5 ms·
Many sibling comments dismiss this as a non-issue if you've ever actually tried an alternative layout. As a Dvorak user on macOS for ~12 years, I do believe it
by cyounkins 5y ago
Many sibling comments dismiss this as a non-issue if you've ever actually tried an alternative layout.
As a Dvorak user on macOS for ~12 years, I do believe it's an issue. I use "Dvorak - QWERTY ⌘" as my daily driver and while it works for most applications, it's infuriating for those it doesn't. Sometimes keyboard shortcuts are control/option based without using command, so it's still in Dvorak mode.
In Gimp, the New Image shortcut is ⌘-N, which doesn't work. I have to press physical L, which is the key for N in Dvorak. This is common. The apps seem to do some lower-level key detection. https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gimp/-/issues/3352 https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gimp/-/issues/3352 I think Fusion 360 does similar, though I don't have it installed at the moment. I have also had trouble with remove desktop applications, which is kind of to be expected but another downside.
- ajford 5y agoThis is where programable keyboards win out when using alternative layouts. When the layout is at the hardware level, the OS only ever sees the actual keycode for the N key, instead of an "L" which is later transcribed into "N" by the OS's layout map.