4 ms·
>I doubt Putin has the balls to use nukes. That's a very bold claim to make. What is that based on?
by gruez 5y ago
>I doubt Putin has the balls to use nukes.
That's a very bold claim to make. What is that based on?
- yks 5y agoHe does not have balls to sit close to his top generals and cronies.
- Giorgi 5y agoIt is based on Turkey shooting down Russian jet without any consequences.
- gruez 5y agoIt's one thing to shoot down a russian jet that was allegedly flying into turkish airspace (despite the kremlin claiming otherwise). It's a whole other thing to declare a no-fly zone above ukraine and actively shooting down jets.
- emteycz 5y agoWhy Turkey can defend its airspace and Ukraine can't do the same together with its international partners, in a manner similar to EU airspace protection for example?
- gruez 5y agoYou're not arguing against an impartial observer. You're arguing against putin. You seriously think that putin is going to be persuaded by this type of lawyering? I think even to a layperson it's fairly obvious that the two represents two very different actions, and very different levels of escalation when it comes to their relations.
- Giorgi 5y agoPutin did nothing when Russian jet was shot down.
- giraffe_lady 5y agoThe main practical concern here is just that russia can launch planes and missiles from inside russia. If you want them to stop you're going to have to bomb some airbases. Or you're going to honor the border I guess? Are they free to bomb civilians as long as it launches from their side? Even the best planes will get shot down if you give the other side enough chances, is nato going to allow that? Anyway where even is the border at 50k feet? How many conflicts have started because a pilot accidentally entered another country's airspace? Or at least that the other country claimed they had.
- Giorgi 5y agoNo fly zone does not concern to Missiles, yes you honor border and you can't bomb anything without invading airspace. >How many conflicts have started because a pilot accidentally entered another country's airspace? Or at least that the other country claimed they had. Exactly 0.
- tchalla 5y ago> without any consequences Are you sure there were no consequences?
- Giorgi 5y agoYes I am sure.
- baq 5y agoHe is rational, just misinformed. Dude is scared shitless of losing and he knows he can’t win this game. He will pretend he’s willing to though, because it works.
- WJW 5y agoMaybe, though it is still to be seen. One of the more "interesting" sub-games in the bigger war is how much support NATO is willing to give to Ukraine. The English sending MANPADS is apparently fine, even though Russia said beforehand that they would regard the delivery of weapons an act of war. The Polish jets were a step too far. USA sending over drones (sorry, "loitering munitions") and anti tank weapons is apparently still OK. The same logic that works against the West has also been working against Putin: "what are you going to do about it; escalate into WW3?"
- Ma8ee 5y agoThe problem with the Polish jets was apparently that they planned to fuel and load them from a German airbase. It wouldn't really matter that the planes only were flown by Ukraine pilots. The German airbase would still be a legitime military target. And then NATO would have to respond when cruise missiles started flying into some of their member states.
- WJW 5y agoPoland is already a NATO state, the Russians could just bomb the Polish airbase instead even if they didn't go through Germany.
- Ma8ee 5y agoThe significance was that they needed to be based in a NATO country, and not in Ukraine. I agree that it wouldn’t make much of a difference if it was Poland or Germany.
- dragonwriter 5y agoThe problem with the jets is that everyone involved thinks that they are a bad idea whose military utility isn't worth the degree of provocation no matter what route they are supplies through, but no one wanting to be the country to say no to Ukraine about it; all the maneuvering was about countries making it so someone else would have to be the one to say no. The US finally said no to the specific plan, and put forth the general rationale for the more general no when it did so. (OTOH, the tolerance for acts that might be seen as provocation by Russia among NATO countries—at least those on the Eastern flank—is going up rapidly, with Estonia and Lithuania calling for a NATO-enforces No Fly Zone, and Poland hold-my-beering them and calling for a NATO peacekeeping force in Ukraine.)