5 ms·
> In my opinion, these changes are effectively supply-chain attacks in their execution. That would make them bad regardless of how correct their expressed posit
by ajross 5y ago
> In my opinion, these changes are effectively supply-chain attacks in their execution. That would make them bad regardless of how correct their expressed positions are about the Ukraine war.
Well, yeah. War is bad. On the spectrum of war badness, obviously, these pranks are pretty mild. But they're bad. It's a bad situation. When at war, people are forced to do bad things to prevent worse things. That's why starting wars is very bad.
Now, sure, you can argue about the semantics about "who" is at war, or whether these npm authors are "really" at war, or why they "think" they're at war, or whether they "should" be at war. You could also get into a discussion about whether or not this tactic is effective (and I'd agree it's hurting more than helping, btw). Go nuts.
But that doesn't change the fact that this is an action in support of a war effort. In wars, principled stands don't win. If you want a particular outcome, you have to pick a side.
- jollybean 5y ago"principled stands don't win." Fighting against bad actors is definitely a 'principled decision'. Ignoring the situation and not taking action is an 'unprincipled decision'. Though it might disguised as principled action, on the basis of supporting some other principle, such 'open source', but ignoring one at the expense of another implies serious lack of self awareness. This war, plus COVID, and the recently released documents indicating a planned invasion of Taiwan (though we don't know for sure) - represent major geopolitical shift of the order of WW1/WW2/End of Cold War, the stakes and consequences are enormous.
- ajross 5y agoThat's sort of a semantic argument. To be clear: I was contrasting "choosing a side" (in this case by senselessly pranking your npm customers) as being a "practical" choice, vs. the "principled" stand taken to avoid the conflict out of a general sense of open source decorum. Obviously in some sense all decisions are based on "principle". And the point is that it's a war. We've crossed the "bad things are going to happen" Rubicon already. You can't make principled arguments like that against people who have chosen to engage in a war out of the hope or desire for one side to win. They already did that moral calculus. It's like telling someone they shouldn't defend their home because pacifism is more important. You might be right, but you won't change anyone's mind.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hulitu 5y ago> But that doesn't change the fact that this is an action in support of a war effort. In wars, principled stands don't win. If you want a particular outcome, you have to pick a side. I picked a side. I will take care that npm is not installed on my computers. Take your political sh*t out of my computer.
- ajross 5y agoPerfect segue to that famous Clausewitz quote! The premise behind your position is clearly that "politics" is some kind of meaningless distraction to the "real" business of shipping software. But... isn't that backwards? It's a war. People picked a side. The idea that unilateral military invasion is merely "politics"[1] is... very strange to lots of people. [1] In the sense of triviality you clearly intended, c.f. Clausewitz again.
- azangru 5y ago> I will take care that npm is not installed on my computers Easy to say if you are not a frontend engineer.
- jacobsenscott 5y agoBut none of these people picked a side in any of the other currently ongoing unjust occupations, or any of those in the recent past. So clearly you don't need to pick a side.
- efitz 5y agoI think you have it completely backwards. You should not involve yourself in any war that you don’t personally want to fight and maybe die in. You do NOT have to take a side. You can oppose the war, or one or both sides, even vocally, without entangling yourself in the war. If you choose to become an actor in a war, then you also open yourself up to being attacked. There is only one kind of actor in a war- combatant. Consider the maintainer who did the “delete all files on servers with Russian IP addresses.” This could be construed as an act of war against Russia. Would Russia be wrong to commit acts of war against this person? If the server performed some life critical task like operating hospital equipment or air traffic control or whatever, this change could have resulted in loss of life (so many mistakes in using JavaScript in such cases but set that aside for a moment). If lives were lost as a result, would Russia be wrong to use lethal force against the maintainer? Disclaimer (sad that you have to add this these days; it should go without saying): I only use this as an example. I think Putin is a thug and I think that it goes against most westerners’ values, mine included, for nation states to preemptively invade other nation states. I’m not apologizing for or justifying any act by Russia. I have deep sympathy for people in Ukraine who just want to live their lives and not be killed or have their stuff destroyed.
- rosndo 5y ago>Would Russia be wrong to commit acts of war against this person? >If lives were lost as a result, would Russia be wrong to use lethal force against the maintainer? Yeah, unless they want to admit that they’ve been waging war against the entire western world by allowing their homegrown ransomware groups to operate with impunity. If we go by your logic, Western countries should have turned Moscow into a giant glass parking lot after NotPetya, a destructive wiper worm released by the Russian government targeting the entire world. Luckily you’re alone with your thinking.
- efitz 5y agoApparently not, guy got swatted. [1] And there are levels of warfare between "nothing" and "nuclear", in case you hadn't noticed. And North Korea and China are doing state-sponsored attacks against US targets, commercial and government and military. It's not clear to me that NoPetya was state sponsored, it's ransomware. The RF is not a bastion of law enforcement and justice; I agree that they do a terrible job of controlling organized crime activities, both cyber and non-cyber. [1] https://www.vice.com/en/article/dypeek/open-source-sabotage-node-ipc-wipe-russia-belraus-computers https://www.vice.com/en/article/dypeek/open-source-sabotage-...
- fauigerzigerk 5y ago>Well, yeah. War is bad You're implying that wars have no rules. This is very much not true, not legally and not morally. You should read the 4th Geneva Convention to disabuse yourself of this dangerous misconception: https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/INTRO/380 https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/INTRO/380 >In wars, principled stands don't win And excessively unprincipled stands can get you sent to The Hague to be prosecuted for war crimes. Now, I'm not saying that deleting some files is a war crime. What I'm saying is that your reasoning for why it is legitimate is flawed. I even doubt that you would agree with your own reasoning given some other examples. E.g., would you not agree that while we can ask McDonalds to stop doing business in Russia, it would be a crime for them to start poisoning their Russian customers?
- AnonCoward4 5y ago> E.g., would you not agree that while we can ask McDonalds to stop doing business in Russia, it would be a crime for them to start poisoning their Russian customers? In the current climate I am not sure anymore that people would disagree with poisoning Russians. Here in Germany they started to purge everything Russian (except people) and also agitating against Russians in general. It feels like we learned nothing from WW2. From what I've seen there seem to be worldwide movements in that regard, that are even overboard for cold war propaganda. edit: added "except people"
- z1nc 5y agoI've seen a few people in the media specify that the war's about Putin's aggression, rather than Russian aggression. But I doubt that they're the majority. Russophobia sells better. We've got people vandalizing businesses [1] and sending threats in the US as well. That doesn't help anyone in Ukraine, if that's really their goal. It certainly doesn't affect Russia's economy if a restaurant in another country takes a dive. The point of the sanctions is to hurt Russia's government (and therefore their military). There's a cost to sanctions as well for Russian citizens who have nothing to do with the war, but I've yet to see an alternative solution beyond escalating the conflict. [1] https://www.axios.com/russian-businesses-us-vandalism-threats-bdde1c92-d661-48d5-9157-c540964b00fb.html https://www.axios.com/russian-businesses-us-vandalism-threat...
- DocTomoe 5y agoYour argument creates dangerous implications. If a programmer creates targeted malware as an act of war - wouldn't that make him a valid military target? Would Russia be legitimised to carpet bomb wherever that programmer is supposed to live in retaliation? If not, would they be legitimised to capture and execute him - because he certainly isn't a legitimate combatant?
- sokoloff 5y agoI surely wouldn’t bet my life that the targeted country would consider it a mere prank.