that you are doing something for his own good when you are doing everything you can to also make him suffer If the intention is just to hurt them for the war, then sure that will work as intended... but I think it's dishonest to pretend we are doing it for anything more "noble" than that
- scotty79 5y agoOk. So we should hug and support Russia in those difficult times and it will inevitably result in lowering Russian patriotism and becomming more westernized? Because we were trying to do for the last 3 decades and nothing like that happened. Russians are very patriotic and strongly support their government when it confronts the western world by bombing civilians. If nothing works I prefer to apply punishment in hopes that smart Russians emigrate and Russia will crumble. And yes, punishment should affect more civilised and smarter Russians too to either motivate them to clean up their country or leave it.
- mardifoufs 5y agoNo, not at all. My only argument is that we can't pretend it's all just for their own good because it will make them finally see the light and get rid of their government. That's just not true, it won't happen and I think it's just something people say to themselves because they aren't comfortable with the reality that they are pushing for an entire civilian population to suffer. It's war, so again no moral judgment on that, but sugar-coating it is even worse than admitting the truth. A bit off topic but if you think the west was supporting and hugging russia or ukraine in the 1990s and 2000s, you might need to revisit how we got here.
- brandonmenc 5y ago> Many average Americans directly benefited from US wars as military employees and contractors. True, but the Iraq War was a net negative for the vast majority of Americans, even just financially.
- fsckboy 5y agono, not true at all in any meaningful sense. American taxpayers pay for the military budget; that some of that money comes back to some as wages does not on average mean that average Americans benefit.
- scotty79 5y agoNot quite. Anerican corporations made a steal in Iraq. That country was robbed. And pushing America's economic interests like prolonging dollar as main currency of resource trade was huge benefit to every USA citizen because main USA export is the dollar. That's why USA van run deficit for decades and be the richest country on Earth.
- croes 5y agoDethroning nowadays needs software. No arabian spring without messengers. People like Putin don't need software but people who oppose him do.
- ridiculous_leke 5y agoNot sure if that will motivate them to dethrone the dictator. But this will most likely impact their work and may as well make them more nationalist in the process. And at the same time open source's reputation suffers in the process.
- handoflixue 5y agoWhy should someone be obliged solely due to where they were born? I'm sure there are many incredibly competent de-throners in Europe, surely they should also get out of their chairs and help?
- scotty79 5y agoUkrainians already dethroned their corrupt system of power. Every post-communist county did that on their own. It can be done. So Russians can do it too. They just need proper motivation. And that motivation for countries that did that was abject poverty that made the people realise that course change is needed.
- vogre 5y ago>Ukrainians already dethroned their corrupt system of power. No they haven't https://ti-ukraine.org/en/news/no-progress-ukraine-s-result-in-the-corruption-perceptions-index-2021/ https://ti-ukraine.org/en/news/no-progress-ukraine-s-result-...
- scotty79 5y agoWhat does that supposed to prove? They got rid of Russia sponsored corrupt dictators, had a bit of politicsl turmoil after that. They got their first good president in 2019. Then there was pandemics that raised the level of corruption in nearly all countries. Especially those weaker in that department. And you are going to judge what system of power Ukraine has based on 2021 datapoint? How quickly did your country got rid of corruption that plagued it? It's a process that just stars with replacing corrupt system of power. You need to adjust whole public sector after that. It can take decades.
- sergeykish 5y agoBecause that's their state, their responsibility. And it has happened before in USSR/Russian Empire, hunger is a key.